Is Sarah15 still in business? Extremely important update !!

Status
Not open for further replies.
My dealing with Sarah15 was as follows. 
 
I had decided to sell 3 guns in mid 2022 — all very nice, not perfect but hardly anything is -- two 3.5” pre 27 pintos in their gold boxes: one formerly owned by & I purchased from Gary Garbrecht in 2004, one formerly owned by & I purchased from Harrison Carroll in 2005, and a 4” inch first year model 57 in its original velour lined case and about a dozen boxes of collector ammo.
 
Based on a recommendation from one of our long-term Forum and S&WCA members and a good and very trustworthy friend of mine, I sent them to this gunbroker seller in question for him to offer on his ‘for sale’ table at the S&WCA Symposium coming up in Concord, NC or on GB if needed.   He acknowledged receipt of all of them bragged on how great they all were, and he did sell them fairly fast at the Symposium on or GB. 
 
Some of the numbers he got for them were somewhat vague, but I didn’t question it, I trusted him, he was an elected officer with the S&WCA, which made me think he was trustworthy and my friend recommended him.   
 
He was very slow to pay me, lots of excuses, health issues, etc., so I tried to be patient & work with him, believing I was dealing with a professional, as so far he had been.
 
At one point I envisioned never getting paid, I had no contract, was working from a position of weakness, good luck to me in front of a judge pleading my case.  I finally called the friend that recommended him asking if he was aware of any of these alleged problems I was having to hear as to why I was not getting paid, then things started happening as I’m pretty sure he put some major pressure on him. He even said if JB never pays me, he would out of his pocket and get it from JB himself.
 
It was almost two months from the date initially he told me he had paid me until I actually got paid, it was in the range of $15,000, wasn’t much of an accurate accounting breakdown either like I’ve gotten from other online sellers I’ve used in the past.

I’m not owed any money now & glad that I’m not.   I won't be sending him anything whatsoever to be selling for me under any name he uses to camouflage himself in the future.
 
 
Just wanted chime in here as someone who was affected by this situation.

On August 17th I was contacted by Sarah15 and they encouraged me to consign some firearms with them as Jim was going to be driving around the country personally picking up other consignee firearms. The incentive would be to save some $ on overnight shipping and insurance to Wisconsin. I have documented that Jim was going to make approximately 10 other stops during that trip.

At the end of August Jim and his son stopped by my house, picked up 14 handguns and 1 long gun, signed a mutual contract for consignment with me, shook my hand, and were off to the next stop.

All but 1 firearm successfully sold by the beginning of October. At that time, per our contract, I should have been paid out within 2 weeks of the new buyer inspection period. I asked them to relist the last gun asap but for weeks it went unlisted. Finally it was listed and I presume sold in late November.

In the beginning of December I got the same notice others received saying that my payout of approximately $11k-12k would not be able to be payed out as it would be viewed as preferential payment due to a lawsuit against Sarah15/Jim. I did my due diligence and found out that suit was filed in Wisconsin Jan 2024.

I’ve been promised that I’d be updated promptly and frequently on the case progress but I’ve had to be proactive in that regard. My legal counsel has been engaged as well as the moderators of this forum. The SWCA board is also aware of the details pertinent to my situation personally. I encourage any other people affected or concerned by this matter to contact the SWCA board and Dave Thinnes the gentleman who started this thread.

Be safe
SVT28

WOW, this and the other posts above, are just SHOCKING!!

First off, I want to apologize to folks here for my earlier post where I basically took up for Mr Brewster! I definitely want it known that I did so not knowing ANYTHING about this situation! What I said was the truth as I knew it at the time. This situation is unacceptable. I feel so sorry for all those that have been affected by it! The troubling thing, to me, is that it was allowed to go on for so long! It seems like a bunch of folks could have been spared this grief if what was going on would have come out sooner. I know that’s a difficult thing. It seems MANY folks thought they might be the only ones being harmed, and therefore didn’t want to hurt his reputation. But, because of their respect for others (like honest people do), now many more people have been hurt. I wish this thread had come out much sooner.

Swt70601, was the Trotter Collection sold on Gun Broker, and if it was, were they made aware of the situation soon after the collection sold and the former owners not being paid? I mean $440K is a very substantial sum, and a YEAR is a long time in my opinion!

