15-8 Heritage, 4 inch nickel, 120 of 200? Any other Heritage collectors?

Joined
Jan 1, 2012
Messages
1,899
Reaction score
2,265
Location
Kansas City
This is my second Heritage. I also have a 25-11. Seller said there were 200 made.

Picked it up today. Pics are from the seller's listing.

Paid $828 before tax and shipping. Seems decent for a low production gun, but the Heritage guns don't seem to appreciate like other guns.

Should dig out my 25-11.

Anyone else collect these?
 

Attachments

  • TYUFdM.jpg
    TYUFdM.jpg
    522.2 KB · Views: 2
  • yM57As.jpg
    yM57As.jpg
    420.8 KB · Views: 1
  • 2RmqUN.webp
    2RmqUN.webp
    70.1 KB · Views: 0
  • sA04zY.jpg
    sA04zY.jpg
    364.1 KB · Views: 0
  • 9dPG0p.jpg
    9dPG0p.jpg
    159.4 KB · Views: 0
  • 9KU1aM.webp
    9KU1aM.webp
    71.2 KB · Views: 0
Register to hide this ad
That was the gun my buddy here in Alabama put on Gunbroker. I looked at that gun before he listed it. Very nice gun!

I did end up talking to someone there. Nice guy.

I didn't expect to win it for $828. Seems cheap for a LNIB gun with only 200 made. Nothing weird about the gun unlike some collectable issued guns.
 
I have a few...

HS-Revolvers-2021-03-28-15-09-59-UTC.jpg


In my defense, the 25-10 is now absent the Altamont stocks in favor of a set of Curt Harlow Myrtle wood Ropers...

25-10-Harlow-2.jpg


Adios,

Pizza Bob
 
$828 is a good deal for any PC revolver IMO.

The Heritage run was pretty neat but kinda fell slightly short of the mark in several areas IMO.
I picked up two of the blue Heritage 17-8's ( pictured below , one wearing Herrets),
in hindsight should have looked harder for a case colored one too! that being said they are nice guns that would have been a homerun if delivered in a wood presentation case with a square butt grip profile wearing a quality reproduction SB pre war checkered Magnas (the tiny retro service stocks were nicely checkered and good quality but are ridiculously small especially on N frames) and last but not least they should have offered each of the PC Heritage guns as a 4" as well, especially the K22, ( maybe 3" and 5" offerings which seem to be in greater demand than 6" ?)
Also, WHY NO RETRO REGISTERED MAGNUM ?
Id have bought one in each barrel length.
The RegMag is probably one of the highest demand models and to this day still no repro offering ???
(Hint in case Lipseys is considering sponsoring a run), The old 4" M&P 22 ( Model 45) is a highly sought after rarity and a fixed sight 4" K frame 22lr woukd probably sell like hotcakes!

The Model 15 Heritage is kind of a head scratcher as all of the rest were styled after their pre war counterparts sans barrel ribs and might have been the only 4"?
(Wasn't the only pre war revolver with a raised barrel rib the Reg Mag ?)
Iirc the PC 15 is the only PC Heritage with a factory post war raised rib barrel style, almost like they had 200 more frames than barrels and someone said, dont we have 200 of the old Model 15-4 barrels downstairs ?
I dont recall if those were the original stocks but if so the the PC 15 is also the only Heritage revolver with off the shelf composite non diamond magnas which supports the theory they might have been an afterthought.

The Heritage series was a great run and stands out as a perfect example of what S&W can accomplish when they put forth the effort, but if they ever decide to undertake such an experiment again ( they should IMO) perhaps focus production more on a small run of the more desirable configurations.
 

Attachments

  • 20250814_125548.webp
    20250814_125548.webp
    2.1 MB · Views: 0
Last edited:
I have a blue & nickel 29, & a blue 24... other than bbl marking & chamber depth, there is no difference between the 24 & 29. Pretty much indistinguishable from Bob's 25-10 too.

"Tapered bbl", thin profile, Mountain Gun XL... whatever you call it, it handles like a 4" bbl with a 6" site radius. Although it is an acquired taste.

"a set of Curt Harlow Myrtle wood Ropers..." those are gorgeous!
 
$828 is a good deal for any PC revolver IMO.

The Heritage run was pretty neat but kinda fell slightly short of the mark in several areas IMO.
I picked up two of the blue Heritage 17-8's ( pictured below , one wearing Herrets),
in hindsight should have looked harder for a case colored one too! that being said they are nice guns that would have been a homerun if delivered in a wood presentation case with a square butt grip profile wearing a quality reproduction SB pre war checkered Magnas (the tiny retro service stocks were nicely checkered and good quality but are ridiculously small especially on N frames) and last but not least they should have offered each of the PC Heritage guns as a 4" as well, especially the K22, ( maybe 3" and 5" offerings which seem to be in greater demand than 6" ?)
Also, WHY NO RETRO REGISTERED MAGNUM ?
Id have bought one in each barrel length.
The RegMag is probably one of the highest demand models and to this day still no repro offering ???
(Hint in case Lipseys is considering sponsoring a run), The old 4" M&P 22 ( Model 45) is a highly sought after rarity and a fixed sight 4" K frame 22lr woukd probably sell like hotcakes!

The Model 15 Heritage is kind of a head scratcher as all of the rest were styled after their pre war counterparts sans barrel ribs and might have been the only 4"?
(Wasn't the only pre war revolver with a raised barrel rib the Reg Mag ?)
Iirc the PC 15 is the only PC Heritage with a factory post war raised rib barrel style, almost like they had 200 more frames than barrels and someone said, dont we have 200 of the old Model 15-4 barrels downstairs ?
I dont recall if those were the original stocks but if so the the PC 15 is also the only Heritage revolver with off the shelf composite non diamond magnas which supports the theory they might have been an afterthought.

The Heritage series was a great run and stands out as a perfect example of what S&W can accomplish when they put forth the effort, but if they ever decide to undertake such an experiment again ( they should IMO) perhaps focus production more on a small run of the more desirable configurations.

I thought the same thing about the model 15 Heritage. It's a beautiful gun, but not really modeled after an older gun. I don't know how a guy would know. Maybe reach out to Lipseys? My 25-11 does have features of an older gun. Pencil barrel, grips, etc.
 
I don't collect the Heritage Series, but I have a PC 17-8. Haven't shot it in years...

The finish is superb, it shoots well and there were no problems with extraction. My only complaint is the stocks. I installed Eagle targets when I took it to the range.

View attachment 786635
Agree on the stocks. I have a blued McGivern model, the grips leave a lot to be desired, that's for sure.
 
Back
Top