Did I just get hosed on this auction or am I being an ***

[walnutred]

Just a follow up. I went to the shop today like I said, and the guy was not there. He knew I was coming because I emailed him and he responded.

After handling the revolver the condition is better than I expected from the pictures. Also, it is model I would like to have and I have been looking for an affordable example for some time. Though frankly it's just a piece of steel and I don't think I want it if every time I look at it I'm reminded of a disagreement.

I emailed the dealer and asked him to review Gunbrokers terms and conditions and get back with me. At a minimum I will file a complaint with Gunbroker if we cannot reach an agreement.

The typo in the add was he listed it as a S&W model 190 rather than a S&W model 1902. Frankly I'm not totally sure it's even a 1902.

 

[Jack Flash]

You're right to not let it make you lose any sleep. There's always another gun.

It sounds like he is not exactly going the extra mile to accommodate you, but who knows? Maybe he had a family emergency?

In your shoes, I would call him and discuss it. The worst he can do is insist on relisting it and invite you to bid again. Personally, I try not to alienate any gun shop owners if I can help it.

 

[pbslinger]

There are a couple of key issues. The fact that you met the reserve trumps the minor listing error. Did he not know what he wanted for the gun along with making the listing error? Can a minor listing error be a foil that allows a seller to relist in case the auction doesn't go like they want?

I would base your response on what you would want the buyer to do if you had made the mistake. If you feel he is jerking you around from the get go, drop the hammer on him.

If the seller isn't willing to meet a satisfactory solution it may be best to drop it since it might not be worth the trouble.

Auctions aren't really based on fair prices, but if your bid that met reserve is near the value of the gun it should be yours if you want it.