I am completely disappointed with Gun Broker. How can they continue to let someone sell on their platform when so many have not received their compensation for previously sold items? I realize THEY probably didn’t loose a penny, but come on, they should have done better and sooner!
Larry
 
This is just one reason why I prefer to do transactions in person only...I have bought guns successfully from members here which were not FTF, and I have had a very few which turned sour...To my relief. I lost no money in those last few mentioned, but it made me reluctant to try it again...I have never sold a gun over the internet, and never will...Gunbroker to me is just a reference source, nothing else...I have never bid on anything in an auction of any kind, and due to reading reports like these, don't look for any raised hands from me in the future...:(...Ben
 
I’m reminded of a lot of bank fraud cases where a teller, usually a young female, borrows some cash from the till, covers it with bank’s cash the next day, and it steamrolls into a huge amount in a short time.

I don’t know this guy, and I’ve been here a while. Above my paygrade, I guess. But I can see how this happens. Not excusing it, but I wouldn’t go the pitchforks and torches route yet.
 
Unfortunately, I am the fool that recommended Jim to a couple of previous posters.(including the 440k one ).I’ve never been more confident nor more wrong about a recommendation in my life. I’m still shocked at this outcome. I must admit , it’s made me re-evaluate how I’d sell my collection when the time comes and honestly killed a lot of my enthusiasm about the hobby , Tulsa , the Symposium, etc. Like some have said , shocking and very , very disappointing.
 
Unfortunately, I am the fool that recommended Jim to a couple of previous posters.(including the 440k one ).I’ve never been more confident nor more wrong about a recommendation in my life. I’m still shocked at this outcome. I must admit , it’s made me re-evaluate how I’d sell my collection when the time comes and honestly killed a lot of my enthusiasm about the hobby , Tulsa , the Symposium, etc. Like some have said , shocking and very , very disappointing.

I for one can certainly understand and appreciate how you are feeling. There was now way you or anyone else could have predicted this happening, nor can you or anyone else predict the future or the outcome of this situation.
But I know that this situation had no involvement with the SWCA, the symposium, the incredible Board and members, other than the fact that Mr. Brewster holds, or held, a position on that Board.
I’m sure the SWCA Board and its members had no involvement and are quite concerned by what has come to light. Tulsa was an excellent symposium and Concord will be the same, if not better.
I hope you’ll consider reevaluating your enthusiasm for the SWCA.
 
Last edited:
I for one can certainly understand and appreciate how you are feeling. There was now way you or anyone else could have predicted this happening, nor can you or anyone else predict the future or the outcome of this situation.
But I know that this situation had no involvement with the SWCA, the symposium, the incredible Board and members, other than the fact that Mr. Brewster holds, or held, a position on that Board.
I’m sure the SWCA Board and its members had no involvement and are quite embarrassed by what has come to light. Tulsa was an excellent symposium and Concord will be the same, if not better.
I hope you’ll consider reevaluating your enthusiasm for the SWCA.

Yessir , please don’t misunderstand me. My disappointment is due to these events and I hold the S&WCA in no way responsible. It’s an amazing organization with great members. My disappointment is due to my guilt for leading my friends astray , losing a good friend , and just the fact that the whole thing is a giant bummer.
I plan to be at the Symposium in NC.
 
I for one can certainly understand and appreciate how you are feeling. There was now way you or anyone else could have predicted this happening, nor can you or anyone else predict the future or the outcome of this situation.
But I know that this situation had no involvement with the SWCA, the symposium, the incredible Board and members, other than the fact that Mr. Brewster holds, or held, a position on that Board.
I’m sure the SWCA Board and its members had no involvement and are quite concerned by what has come to light. Tulsa was an excellent symposium and Concord will be the same, if not better.
I hope you’ll consider reevaluating your enthusiasm for the SWCA.

I’m sure you’re correct….unfortunately, him holding a position on the Board is probably one of the reasons why many folks trusted him so highly and didn’t think twice about doing business with him! I am a very trusting person, doing business with folks with only a handshake. I know a lot of folks on this forum who do things the same way, and I absolutely HATE having to change my way of doing things.:mad:
Larry
 
No One Wants To Admit They've Been Scammed

Kudos to Thinnes for bringing this to light and to the others for telling us your experiences, probably just the tip of the iceberg. No one wants to admit they’ve been scammed.

I seem to recall the Bernie Madoff story, where friends of his that were scammed by him and they trusted him, were reluctant to come forward, probably similar situation here.
 
