Skip Sackett
US Veteran
Brother Paul,
The issue isn't 158gr @ 1000fps for 351ft/lbs. It is a 200gr @ 745fps for 247ft/lbs which is nearly half of the 400ft/lbs you mentioned.
What the 40S&W will give you at the data you provide is quicker recovery than the 1300fps 357 round you mentioned and a whole lot more of them.
Maybe not needed on the dirt roads in your area shooting hogs BUT in a big city where the gang bangers have hi-cap 9mm or whatever, I want the auto and a box of rounds. Which is what you carry in just a little over 3 magazines.
I wish it was like where you liver everywhere else, but it isn't.
The issue isn't 158gr @ 1000fps for 351ft/lbs. It is a 200gr @ 745fps for 247ft/lbs which is nearly half of the 400ft/lbs you mentioned.
What the 40S&W will give you at the data you provide is quicker recovery than the 1300fps 357 round you mentioned and a whole lot more of them.
Maybe not needed on the dirt roads in your area shooting hogs BUT in a big city where the gang bangers have hi-cap 9mm or whatever, I want the auto and a box of rounds. Which is what you carry in just a little over 3 magazines.

I wish it was like where you liver everywhere else, but it isn't.