38 M&P Model 1905, 4th change. With unusual markings

.380 MkII was the designation of the FMJ round of the issue ammo until late in 1944 or early '45.
The designation of that FMJ round was changed to .380 MkIIz & sometimes headstamped as .380 2z at that time.

The Austrian Police mark looks like that applied to the mountain of M&P revolvers issued/given post-WW2 to them for Police and Security work.
 
What you have is a bargain at $125, and a $1,000 mystery, money well spent, regardless of what you do with it. I do not normally refinish old guns in that shape, however, I probably would that one. And I would shoot it all day long with 38 Special standard pressure loads.
 
I’m super jealous! This was used by the occupying forces post WW2 then passed on to Austria.

The Brits had 38 Special Pre-Victory revolvers that they ordered direct prior to our involvement in WW2. These WILL NOT be marked U.S. Property and WILL NOT have the V prefix. After the 38/200 Victory models arrived these 38 Specials were handed off to less embattled regions of the Empire. The barrel should read “38 S&W Special CTG”

These are noted in The Smith & Wesson Catalogue under 1905 4th change. (4th edition p163) Yours fits the SN range. I also confirmed the British purchase through Ian Skinnerton, author of “The Broad Arrow.” He is a British firearms historian and a good friend.

I collect guns of the British Empire. You have a beautiful revolver! I wish I had one!

Here’s some pics of my South African.
The barrel is marked 38 S&W Special.CTG as you described. It’s also not marked US Property.
Mechanically, the gun is like new.. cosmetically the gun had some pretty bad rust areas on it but no pitting. I may have screwed up by cleaning up the rust but something had to be done or pitting was just around the corner.
Being a history buff at heart, these old guns fascinate me and I wish they could talk.
Since I only paid 125.00 for it I’m going to send off for a letter just because I want to know. 🤣🤣
Thank you for your information, it’s much appreciated.
 
Boy - glad the serial number is now known by everyone!!!!! The 38 S&W was a shorter and larger round than the 38 Special. The 38 S&W bullet was .361" dia, and the 38 Special used a .357" bullet. The brass is also larger than a 38 Special and using a original factory 38 Special cylinder, you should not be able to fully chamber a 38 S&W.
 
I imagine this gun will letter rather prosaically. Its subsequent history, that is, just when and how it came to be altered to accept the British .38 cartridge and the exact circumstances under which it ended up in service with the post-WWII Austrian police are probably undiscoverable.
 
I picked up what I believe to be a Model 1905 38 M&P , 4th change. Ser # 439XXX. Gun was not in good shape outside and I paid 125.00, figured it would be a project this winter for a truck gun.
Started to get the rust off and noticed two stamps I can’t find any information on. I appreciate any info people may be able to provide.
I appreciate being here as I love the old S&W revolvers.
View attachment 779287View attachment 779288View attachment 779289
I picked up what I believe to be a Model 1905 38 M&P , 4th change. Ser # 439XXX. Gun was not in good shape outside and I paid 125.00, figured it would be a project this winter for a truck gun.
Started to get the rust off and noticed two stamps I can’t find any information on. I appreciate any info people may be able to provide.
I appreciate being here as I love the old S&W revolvers.
View attachment 779287View attachment 779288View attachment 779289
Of you find the markings CB on the gun it does mean that the German gunsmitj Carl Bernhard has converted the gun to . 38 Special. This usually happened to guns having the .38 S&W Calibra with the shorter case. The .38 S&W is a Little thicker which expandiert the 38 Special cases so that they are a little more resistent when reloading during the sizing process. This All might not be relevant to your gun, but maybe you find one some day. For the rest it is correct that the allied forces gave the revolvers to the German or Austrian police after WW II. Excellent information can be found in The fine book of Charles Pate “ Handguns of WW II. Enjoy collecting these oldies!
Rainer
 
It sounds like this gun might be worth lettering, if only to find out where it originally went.
Unfortunately, it is extremely unlikely that a letter will provide even the slightest clue regarding how the revolver found its way into Austrian police service or how it returned to the USA.
 
What you have is a bargain at $125, and a $1,000 mystery, money well spent, regardless of what you do with it. I do not normally refinish old guns in that shape, however, I probably would that one. And I would shoot it all day long with 38 Special standard pressure loads.
I feel the same about refinishing but made an exception for this one. Honest wear and patina is great but rust has to go when it’s like this one was.
 
