I had the same experience with the rebate back in August,-- denied by Smith & Wesson Rebate Center twice, after sending everything that they asked for (twice), which Grabagun had sent to me. I did not pursue it any further, just chalked it up against S&W, because I was going to buy the gun anyway, with or without the rebate (the three magazines), and I did not expect or want Grabagun to take up S&W's slack. But I will not pay any attention to, nor give any credence to, any future S&W rebate offers. I will buy more guns from Grabagun.com.