Grip Identification And An Ugly Model 36

cone2245

Member
Joined
Jul 5, 2020
Messages
17
Reaction score
21
Location
Texas
Howdy Folks,

A while back I snagged this ugly as hell Model 36 no dash from a pawn shop on the rough side of San Antone for $158 OTD. Figured the ugly duckling would be worth a gamble. It was pretty obvious the gun was refinished and some previous owner did a little high class custom wood work on the original stocks by adding finger grooves and coarse checkering. I discovered while cleaning and diagnosing that the finish was actually paint! Wiped right off with Hoppes or alcohol. I had to buy $30 of replacement screws and a couple minor internal parts. Mechanically, she's pretty sound with excellent timing and a great trigger. The hammer spur was broken off and pretty jagged but a few passes with a file made it good enough for government work. I slapped a BK grip adapter on it and put it through a few boxes of ammo and drills. This ugly ducking turned out to be my best shooting J Frame. It rides in my pocket pretty often and the black paint finish is starting to wear from use.

GhettoGat1.jpg
Ghetto Gat2.jpg


During a trip to East Texas I stopped by a small gun shop and dug around the odds and ends. $35 got me an Uncle Mike's boot grip (now rides on the ugly Model 36) and these wood finger groove grips. They were inside a Herrett's Shooting Stars box but I am skeptical they are Herrett's- have not found much reference to a similar model in my research. They fit my hand pretty well and my Model 38 perfectly, but they don't quite fit the ugly Model 36 that well.

Who do you fine folks think made these finger grooves? Any suggestions for a cheap finish for the ugly gun when the paint is all worn off?

S-WHerritt1.jpgHerrits2.jpgherrits3.jpg
 
Register to hide this ad
Howdy Folks,

Any suggestions for a cheap finish for the ugly gun when the paint is all worn off?


Parkerizing might the least expensive?

Personally, I would opt for a decent bluing job. Something like the raw orphan gets adopted, sent to finishing school & becomes the suave, sophisticated (can't believe I spelled that word right! LOL!) gentleman.

A good bluing job would allow for a good "you won't believe this story" moment, IMO. ;)
 
Believe me- I am beyond proud and tickled to have gotten this gun back in action and shooting so well. Saving the refinishing money to shoot the hell outta it is pretty tempting.... it really loves my wadcutter handloads and PPU's LSWC HP.



Being that this was a cheap gun, my stingy German roots ain't keen on spending a lot on refinishing. Options I've considered were send off for hot blue, cerakote, or parkerizing or DIY engine enamel, or cold blue. Engine enamel and cold blue ain't the most durable, but will do the job.


Maybe I need to keep the gun's inner city roots alive with a fresh coat of paint every year.
 
Spend the refinishing money on ammo and shoot the snot out of it!

Exactly ! I never have understood refinishing-
On a collectible it decreases value
On a well worn shooter it doesn’t increase value or make it shoot any better.
I like the old worn looking orphans and would have jumped on that for the price.

I can’t remember the last time I saw a S&W revolver in any condition for less than $250
 
Exactly ! I never have understood refinishing-
On a collectible it decreases value
On a well worn shooter it doesn’t increase value or make it shoot any better.
I like the old worn looking orphans and would have jumped on that for the price.

I can’t remember the last time I saw a S&W revolver in any condition for less than $250


Agreed- this gat will never be an investment piece. Its a beater and carry gun. I only want a finish to provide a modicum of protection from rust. Refinishing is low priority- seeing how many empty Copenhagen cans it can send flying off a dead Live Oak stump is a much higher priority.
 
I agree those aren't likely Herrett's. Probably Mustang.


I believe you are correct- found similar examples while researching Mustang grips this afternoon. Had never heard of that outfit before. The shop also had a couple of their odd snap together K frame grips in the odds and ends box.
 
You could rust blue it. Forum member Shotguncoach has been bringing back "basket case" revolvers, and I believe he has boiled and carded a few of them. It turns out great and is inexpensive to boot.
 
I’m having little to no luck enlarging the thumbnails, but what I can do with the best picture of your finger groove grips surely suggests the old Mustang grips to me. I had a pair several years ago I put on a pre War HFT. I’m still kicking myself for allowing a friend to talk me out of them. :(
Froggie
 
You could rust blue it. Forum member Shotguncoach has been bringing back "basket case" revolvers, and I believe he has boiled and carded a few of them. It turns out great and is inexpensive to boot.


Yes, rust bluing is an option. Being a DIY country boy I looked into rust bluing. Seems easy and cheap enough to do in the city apartment or deer camp with a small gun.
 
My vote is for Jay Scott on the finger groove stocks.

attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • Jay Scott cat J square.jpg
    Jay Scott cat J square.jpg
    66.9 KB · Views: 23
Back
Top