357 questions

Joined
Nov 8, 2014
Messages
1
Reaction score
1
Ok here is the problem only have limited funds and want a 357 with 6" barrel everyone says get a old smith instead of a new budget brand but most of the new budget brands have a lifetime warranty and Smith only offers one to the original owner I have 5906 I had sent for repair and had to pay for when I asked why they said you're not the original owner then they had the gun for about 4 months I gave them my new address 3 times before they sent it back and they still sent it to the old address so please no bs about how great Smith's customer service is because IT'S NOT I'm looking for a mechanical sound 357 single and double action 6" barrel that I can put thousands of rounds threw with a great warranty like I said on a budget of 300$ it don't half to be pretty so if you know a budget brand that fits all categories I asked about let me know
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
Welcome to the Forum.
Unfortunately I can't think of any new model revolver that fits your terms for three bills. I suppose a used Rossi or Taurus, but nothing new. If your are concerned about longevity, I would advise you to save a bit more money and get an S&W M28 or M19 used. The latter is a K-Frame and the former an N-Frame. The N-Frame in .357 Magnum will outlast you.
It will cost about twice what you have now, but will be well worth it.
Jim
 
You should save more money and get a solid model like a smith or ruger. If you plan on putting thousands of rounds through it, what's a couple extra hundred. Your budget is too low and you will end up with a Taurus exploding model.
 
Find a mechanically sound N frame.

You can find decent used model 28's (Highway Patrolman) for about $500.

I think that $300 won't buy much these days, it sure won't buy anything new (of any repute anyhow).

I know where there is a 4" model 28-2 for $450, it is solid, but it isn't pretty.
 
Don't settle. Save more and buy what you want. Don't be impulsive. As the saying goes. ...buy once cry once. Budget brands offer a lifetime warranty because they are budget guns. It's their selling point because they can't sell it as a quality well made gun. ...because it's not.
 
What everyone else said.. :) I'd rather have a L, N, or K frame S&W or a Ruger. Than a dollar two ninety five S. American..
 
Last edited:
686 or ruger. Itll cost you a bit more but its what youre looking for. check gb and you might be able to get one a little cheaper.
 
I saw M65 Police Trade-in for $400 at Buds Gunshop last week. You might go there and look 'em over.
 
Ok here is the problem only have limited funds and want a 357 with 6" barrel everyone says get a old smith instead of a new budget brand but most of the new budget brands have a lifetime warranty and Smith only offers one to the original owner I have 5906 I had sent for repair and had to pay for when I asked why they said you're not the original owner then they had the gun for about 4 months I gave them my new address 3 times before they sent it back and they still sent it to the old address so please no bs about how great Smith's customer service is because IT'S NOT I'm looking for a mechanical sound 357 single and double action 6" barrel that I can put thousands of rounds threw with a great warranty like I said on a budget of 300$ it don't half to be pretty so if you know a budget brand that fits all categories I asked about let me know
Welcome to the forum, goodtimes795. :)

If I've followed you correctly, you want:

1) A .357 Magnum revolver with a 6" barrel.
2) New.
3) Lifetime warranty.
4) Quality built and can handle thousands of magnum rounds.
5) $300.

Assuming this is a sincere request, I'll answer directly: it's not out there, it doesn't exist, it isn't going to happen.

When "everyone" gives you the same advice (to include posters in this thread), consider that there's a good reason.

Wait. Save. Make a sound decision on a quality firearm. Pay more. Cry once over it, rather than many times because you bought cheap.

Accuracy, reliability, hard use and safety come at a price, and understandably so -- they're all important, especially safety.

Curious to know -- when "everyone" has already told you to buy a S&W -- what response you were expecting in your first post at a S&W forum asking for a non-S&W suggestion while bad-mouthing S&W service?

Regardless, get a S&W. Or a Ruger. New. Or used. Just pick wisely. You don't have to spend thousands of dollars to get a great gun, but you do have to spend more than $300 to get what you're looking for.
 
I think your best bet is to find a nice, quality used revolver. There is a chance you could luck into one for the price you are looking for. Half of the the fun is the chase. Good luck.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Do not go with a so called bargain brand. You will regret it later, and if lucky will only pay for it twice. If you are not lucky well anything could happen. It seems what you really want is a new S&W for $300 or less. If this is true I am sad to say that you are about 25 - 30 years too late. Save up the money that you need and get what will do you the most good, don't buy now until you know what you are getting. I have bought a few revolvers used, a 3" S&W 65 and a 4 Colt Python and both have been just great. Buy quality once, buy bargain brand 2, 3, or more times.
 
