BPA Content in Canned Goods

Texas Star

US Veteran
Joined
Mar 11, 2005
Messages
20,360
Reaction score
16,169
Location
Texas
I was curious as to whether our corned beef in cans was the same as the British Bully Beef mentioned in so many Commonwealth accounts from the Boer War to WWII. Basically, yes. The name arises from the French term for boiled beef, boeuf boulli, if I spelled that right. Got corrupted to "Bully" in English.

BUT... when I looked on the Net to see if I could just use corned beef from the can or had to cook it, I found an article that confirmed that canned beef is cooked and can be used without re-heating. Most of you probably know that; my family just never used it when I was young and I've never bought any. Don't have a can, or the label would probably have answered my question.

BUT, this is where the plot thickens. The best article I found said that eating this or ANY canned goods exposes one to the same BPA chemical toxin that caused many to be cautious about using poly bottles to carry water. Nalgene (to name one brand) had so many complaints about this that they offer a bottle free of BPA in construction. I got one, to be on the safe side, as I carry water in those when camping or hiking.

I may be the last to know this, but if YOU don't know that cans also carry the same sort of BPA contaminaton that those plastic bottles do, you may want to realize that.
BPA has been determined to cause several cancers, diabetes, neurological disorders, and other health issues, including increasing allergies! I'd only read about the cancer part.

I exist mainly on canned food, as it's fairly cheap and quick to prepare. No more. I'm going to make a point of limiting canned foods and eat more "fresh", despite trying to write a book, shop, and do all of my house work on my own, as I'm single. (Divorced.) Time is limited, especially if I want to do any hobby activities.

But I'm going to MAKE more time for cooking. And if you've been subsisting from cans, you probably should, too.

The article said that canned goods affect the contents more or less according to the food within and the length of time the food has been canned. And we don't know that: we just see expiration dates on cans.

This news has to be put into perspective. You can eat canned goods some of the time, but should strive to avoid it when possible. When time allows, cook fresh foods.

This may not matter to you married guys, whose wives probably know this and cook from scratch. But for lazy old bachelors like myself, it may mean something.

BTW, I found this past week that if you like to nibble Triscuits, the Safeway and Kroger brands of the same basic product (woven wheat crackers) are about the same and cost $1.77 against the $3.99 of actual Triscuits where I shop. Usually, I approach store brands with caution. But in this case, I see little or no difference. (This is my opinion, and presented as such.)
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
I work for a LARGE manufacture of cans, both aluminum and steel. No offense but your not getting that much BPA to be at risk. Ive read several reports on this, when the BPA scandel broke out last year, it couldve had a big impact on our company, we were goin to try new sprays ect. Basically your body neutralizes BPA as it goes through the body, and theres really no harm done. We make cans for baby formula, coke, pepsi, ect, all has been tested extensively by the big companies and independent studies.
And im not trying to start a debate on this topic, but as someone who works directly with it i thought i'd chime in, maybe put your fears at rest. Its only a big deal(well was last year... Havent heard this for awhile) because of shows like Dr. Oz ect. According to him last time i watched, i shouldnt drink apple juice cuz of the arsenic in it... :rolleyes:

Heres a good link, also has links for various studies done worldwide to prove its ok.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/jonenti...-reporters-and-ngos-botch-coverage-yet-again/
 
Last edited:
I work for a LARGE manufacture of cans, both aluminum and steel. No offense but your not getting that much BPA to be at risk. Ive read several reports on this, when the BPA scandel broke out last year, it couldve had a big impact on our company, we were goin to try new sprays ect. Basically your body neutralizes BPA as it goes through the body, and theres really no harm done. We make cans for baby formula, coke, pepsi, ect, all has been tested extensively by the big companies and independent studies.
And im not trying to start a debate on this topic, but as someone who works directly with it i thought i'd chime in, maybe put your fears at rest. Its only a big deal(well was last year... Havent heard this for awhile) because of shows like Dr. Oz ect. According to him last time i watched, i shouldnt drink apple juice cuz of the arsenic in it... :rolleyes:

Heres a good link, also has links for various studies done worldwide to prove its ok.
Bisphenol A (BPA) Found Not Harmful, Yet Again -- So Why Did So Many Reporters and NGOs Botch Coverage, Yet Again? - Forbes


Thanks for that link. The truth is probably somewhere between what the proponents of both sides say. But the article that you cited suggests that the risk may be lower than some maintain.

Nonetheless, I think I'll feel safer eating less canned food and more fresh. I also don't drink much soda pop, which I feel might be harmful in excess. Of course, most things are harmful in excess.
 
Thanks for that link. The truth is probably somewhere between what the proponents of both sides say. But the article that you cited suggests that the risk may be lower than some maintain.

Nonetheless, I think I'll feel safer eating less canned food and more fresh. I also don't drink much soda pop, which I feel might be harmful in excess. Of course, most things are harmful in excess.

No problem, like i said wasnt trying to start a debate or anything. And yea im a big anti soda guy... and i make the cans and lids. Ive lost 60 lbs this year just cutting out pop and making sure i drink water
 
Does anyone but me suspect that Dr. Oz is really well-named?

I've been a cook all my adult life, which has been helpful since I was widowed. I eat pretty well, because I love to cook.

I prefer fresh or frozen vegetables, but use a hell of a lot of canned tomatoes and tomato sauce, some canned meat (I love Spam and canned corned beef, so sue me) and canned fruit. I won't sweat the BPA until I'm SOL and maybe DOA.

A lot of the Kroger house brands are good stuff. I use their Italian roast coffee, a lot of their canned fruit, the crackers, and their whole-wheat pasta. Lots of other stuff. Only thing I'm picky about is the canned tomatoes. I'm a Red Gold man from way back. Oh, and Hellmann's Mayonnaise.
 
texas star- you need a housekeeper and chef combo. then you could get things done you want to do.
 
texas star- you need a housekeeper and chef combo. then you could get things done you want to do.

This is entirely true and I'm trying to think of a way to clone my favorite Victoria's Secret model to do that for me. So far, I haven't gotten beyond the planning stages.

I did jokingly ask my DIL to do that for me, as she does animal cloning, but she just rolled her eyes. Said that geneticists hear far too many comments like that.
 
Back
Top