As a relevant but side story, I have a surrendered Austrian Gendarmerie 08/34
Steyr, GI bring back.
The capture papers states May 21, 1945, in Fugging*, formerly spelt (not for decent folk speak with gg replacing ck) until 2021, is an Austrian village in the municipality of Tarsdorf, located North of Salzburg, in the Innviertel region of western Upper Austria.
* Look it up
 

Attachments

  • Mine.jpg
    Mine.jpg
    78.9 KB · Views: 0
  • My Steyr L.jpg
    My Steyr L.jpg
    86.7 KB · Views: 0
  • LeftBreak_2.jpg
    LeftBreak_2.jpg
    54.1 KB · Views: 0
  • My Steyr top.jpg
    My Steyr top.jpg
    66.8 KB · Views: 0
  • Steyr rig.jpg
    Steyr rig.jpg
    502.9 KB · Views: 0
  • Steyr rig holster.jpg
    Steyr rig holster.jpg
    71.5 KB · Views: 0
Last edited:
The barrel is marked 38 S&W Special.CTG as you described. It’s also not marked US Property.
Mechanically, the gun is like new.. cosmetically the gun had some pretty bad rust areas on it but no pitting. I may have screwed up by cleaning up the rust but something had to be done or pitting was just around the corner.
Being a history buff at heart, these old guns fascinate me and I wish they could talk.
Since I only paid 125.00 for it I’m going to send off for a letter just because I want to know. 🤣🤣
Thank you for your information, it’s much appreciated.
You sir have inspired me. Now I have to dig thru my safe and check out one of mine. I was gifted it by a family member decades ago. When I got it, I was surprised because it was loaded, with 38 Special, 38 Long Colt and I think, 38 S and W, all three in the gun. Now, I have to check and see about that second ring inside, for the 38 SW round. It possibly could have been 38 Short Colt for that third set, not sure. I just recall it being loaded with 3 different rounds and quite a mystery for me at the time. The owner was 93 years old and carried it around with him and about $50,000 in cash because he did not trust banks. He was a bit, unique.Model 10 roberts.jpg

I do reload 38 Short Colt just because they tell the grand daughter they are low recoil ammo for her 38 Special handgun.


This gun has the same early markings and had been back to SW to be nickel plated at some point in time, as evidenced by the "R" stamp on the gun. The last patent on this one was 1917 and we think it was produced shortly after that, making it well over 100 years in the field, some field, somewhere. Like you, the history is worth as much as the gun. Give us some follow up when you get the letter.

As to the rust, absolutely, gotta stop that. I am a big fan of Flex Hones and similar 800 grit size abrasives which can often kill the rust and get down to a level that can be blended to where it does not show. And then protective stuff can protect the finish. I like Ren wax but any will do.

I just find yours fascinating. Who knows what holster that one rode in and what stories it could tell. I have carried issue guns on foreign soil that have their own story. Unfortunately, the government gives and takes away, so those stories are long gone. Sometimes guns are like favorite dogs, they become companions. Am I nuts? Prolly so. Most, like Glocks do not matter, you lose one, buy another tomorrow, they have no personality.....Anyway, thanks for the interesting post.
 
Information from Cartridges of the World. .38 Long Colt can be fired in a .38 Special. Assume .38 Short Colt could be also. Both of the Colt cartridges were shorter versions of the .38 Special. .38 Special was also called .38 Colt Special. Just like S&W did not like to use the Colt or Winchester name on their guns, Colt did not want to give any credit to S&W.
.38 S&W is also known as .38 Colt New Police and with a 200 grain bullet as .38 Super Police. The British service load is called .380/200. Also referred to as .380/200 MK I. .380 MK II like your gun is marked was a 180 grain FMJ bullet.

Many .38 S&W guns were converted to .38 Special. Because the .38 S&W chambers are larger diameter have heard of .38 Special cases swelling or splitting. Think most folks think safe to use.
Your gun is the opposite. .38 Special converted to .38 S&W. Same situation if you use .38 Special ammo.
 
Last edited:
.380 MkII was the designation of the FMJ round of the issue ammo until late in 1944 or early '45.
The designation of that FMJ round was changed to .380 MkIIz & sometimes headstamped as .380 2z at that time.

The Austrian Police mark looks like that applied to the mountain of M&P revolvers issued/given post-WW2 to them for Police and Security work.
The significance of Mark 2z or Mark IIz is that the z denotes the use of nitrocellulose granular powder propellant, sort of like Bullseye, etc. Lack of the z indicates Cordite was used. The cartridge is the same, only the propellant type is different. There were numerous types and varieties of Cordite used in British ammunition through WWII. I never understood why the British were so married to Cordite instead of using nitrocellulose granular powders like the rest of the world.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top