Which is the better woods gun?

aterry33

Member
Joined
Mar 22, 2009
Messages
1,037
Reaction score
28
Location
Charlotte, NC
S&W Model 29 4"

S&W Model 27 5"

S&W Model 19 4"

Note that this is an unfair, subjective question, and assume that the gun would not be carried in Alaska or anywhere where Brown Bears would be present.
 
Register to hide this ad
I guess it could depend on what is in the woods. I'd go for one of the 4" ones as I like the shorter barrel revolvers for woods carry. Probably your 29 would be my preference for all critters great and small.

140235855.jpg
 
Interpreting no browns to mean no grizzly either, I'd say the 19 would make a fine woods gun.
 
Of those three, the 4" 29 followed by the 19.

There's no advantage of a .357 N frame over the 19 that offsets its greater weight and size.

/c
 
19 loaded with buffalo bore 180 grain hardcast or something similiar.

After I put that load clean through a 1/4" stainless steel solid plate out of a 16" barrel rifle, my respect for the .357 changed dramaticly. The weight of the 19 is far easier to carry around. I carry a 3" 66 myself. But typically load with 158 grain hollow points from BB. Also pretty impressive ballistics.
 
Last edited:
Any will do.

The most dangerous creature you will ever meet in the woods is man. That's not to say the woods are totally safe, but it's a lot safer than any city.

I've seen other forums where idiots recommend monster guns - 460 calibers and up - as if dinosaurs still roamed the earth. City folks make me laugh. I've roamed West Virginia woods since I was about 12 or so, and never carried anything larger than a sizable Bowie knife

Chances are you'll NEVER be in danger from animals. You might have to worry about pot growers (most of them are just stupid hippies) or, maybe, dumb rednecks, (although they tend to avoid the woods).

The only truly dangerous animals will be a black bear, (attacks are very, very rare) or California cougars (And frankly, who cares - they just eat runners & yuppie liberals).

What I worry about is escaped/semi-domesticated male deer (bucks) filled with testosterone (deer farms are becoming more popular). This is the "domesticated" wild animal responsible for more human fatalities than all other "domesticated" wild animals combined. These critters will attack you in the suburbs.

Bucks and rabid animals (again, very unlikely) are about the only worry you have.

You'll also hear about danger from wolves, but that's crap. Wild dogs are more dangerous, but that's also mostly crap. And you can kill a snake with stick.

Sorry for the long post, but I've seen this sort of thread several times before, and most of the people who comment have never set foot in the woods in their life.

However, I do recommend at least a .357 magnum. A testosterone laden buck is almost as dangerous as a meth-brained junkie, and a .357 hollow point will generally do the job on both.
 
4" 29 loaded with Buffalo Bore heavy 44 Special 250 Keiths at a 1000 fps.

Easy on the recoil only weighs 6ozs more than the 19 which is limited in its capacity to fire "fullhouse 357s" and that 44 still speaks with great authority even if its' only Special.
 
Model 29, 4" is my choice. I also have a 3" 29 and a 3" 696 .44 Special. Any of these are fine choices for the woods. I prefer 4" bbls or shorter.
Sonny
 
29. The 44 can be loaded down enough for anything. The 357 can't be loaded up enough to deal with anything.
 
I'm thinking an education is in order here... maybe you misread the article.

Really? Brown bears aren't the only thing in this Country that I'd rather have a 44 for sir. The original post left plenty of room for those other possibilities in my reading of it. A 357 is kind of light for moose, black bears, etc, in my opinion. Educate me on what I missed and you took from that post of his?
 
I have all listed and switch off with my mood. One you didnt list is a model 24-3 4" that gets my top vote. Its lighter with the pencil barrel and shorter clyinder than either the 29 or 25. Also put on the maga grips, works fine for me. Its a mountain gun, yet I dont own a mountain gun. Any mountain gun would be nice.
 
I like the 4 inch Model 29 and the 4 inch Model 27 (I know you got a 5 inch) With a 44 mag you can carry 300gr bullets and standard 240s to hunt or defend with and you can shoot shotshells for food if you like. RCBS makes dies to cut off 30-30 cases and form them as a shot shell in 44 mag. They hold 1/2 oz shot. 44 mag is very versatil and usefull over a wide range of uses. For the Model 27 that thing has skull penetrating power. Dont think its a .38 it aint. Outa your 5 inch its just that much better. However the 44 gives you more bullet for the money.
 
Back
Top