185 MPH and traveling backwards

You need to understand that the length of all the high-speed train lines in Europe would not get you out of the state of Florida. Anyone can build a line that runs a couple hundred miles from Point A to Point B.

It's not the total cost that is under discussion, it's the fact that accurate estimates for a line of any length in the US or UK seem to be impossible to obtain, either because of incompetence or fraud.
 
You need to understand that the length of all the high-speed train lines in Europe would not get you out of the state of Florida. Anyone can build a line that runs a couple hundred miles from Point A to Point B.

Just France will get you out of Florida, easily.
France has 1740 miles of high speed line and Spain has 2388 miles. Then there is the rest...............

Stu
 
I had not heard that before so looked it up. Per this article, it is not true.

"...trolley systems were replaced by bus systems for economic reasons, not because of a plot. Bus lines were less expensive to operate than trolleys, and far less costly to build because there were no rails. Extending service to rapidly growing suburbs could be accomplished quickly, by simply building a few bus stops, rather than taking years to construct rail lines. So, buses replaced streetcars.

For similar reasons, with the added one of personal preference for individual transportation, private cars also played an important role in the demise of streetcars. People understandably liked driving their own cars directly to their destinations more than crowding onto trolleys that dropped them blocks from where they were going...."


The GM Trolley Conspiracy: What Really Happened - CBS News

Uh Huh. I do know for a fact that the Chicago streetcar system was replaced by busses courtesy of good deal of "grease" from GM.

I'd hadly call CBS a credible source.
 
Right on.

Due to circumstances a few years ago my wife and a couple of her friends were going south to attend a convention.

They took the train and from what my wife said never again!

From what she said among other things like very messy rest rooms they ran into way too many "interesting people"
Your wife thinks trains are bad, try taking the Hound or Conteniental Trailways!
 
Brightline, a commuter rail between Miami and West Palm Bch, began service past Friday to Orlando after repeated delays pushed back the start date several weeks. A pedestrian was promptly struck and killed in Delray bringing the total number of deaths in Palm Beach Co. alone to 28 since it's inaugural run Jan. '18.
$158 one way saves 30 minutes drive time.
 
Okay, okay, enough with the horror stories...

Back in May, my girlfriend and I rode the Amtrak Vermonter from Union Station in Washington, D.C., to St. Alban's, Vermont, where we spent four days enjoying the New England Spring.

The train was clean and comfortable, the trip took about 12 hours, and the round-trip fare for two (ahem!) "senior citizens" was far less than what it would have cost to drive there...highly recommended! :)
 
I find it both puzzling and worrying that it appears to be impossible for Western world engineering to come up with a remotely accurate estimate on the costs of transport infrastructure.
Here in California, the Brown Streak was never intended to be a high speed rail system. It may have been advertised as such but to the political people involved, it was a funding source for many other transportation jobs.
I've said enough.
 
I think our country gave up on passenger rail service nationwide.....

.......too early.

Best memory from childhood, parents and I boarded a Frisco passenger train in the small Ozarks town where we lived. Quite an adventure for a youngster. Arrived at Kansas City's Union Station late that night and transfered to the Santa Fe's El Capitain and headed west. Dodge City and many other towns and places whose names were so familiar from the daily dose of television westerns that I grew up on.
All too soon the magnificent train trip ended at LA's Union Station. Kids don't know about architecture and the appearances of structures but I remember being stricken with how unique and impressive the station was.

In early adult life decided to ride Amtrax to Texas to visit my Sister. Boarded at a small town in NE Arkansas at 4:00 AM ,where I once picked up my load of Memphis Press Scimitar papers to deliver by bike.
The experience of the train trip to San Antonio was by no means as magical at the one with the parents but it was still very enjoyable and would do it again someday but might opt for a longer journey and chose a sleeper compartment.

Didn't meet or see any strange or questionable folks but I am sure there are some on Amtrax from time to time. Probably not as many as fly the friendly skies if the news reports are true.

Train travel in my opinion is a very relaxing ,civilized means of travel.
Wish it was still available across our country.
 
Last edited:
We used to hop trains when I was in Jr. High, just from form New Brighton over to Beaver Falls. Then my friend Willy slipped & lost his foot under a wheel. Pretty disgusting from what I hear. One event I'm happy to have missed. I really would like to take that loco trip up in the mountains before I die.
 
