Electric Knife Sharpener

italiansport

Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2007
Messages
3,222
Reaction score
5,336
Location
Arizona
I am having a hard time finding a reasonable quality electric knife sharpener. Apparently, the stores don't stock them anymore and I'm not wanting to order one online with some knowledge of it. I did this a while ago and ended up with a piece of Chinese junk. Please give me a recommendation and a brand if possible plus a location to buy it. Thanks in advance.
Jim
 
The Cabelas store near me has a display of a bunch of manual and electric sharpeners that they will demo for you. If you guys are close enough to a Cabelas it might be worth a shot!
 
A friend of mine says this one is well worth the money. I haven't seen or used it. I may get one.

[ame="https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00S0BEUIY/?coliid=I520MJKVKWQ62&colid=1I5FE19S7O2RV&psc=0&ref_=lv_ov_lig_dp_it"]Amazon.com: Electric Diamond Knife Sharpener for Ceramic Knives and Stainless Steel Knives with 2-Stage Diamond Sharpening Wheel: Kitchen & Dining[/ame]
 
I watched a GURU at Cabela's last year sharpen an elec. knife sharpener.

He gently placed the knife onto the belt an, "Wa La" ..........
the belt went flying !!

Seems that the blade was pointed in the wrong direction,
cutting the belt in half. :eek::eek:
 
When it comes to knife sharpening I've been up, down & back!! I have tried many of the store bought knife sharpeners, many of the systems sold on websites, and everything in between. A bunch of years back I decided to master the art of properly sharpening knives without ruining them or prematurely grinding away metal.

I purchased 3 high quality Arkansas Stones 2" x 10", one medium, one fine and one extra fine and a quart of food grade Norton Honing Oil. It took me hours and hours but one day t just clicked in! I can now sharpen any knife shaving sharp in no time at all! :) For Kitchen knives I use the Fine Stone to quickly bring back a very sharp edge unless my wife has really dulled them. For Workshop and garage knives I just use the Medium and for my good pocket knives, vintage fixed blade Scalpels, Hunting knives and tools I use all 3 in progression.

It takes commitment, patience and perseverance BUT once you "get it" it stays with you and knife sharpening becomes a snap! :)

I have NEVER found any electric or store bought sharpener that was worth anything and if you have fine or expensive knives I'd NOT want to ruin them in such a devise. BTW, sharpening knives by hand is not only highly effective & efficient, it will also allow use of your favorite knives for lifetimes to come since it won't waste the metal by unnecessary grinding.

I suggest looking into Arkansas Stones and check out Dan's Whetstones website (I am not affiliated with them in any way). They have excellent Stones and the will last your lifetime in normal use with proper care.

I have also followed the same path sharpening Drill Bits. No more Drill Doctors or Jigs that never work very well. I do them by hand on a Bench Grinder checking my work with a Drill Gauge. At first - very awkward, but after a while it becomes pretty easy. :)
 
Last edited:
I admire guys who can do a truly good job sharpening knives on whetstones. (Just sharp enough to catch the edge on a fingernail doesn’t count. Even I can do that!)

But I have a local guy in Japan who does terrific work, and take my good knives to him regularly. When I spend time in the US, I bring a couple of good, sharpened kitchen knives with me.

 
I have a local guy in Japan who does terrific work, and take my good knives to him regularly. When I spend time in the US, I bring a couple of good, sharpened kitchen knives with me.
Imagine if you lived in England and tried to do that?
(It’s pretty easy to tell you are living under unjust laws, when you can compare and contrast like that...)
 
Uh...I don't know. I've heard that you don't want to use an electric sharpener on any high quality knife because the heat generated will ruin the temper.

Now, I don't know if that's true or not. I heard that many years ago, so maybe the new electric sharpeners won't do that.

Personally, like chief 38, I stick with the Arkansas stones. Sure, it takes a little longer, but at least I think I can regulate the grind a little better. Of course, that's just my opinion. I've used sharpening stones now for over 50 years, and I guess old habits die hard.

When I touch up a knife, I just sit in the old rocking chair, turn on an old B-Western movie, and sharpen to my heart's content.:)
 
I understand what you are saying about honing and I've done my share with quality hunting knives but in this case we're talking about utility kitchen knives. I just use them for cutting up meats vegetables etc. If a knife wears out I'll just discard it - no great cost or loss. There are a couple that have received good reviews on Amazon that are not particularly expensive so I'll probably buy one of them.
Jim
 
Knives, and sharpening systems has been a hobby of mine for over 40 years. Started out with the high quality Arkansas stones as a kid. I will say, with the new super steels, they just dont cut it. Wicked edge and apex. Style sharpeners do ok, but you will end up with a lot of money invested by the time you get all the stones, so my advice for the guy that wants sharp knives without going too crazy, would be the worksharp sharpener. $100 bucks with some extra belts and your good to go.
But, if you want the sharpest freaking blade possible , go get you a 1x30" belt sander and put a high quality leather belt on it. And buy green and white compound. I'm telling you , there is no better edge than the convex polished edge that this will produce. And fast. I spent something like 8-10 hours with wicked edge polishing ZT blade, and put a better edge on it in 5-10 minutes with leather belt.
 
Electric knife sharpeners remove metal every use, so if You are sharpening very good or expensive knives go on the internet or UTube and learn to use a stone. Your knives will be sharper and will last a long time.
 
Those of you running down electric sharpeners because of heat have obviously never used a Work Sharp. Not at all comparable to the old combo can opener/knife sharpener you are comparing it to. I've got the Lanskey system ( I can sharpen 3 knives by the time the guide rods are set and then changed on that cumbersome newby tool), several Arkansas oil stones, Diamond impregnated sticks, ceramic sticks, butcher steels and a couple of old school grey whetstones. I can get a shaving sharp edge with all but none are as fast as a WorkSharp and none will get a better edge. As I recall, OP was asking about electric sharpeners.

As far as taking off metal, once you have your edge all that is necessary to keep it is a few light passes on the grey belt. 2000 grit as I recall and doesn't take much off, mainly just polishes the edge. Now if you are constantly cutting heavy cardboard or digging dirt it's going to take a more aggressive belt but who uses a good knife like that? :eek:
 
Back
Top