Advice on vinyl plank flooring----

Maddog 521

Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2007
Messages
3,916
Reaction score
3,999
Location
Texas
We had slab leak and we have to install new flooring so I'm looking for suggestions.
There was Pergo here when we bought the place and it's been here for 12 years. We've looked a many brands that are available. Does anyone here have any advice to give on our project?
Thanks
 
Register to hide this ad
When I remodeled our master bedroom in 2020, I installed Luxury Vinyl.



IMG_2659.webp


IMG_0644.webp


I'm really a hard wood floor guy, but this stuff looks and performs perfectly.

Bulletproof!

You have to follow their instructions for prep and underlament.
 
Do Not use Laminated Bamboo Flooring ...
It warps , swells and shrinks ... We were lied to by the suppliers about how good it is ... it sucks rocks .just avoid the product .
A good Vinyl flooring would be a good choice .
Gary
 
I did half my house using the mid level vinyl plank flooring available from Home Depot. 26 years, 2 teenagers, 7 dogs, and 3 grandchildren later there is exactly one nick in it where a bicycle fell over and the tube of the handlebars fell just right to scoop out a nick about 1/4" across. I've been very pleased with it.

With the right installation tools it goes down pretty quickly. I used a ryobi battery powered 4" circular saw to do the cutting and trimming right where I was working. IIRC I went through 2 batteries and 1 saw blade per room.
 
Agreed about bamboo. Mine didn't warp, but the cherry stained veneer is about one molecule thick and comes off if you just look at it.
 
I did half my house using the mid level vinyl plank flooring available from Home Depot. 26 years, 2 teenagers, 7 dogs, and 3 grandchildren later there is exactly one nick in it where a bicycle fell over and the tube of the handlebars fell just right to scoop out a nick about 1/4" across. I've been very pleased with it.

With the right installation tools it goes down pretty quickly. I used a ryobi battery powered 4" circular saw to do the cutting and trimming right where I was working. IIRC I went through 2 batteries and 1 saw blade per room.


The flooring I used (above) you just scribe/score it and snap the piece in-half. I didn't require any power tools. The planks snap and lock together. It takes a little finesse but they LOCK very tightly.

I did 380 sq feet. The boxes weighted a total of 1350 pounds. Surprisingly heavy. They have to acclimate for 48 hours. It was a job unloading them from my truck, stacking them around in an adjoining room.

Then carry them again to the installation room, as I went. I could have used a gopher.....LOL



,
 
Last edited:
Like Warden Ross, we went with LVP (luxury vinyl plank) over twelve years ago for our basement flooring. It's amazing. Very low maintenance and it looks great. And if our basement ever floods (heaven forbid) it's easy to take up, dry things off, and put it down again. Doesn't warp, fade, crack, etc. We've been very pleased with it.

T3EXdBu.webp
 
How does the LVP hold up to dining room chair legs and dragging furniture across it? That seems to be our main challenge. We have wood-tone porcelain and it's been good except fot the above.

Oh, and dog messes.
 
So far....after five-years...it appears indestructible.

Quigley does four-paw-drive full power slides frequently. No scratches anywhere. Heavy furniture hasn't phased it.

Wifey's makeup table and chair hasn't done anything. She do a lot of the makeup thing too.

I have 150 pounds of benchrest gear that I two-wheel across it twice each week.

It locks together so tight, I believe you could line a swimming pool with it.

Now our flooring is the premium example. Lifetime warranty. The planks even have a rubber-like backing on their bottom. Very quiet walk.

,
 
We needed to replace the flooring in a cabin we inherited. I looked around and after asking enough questions settled on a Masonite product. I figured that if Masonite was as tough as it was their flooring should be as well. I got a great deal on a discontinued green pine colored flooring. I asked the guy how tough it was and he proceeded to slam a qallon can of paint on a sample. He said the trick was in the sub floor cushion, the Masonite came with a roll of a foam subfloor. He said you need to use this cushion otherwise it wont work right. We followed all the instructions and although at first it seemed kind of hokey, applying a layer of glue to the tongue and using a designed piece of wood to smack the groove of the next piece up against it, it went real well. We used it for at least eight years before we moved on and that flooring looked as good the day we left as when it was installed. Another thing was making sure your subfloor was relatively flat, you can use a leveler if needed or sand down any high spots as I did, it pays to do your prep work. It was real slick, we have been gone from there twelve years now, so it was probably twenty years ago we put that stuff in. It was almost state of the art back then, now everyone has that kind of flooring in their houses, hardwood is a thing of the past.
 
Would be nice if someone made vinyl flooring that looked like wood parquet. Last time I checked, nothing like it was made, Nor is original wood parquet flooring available any longer. No bare floor looks quite as elegant as dark wood parquet.
 
I've been a commercial contractor for over 35 years and we use commercial glue down Luxury Vinyl Plank. If it floods several inches deep in water you can shop vac it and its totally fine. Most do-it-yourself home owners put down floating floors that snap together and are laid over a sheet of plastic and the weight of the furniture hold it in place. If it ever floods, water will be trapped beneath the plastic and floor so you need to pull up the whole floor and re-lay it. I've done dozens of buildings over the years and never had a problem with the luxury glue down floor other than a piece coming unglued occasionally which is easily re-glued. If the floor get damaged you can just use putty knife to pop up the damaged planks and relay them. If a floating floor gets damaged its a pretty big hassle to try to cut up the bad pieces without breaking the spline then snap in new floor and then try to glue it to the adjacent plank.
 
I used luxury vinyl planks that had a foam backing. It was "no long made, bankruptcy" stock. Planks were about 1/4" thick, 7 planks in a bundle was all I wanted to carry with 13 bundles to move. It was a deck converted to a room. The floor was leveled deck boards, 2 layers of 30# tar paper, layer of 1/2" plywood, sanded plywood joints smooth. Snap lock ends and sides were easy to do once I learned the correct technique. A flat block of wood and 22-ounce rubber faced mallet helped joint tightness. The flooring sat on garage floor for 1.5 years before installation on the enclosed room with a/c installed. It was cut a line on the finish side and snap. For notches and cut outs I used a plywood blade (many, many small teeth installed backwards on 5" circle saw or an oscillating door jam saw.

Pergo is expensive and NOT water-proof, bamboo is a joke. Solid vinyl cannot absorb water. "Water resistant" means you have 5 seconds MAXIMUM before things go really wrong. It definitely doesn't work when you have pets, because there will be a pet accident.
 
How does the LVP hold up to dining room chair legs and dragging furniture across it? That seems to be our main challenge. We have wood-tone porcelain and it's been good except fot the above.

Oh, and dog messes.
Use "super sliders" under all furniture. I slide my tables around, my couch and even my 65 inch Solid Cherry TV unit with the 75 inch TV on it. Peel and stick on everything!!! Under the legs of my chest of drawers... they work great.
 
The new home in San Antonio has the glue down LVP in common areas (LR, kitchen, bathrooms, hallway, utility room.) It looks nice and is quiet, comfortable, and easy to clean. I cannot speak to its durability, though, as it is only about 6 months old.
 
I can heartily endorse "Life Proof" vinyl planks sold by Home Depot. It is, indeed, life proof as evidenced by a teenager and four cats doing their level best to destroy it and failing. Great stuff.

Bryan
 
We did a bathroom floor this spring with product from Lowes. Bought it and then read the reviews of the difficulty in installing the stuff. It works and is functional but never again. Check out installation first from several sources.
 
Back
Top