Hope both of you are having a great time. Been watching Shirlyn's posts about the trip!

I am unable to ride in anything backwards. About ten minutes in I start getting iffy.
 
We used to move cross country by train when I was a kid. We would stay in a Pullman car with a small bathroom. It was a true adventure and I loved it, we did that all before I started first grade, then settled down. It wasn't until I got stationed in Germany that I started taking the train again, loved it. It was so much convenient that using about any other method and the schedules were on the money. I've thought of taking a train trip, staying in a private sleeping car, etc. Thats as far as I've got, if your a reader, trains are terrific ways to travel. The new Pullman cars are much smaller, yet still private, prices are higher than flying unless you like 1st class which I vow will be the only way they get me in another cramped airliner.
 
I am unable to ride in anything backwards. About ten minutes in I start getting iffy.

You must be related to my late mother. She always needed to "face the engine". Consequently, I either rode backwards or had to sit next to my mother, and what self-respecting young man of nine or ten wants to do that? ;)

Being a smart-alec young boy I pointed out that on many of the electric and diesel multiple unit trains we rode, there were engines all over the place. Yeah, that made me popular.
 
We used to hop trains when I was in Jr. High, just from form New Brighton over to Beaver Falls. Then my friend Willy slipped & lost his foot under a wheel. Pretty disgusting from what I hear. One event I'm happy to have missed. I really would like to take that loco trip up in the mountains before I die.

We had a young local girl did the same years back. Unfortunately she lost a leg.
 
Brightline, a commuter rail between Miami and West Palm Bch, began service past Friday to Orlando after repeated delays pushed back the start date several weeks. A pedestrian was promptly struck and killed in Delray bringing the total number of deaths in Palm Beach Co. alone to 28 since it's inaugural run Jan. '18.
$158 one way saves 30 minutes drive time.

Unless the train hits someone and has to sit for the investigation or until another train is sent to pick up the passengers. I think the "buzz" will wear off in a few years and then it will just be a continuous money drain to prop it up.
 
In early adult life decided to ride Amtrax to Texas to visit my Sister. Boarded at a small town in NE Arkansas at 4:00 AM ,where I once picked up my load of Memphis Press Scimitar papers to deliver by bike.
The experience of the train trip to San Antonio was by no means as magical at the one with the parents but it was still very enjoyable and would do it again someday but might opt for a longer journey and chose a sleeper compartment.

Train travel in my opinion is a very relaxing ,civilized means of travel.
Wish it was still available across our country.
I took an overnight Amtrak trip from California to New Mexico before COVID hit.
Was the worst trip imaginable. I suffered a minor whiplash on the train.
The tracks were in such disrepair they had to reduce speed in some sections, if they didn't, the sleeper car would whip sideways so violently that you were forced into a wall if walking or rolled out of bed. No way could you sleep on the upper deck.
The ONLY bright spot was the dinner I had. To say the steak dinner was fantastic is to damn it with faint praise. (eating and drinking in the Dining Car was another roller coaster event though)
 
Unless there's a huge cultural shift south Floridians will never give up their cars to the half-assed attempts at mass transit foisted upon us for the past 40 years.

Part of the reason for that is due to the Californian's fleeing this crazy place and taking their cars with them.
Californian's will never willing give up their cars no matter what the AQMD or Urban Planners decree nor the resulting travel time due to mass traffic jams.
 
Unless there's a huge cultural shift south Floridians will never give up their cars to the half-assed attempts at mass transit foisted upon us for the past 40 years.

That's the problem right there. Most mass transit plans in the US are half-baked.

They built a monorail in Vegas servicing the Strip that was perfectly aligned to go direct to the airport. That clearly got nixed by the taxi companies, car rental companies, and even the hotel/casinos on the Strip. The last one may come as a shocker, but in the 80s-90s the casinos had a totally hostile attitude to anything that made movement easier.

Perfect example. For a while when the county widened Las Vegas Boulevard to the maximum allowed by the easement, several hotels refused to have sidewalks or pedestrian bridges on their property. Sidewalks and bridges meant it was easier for people to leave the property, and the casinos wanted nothing to do with that. It was only the threat of eminent domain action that made the casinos acquiesce, albeit begrudgingly. Perhaps the quid pro quo was that the county agreed never to approve a monorail extension to the airport.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top