1911 recommendation

I forgot to mention that you should check out the 1911 Forum. The one that I am familiar with provides a lot of information, and even has subsections devoted to certain brands.

As for my not recommending SIGs, I didn't because as far as I know, they don't have a GI model, they are usually close to $1K new, which is about twice your stated budget, and they do have a FPS. SIG's CS is pretty good, although it does have its highs and lows.

I didn't recommend Colt for the same reasons (although some models are available without a FPS.) Colt does have good service, if you are in no hurry...like several months, in most cases. Colt gets too preoccupied with its large military contracts sometimes...at least that's the best explanation I have ever heard. I've never had a problem with any Colt that I've ever owned, but I've read about the experiences of many other owners...and they have all said pretty much the same thing: it takes months to get your gun back. Take that for what it's worth...they may be exaggerating the time interval (like when my mother-in-law visits, or I'm waiting for a gun I ordered to come in, the clocks/calendars seem to stand still.) With a Colt, though, you can be pretty much assured it will retain its value, unless you abuse it or don't take care of it. It's an American icon, much like Harley Davidson, and some Colts do rattle and leak too. ;)

I've read good and bad about Remingtons...I didn't have any problems with mine, but didn't keep it (I thought maybe I could figure out a grip that wouldn't get me bit, but I wasn't able to.) They also have a FPS, no lifetime warranty (unless that has changed), and don't get glowing reviews on their CS, as far as what I have read.

Based on my bad experiences, I wouldn't wish a Kimber on anyone...and I don't care for Taurus products either (poor CS, poor QC, and resale value sucks.)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: A10
I like the Sig so much, I have a Stainless, and a Black Nitron finished one too!

Chuck
 
Some years ago I had a Norinco 1911. Quality and finish seemed much like the GI 1911s. I shot it a lot and had no problems with it.

Not fancy, but a good shooting basic 1911 that should be available at a reasonable price.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rpg
Best Buy in a .45 1911

Colt!

For under $1000.00 you can get a brand new factory fresh Series 70 (or 80 if desired) Colt Government model. The new Colt 1911's are BEAUTIFUL, have great actions, are dead nuts accurate, beautiful rosewood grips, have very good triggers, and have the improved fixed sight. For another 200 bucks you can get the Gold Cup. They are simply GREAT GUNS!

The Colt is not the cheapest 1911 on the market, but for the quality you get I think it is actually the best buy in 1911's today. I have many friends and shooting bud's with Wilsons, Browns, Behr's, SA, Kimbers etc. that are two to three times the price of a Colt and not even nearly as reliable. You can save a few bucks with some of the copies but they are not in the same league as the Colts are IMHO. AND........ you get an original not a copy!
 
RIA best bang for the buck i bought one in 9mm a 1911 fs tact ll over 1500 rds of assorted ammo steel brass not one issue.cant be beat for under 500 bucks.
 
My vote is for the Ruger SR1911. BTW, I'll admit a strong bias, I like the first one so much I purchased a second as a spare.

Positives.

A very good looking finish and a great looking 1911.

It's a series 70, so no firing pin safety to complicate a full detail strip and cleaning. Another plus is the single side safety to ease detail stripping and improve reliability. In fact it's the easiest handgun to detail strip I've ever owned. By Far, in fact it's so simple to detail strip down to

Both of my have featured totally, 100%, flawless reliability. So far I've run Speer Gold Dots, Hornady XTP hollow points and probably 50 or 60 lbs of 230 grain round nose FMJ and plated through mine without one single failure to feed or eject.

Sights are another big plus, especially for those of us with aging eyesight. Big white dots that are easy to see. Accuracy is what I consider quite good for the price paid, IMO they are capable of grouping around 2 inches at 25 yards with the right ammo and in good hands. BTW, IMO this is a result of a very good fit between the barrel, barrel bushing, and slide to bushing. They aren't tool needing tight but are tight enough to not have any play that can be felt by hand.

Minuses.

First, it does rattle. The frame to slide fit is what I call a Service Fit. Meaning it's loose enough to provide excellent reliability with a minimal impact on accuracy. BTW, I've done some checking and the fit is basically identical to a Colt, Remington, or Springfield Armory 1911. Kimbers have about 30 % less play in the slide to frame fit and Ed Brown 1911 have almost zero perceptible play in the fit.

Second negative is the magazines, the feed lips are a bit ragged and scar up fired casings and are difficult to load. Solved that with 8 of the excellent Wilson Combat 47D magazines.
 
If you go higher end (and if you can afford it), look at the Sig Traditional models. They have the standard 1911 slide profile, outstanding sights, and are very well put together. They are all stainless and no MIM parts. I have been very pleased with mine.
 

Attachments

  • picture022.jpg
    picture022.jpg
    91.2 KB · Views: 88
The High Standard 1911 is worth checking out too. I've seen them online for well under $500. A friend of mine bought the compact version & loves it so much that it became his everyday carry pistol.
 
There have never been so many different 1911s to choose from and I doubt that anyone can honestly attest to experience with more than 4 or 5 brands. I've never known of ANY brand that was consistently bad, and price alone doesn't always guarantee absolute excellence. I currently have two; an inexpensive RIA 3.5" compact and a Springfield Mil-Spec that's been tuned by the Springfield Custom Shop. They are both reliable guns. The little RIA actually has more features, but I enjoy shooting the full-size Mil-Spec more. I've got about $450 in the RIA and maybe $750 in the Springfield, including the custom work. Check out the 1911 Forum if you want detailed information on just about any model you can think of.
 
  • Like
Reactions: A10
Start by talking to other shooters at your local gun stores, and indoor or outdoor ranges. Get the word out and the perfect 1911 will show up, if your ready.

Chuck
 
Collectors Firearms in Houston always has a nice selection of old military 1911s. I came very close to buying one that was issued to a man who received the Medal of Honor for his actions in France in WWI. However, I cound not justify spending $5,000++ for it.
 
Try Collectors Firearms in Houston. They have old military 1911s in stock and I almost bought one that had belonged to a Medal of Honor Recipient who earned his MoH in France in WWI. However, I could not justify paying $5,000+++ for it so I passed.

Sorry for the dupe post. My computer hiccuped when I posted the first time.
 
What movie was that? "Build it and they will come." :p

It was "If you build it, he will come" from "Field of Dreams."

If anyone wants to give me a 1911, I will definitely show up for it. :)
 
I would go with the Ruger SR1911. Decent fit and finish, everything you need and nothing you don't need. Mine came straight from the box with a crisp 4.5 lb trigger, and it holds 3" at 25 yards with Winchester WB 230 gr. You can usually find them for around $650-$700. It's a Ruger so it is a solid pistol.
 
Sorry if this has been beaten to death, but here goes...

I'm looking for a range toy 1911. Won't ever carry, not home defense. Just a range toy. .45 auto of course. I really like the look and features of the GI/WWII standard 1911's, like the remington R1 for example. No crazy extra frills, just standard 1911. I don't plan on using this gun as a platform for upgrades and mods, I'd just like to take it out of the box and enjoy target shooting with it. I'd like to spend less than $700 if possible.

Recommendations would be greatly appreciated, if you could suggest a model and what I might expect to pay for it.

Thanks guys!

RIA is excellent. So is Springfield Armory. RIA will be about $450 give or take. Not sure about the SA. I bought a used SA GI 1911-A1 for $400 in February. HTH. Sincerely. bruce
 
Back
Top