New for $300 just isn't feasible but there are some bargains in the used market but you will need to save a little more. The model 28 N frame even in an older gun will see you through many years of service. Probably the most common 357 6" will be the L frame S&W in 586 or 686. You can find bargains sometimes. I recently saw a 686 no dash for $425 at a gun show. It was a very solid gun just showed signs of being carried a lot. One that is rock solid but out of production is a Ruger Single Six. They are built very well and can be found very reasonable. I picked up a stainless one for $325. The triggers aren't as nice as a Smith but they are a hell of a bargain. Another non Smith still in production also very solid is the Ruger GP100. You can find a bargain in one on occasion. Taurus I have never owned one but I know a few people that have had good service out of them. I have never heard that you had to be the original owner for warranty I guess I got lucky. I needed the ejector alignment pins for my model 64 and they sent them to me free and I bought it used.
 
Best gun that fits "closest" to what you are looking for in my opinion is a ruger security six. They are out of production so I'd say no warranty (ruger doesn't express any kind of warranty even for new but that's another topic). Otherwise keep saving for an s&w or newer ruger of your choice.

On a side note I've dealt with s&w customer service a handful of times now and never had a problem. 2 warranty issues. One was back to me in 2 weeks and the other in 3 if I remember correctly. And a couple repairs not under warranty. These took longer of course. It's the way s&w is handling repairs. Warranty takes precedent over non warranty. But wait times were still typical of what's going on with all the big names it seems. Received email notification when all guns were shipping back and I notified fed ex to hold at their shipping hub for me to pick up. Never a problem. Oh, welcome to the forum.
 
Before I carried a Rossi or Taurus I would much prefer a BP .44 cap and ball. I am being serious here. I have had the cheap-o revolvers. Been there done it. Never again and was told by Taurus to ship on my dime to FL.
I packed a .36 in the 70s before I was 21. I could have the issue .45 but not buy one. Long story.

There are used Ruger and S&W guns at fair prices but it takes a lot of looking.
Still doubt you will find a $300 .357 maybe $400
If I had a time machine I would go back to 1974 and buy a truck load of 28-2 S&W for $145 retail and bring you back one.
Buy like YOUR life depends on it.
 
Before I carried a Rossi or Taurus I would much prefer a BP .44 cap and ball. I am being serious here. I have had the cheap-o revolvers. Been there done it. Never again and was told by Taurus to ship on my dime to FL.
I packed a .36 in the 70s before I was 21. I could have the issue .45 but not buy one. Long story.

There are used Ruger and S&W guns at fair prices but it takes a lot of looking.
Still doubt you will find a $300 .357 maybe $400
If I had a time machine I would go back to 1974 and buy a truck load of 28-2 S&W for $145 retail and bring you back one.
Buy like YOUR life depends on it.
ibewbull if you get that time machine going grab a couple of 28's for me. [emoji2]
 
If you can't find a good used Smith then a new Ruger gp100 is what I'd get. But you are not finding them for $300. That is probably half.
Have you considered a regular old 38? Like a model 10. Those would be better than a Tarass or Rossi and still doable in your price range.
 
The best three hundred dollar gun you're going to find is an ex-LEO M64 in .38 Spl. Those can be found in 2-inch and 4-inch form. I don't think they ever made a 6-inch M64. There's quit a few of these $300 M64's on the market today (I just bought two a couple of weeks ago). I'd hurry, though. They're selling fast and once they're gone I don't know how many more large batches of surplus revolvers were going to see in coming years.
 
Bargain brands like Taurus or Rossi have weak cranes and lockwork. That's not conducive to long term use or ownership. Charter Arms aren't bad, but they are small framed, rough fit and finish, and notorious for critical screws and pins coming loose.

As others mentioned, Smith or Ruger.
 
Long ago I was a young man with a family and limited $. I wanted a S&W but, the price was so much higher than others and I bought an other. I just wasn't satisfied and finally sold the "other" at a loss and got a S&W. If I would have waited I would have been better off. I have since never regretted buying any Smith. I have only regretted selling the once I have sold.