I received a phone message from Bill Cross this morning. Rather than face an ethics panel appointed from our Board of Directors, James Brewster resigned from the board effective immediately.
A clarification:
It is my understanding that Jim Brewster has resigned from membership in the SWCA, and by default, from his position as Secretary.





I’m sure you’re correct….unfortunately, him holding a position on the Board is probably one of the reasons why many folks trusted him so highly and didn’t think twice about doing business with him!
For the record-
Jim Brewster became the Secretary of the SWCA in 2018.
His reputation as an effective seller was already well established by that time. I do agree that his position as Secretary of the SWCA probably helped his acquisition of clients- it certainly did not hurt.

He has never been the Treasurer of the SWCA.

This whole affair saddens me greatly. I hate to see a friend crash and burn, and I am certainly sympathetic to the consignors who have not been made whole.
When all is finally said and done, I certainly hope you all are made completely whole.
Godspeed.
 
Incredible to think

Two ,three days ago he was soliciting business ON THIS THREAD!!
Thank you for the kind words everyone, especially Lee. On the bright side I have met many kind, decent honorable men the last several days that I am now able to call friends.

I was never able to attend a Symposium because it conflicted with another big annual event for me. But now I feel compelled to attend. I have immensely enjoyed the Forum and interacting with like-minded Smith crazies.

I have already given up hope of receiving any money. But I promise you my efforts to rectify this will not stop until full resolution of these matters is completed.

As a result of hard work, a great spouse, and God’s graces, I will financially survive this. But there is an expecting father involved here that consigned guns to pay for out of pocket medical bills associated with his baby’s imminent birth. Think about that.

I will also say our board was outstanding in dealing with this. Thank you.
I am also fortunate that I held back more valuable guns.

I will post more as I hear back from the agencies I have contacted. Dave
 
You have some nice firearms and I have sent you an email response. Obviously you arent going to do business with me, but …. etc.

I actually felt embarrassed and somehow bad and wrong for some reason. I even thought I should try to smooth things out with him in my 2nd post.

I still can’t wrap my head around all of this. Again. Ironically this Monday I was able to make contact about a consignment and Tuesday, (four days ago,) I promptly got an email response. “We would love to sell your firearms.” I attached that email in my first post.

How could anyone agree to sell my firearm,(s) with no intention of paying me for it/them?

I’ll again thank Dave for starting this thread when he did. I need to thank Mike again for his almost instant email response to me regarding my first post.

Jim
 
Two ,three days ago he was soliciting business ON THIS THREAD!!


This is the part that I find the most disturbing and disappointing. You are sending out form letters saying under the advice of counsel, you are unable to pay any consignor, WHILE you are looking for more consignors. That’s very disturbing.
 
This thread is heartbreaking. I feel terrible for the folks that have been impacted by their potential financial loss and breach of trust by this individual. I sincerely hope you somehow can be made whole.

Thank you to those that have exposed this dishonest businessman and potentially saved others from a similar fate.

I'm now left rethinking this hobby. Sarah15 was one of the people I had on a list for my wife to potentially consign with if something suddenly happened to me.

I've never purchased a firearm with future profit potential as the deciding factor. I have always purchased for sporting purposes or because they are models I admire and are nostalgic to me. Having said that, I would never want to lose my entire investment and leave nothing to my family.

This feels like a huge wet blanket. Maybe I'm just in over my head.
 
…I've never purchased a firearm with future profit potential as the deciding factor. I have always purchased for sporting purposes or because they are models I admire and are nostalgic to me. Having said that, I would never want to lose my entire investment and leave nothing to my family.

This feels like a huge wet blanket. Maybe I'm just in over my head.

I hear you, and I too am sadden to read this. I do not minimize the effects of this incident on others who appear to have been harmed, but there is the old saw that “one bad apple doesn’t spoil the whole barrel.” It’s true. Please don’t let this spoil the enjoyment of your weapons and your hobby.
 
Mr. Brewster's use of the term "preferential payment" would indicate that a petition in bankruptcy may be imminent. Preferential payments are those made by a debtor to a creditor within 90 days of filing for bankruptcy. My guess would be that the victims of Mr. Brewster would most likely be in the unsecured class with any recovery minimal at best.
 
attachment.php



...and to think that this week I was thinking of consigning a few firearms through a local auction company. I've bought from them and all seemed good, but this thread is some kind of wake-up call.:eek:

Good luck to all those owed money.
 

Attachments

  • Escalated.jpg
    Escalated.jpg
    43.6 KB · Views: 731
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top