Does .45 Long Colt have enough of a rim to provide reliable extraction?
.45 Auto Rim might be a better cartridge choice.
The body of a 455 is .480 the exact same as a 45 colt and they will eject properly if the muzzle is held tilted up as it should be, even though the colt rim is slightly narrower than the 455. The 45 colt rim OD is .512 and the 455 is .530 The 455 rim is only .038 thick and the colt's is .060 so the 455 extractor is about .020 thicker but other than that it is the same as one in a modern model 25 or 625 in 45 colt
The best way to modify a 455 cylinder to fire 45 colt is to ream the cylinder to 45 colt dept and machine a .512 OD, .020 deep recess. Then it will chamber, close up and fire 45 colts,plus, still chamber and properly head space the 455 because their wider rim will sit above the recess.
A 45 auto rim has a .515 Od rim, just .003 wider than a colt, but it is .083 thick so to modify a 455 cylinder to fire them you need to shave or recess the extractor .044 for the heads to clear the recoil shield and you would still end up with just .0015 more width of material sticking out from the case body for the extractor to engage.
A 455 cylinder reamed and partially recessed to fire both 45 colt and 455 as was done to my 455 triple lock prior to my purchasing it
There is a step in the cylinder from case to cylinder throats, it just doesn't show up well in this photo
There is also no reason you could not fit a 45 acp or a short 25-3 vintage 45 colt cylinder or one made from a 357 length cylinder to a second model 455. The first models (triple locks) would require more work as I believe they used a differnt OD center pin.