So, wait and save. If I was looking for a 357. I would get an L frame although I am an N frame fan, the N frames are kind of big for the 357 and in my opinion better when they have a 4 plus number.
 
....want a 357 with 6" barrel .......I'm looking for a mechanical sound 357 single and double action 6" barrel that I can put thousands of rounds threw with a great warranty like I said on a budget of 300$ it don't half to be pretty so if you know a budget brand that fits all categories I asked about let me know

I agree with the others. I would save up for a S&W or a Ruger, all the while keeping my eye open for a used L (586 or 686) or N frame (model 28) because every now and then one pops up from an individual seller for a great price (maybe close to $300 if you're really lucky) but you would be without a warranty.

Re: S&W and Ruger warranties - see end of post.

Your best bet for a good warranty is to deal with a distributor or reseller that offers a "great warranty."

For example, Davidson's Inc. (www.galleryofguns.com - Buy guns online, top brands, best price, best service, best warranty; all types of firearms: revolvers, rifles, pistols and shotguns.), a distributor, offers a lifetime warranty on firearms purchased through them. You can buy directly from them although they are usually out of stock on S&W revolvers. It looks like a new Ruger GP100 is about $625 out the door depending on your location and local gun stores that participate with Davidson's.

Other resellers or distributors may offer similar lifetime or 100%guarantee warranties similar to Davidson's. For example, Bud's Gun Shop website implies they have a very thorough warranty on BOTH new and USED guns. Here's a link to their warranty page:
Discount Guns for Sale - Buds Gun Shop
A new Ruger GP100 is $524 + FFL transfer through Bud's. I'm not sure if taxes would be involved? My interpretation is that the $399 police trade-ins at Bud's would be covered under their warranty which appears very generous however it does not fit your criteria of a 6" gun. A new Taurus 66 from Bud's is only $73 less expensive than the Ruger GP100.

John

Here are the warranties from S&W and Ruger:
From the S&W website:
1. Lifetime Service Policy
"We will repair any defect in material or workmanship without charge to the original purchaser for as long as you own the handgun."
2. From the Ruger website:
"The Magnuson-Moss Act (Public Law 93-637) does not require any seller or manufacturer of a consumer product to give a written warranty. It does provide that if a written warranty is given, it must be designated as "limited" or as "full" and sets minimum standards for a "full" warranty. Sturm, Ruger & Company, Inc. has elected not to provide any written warranty, either "limited" or "full", rather than to attempt to comply with the provisions of the Magnuson-Moss Act and the regulations issued thereunder. There are certain implied warranties under state law with respect to sales of consumer goods. As the extent and interpretation of these implied warranties varies from state to state, you should refer to your state statutes. Sturm, Ruger & Company wishes to assure its customers of its continued interest in providing service to owners of Ruger firearms."
 
I saw a new, high quality 357 with a full warantee costing $300 once...it was carried by a man riding a unicorn and eating rainbow stew....


You really do get what you pay for..barring that 1 in a million deal on a used revolver
 
Last edited:
The money you have to spend just may not be enough. But, you are on a S&W enthusiast forum asking what to buy. I would suggest you also stop over at the Taurus forum & see what they have say....
 
$300.00????? What you might buy for that amount wouldn't be worth three cents, unless you could find a clueless seller. Good luck.
 
Last edited:
My first thought when I saw the thread title was:

Man, that's a lot of questions!

Anyway, I also agree with everyone else. $300 probably isn't gonna do it.
 
Some gun manufacturers use the "Lifetime Warranty" as a way to cut costs. They save money by not having a quality control dept. Instead they send the bad guns out with the good guns and let the buyer be the quality control. It has worked for Taurus.
If you can save up enough money to buy a quality revolver it will retain it's value. I bought a used Smith and Wesson revolver (model 36) several years ago for $350. Today it is worth...$350. I haven't lost much money on it.
 
Last edited:
Not a problem, you just need a time machine...
I remember buying a like new model 28 for $235, and a 66 for $250, and my Dan Wesson was $265....
 
About the closest for $300.00 would be a Ruger Blackhawk, used. If you look around a lot, you might find a Ruger GP100 for about $400.00. The Security Six is good but parts may be hard to find.

EAA has a Windicator model but I dont know how good it is. Had a couple of their single action Bounty Hunters in 44 Magnum that were good guns.

Years ago I would have said get the Highway Patrolman. But they are way high now.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top