Good deal or bad?

[GARANDY]

I traded the 2" blued US marked Model 10 from 1967 lettered by S&W as one of 3 sent to RIA for testing to be returned to S&W
I got for it a minty lettered Colt Jr. Commando 2" sent to Oakland in 1943

 

[GARANDY]

 

[Legendarylawman]

I would have made the trade.. FWIW.

 

[old bear]

If you are happy that's all that counts..

 

[1Celticfozzie]

I would have done that trade as well.

 

[MajorD]

Both not exactly common, but think the colt is the more rare of the two

 

[444 Magnum]

I think value wise it's an even swap. I would either have bought both or kept the S&W. My understanding is that most of the US marked model 10's were destroyed making a standard issue pistol scarce. One of three sent to RIA for testing would add a premium in my book both in value and desirability. I think it would be harder to find than the 2" Colt.

 

[GARANDY]

My collection is WW2 so it's a no brainer for me