I have noticed out here in Cali. that the same gun with a lock does not sell as quickly or for as much as the same model without the lock. Is this nationwide I wonder? I wonder if S&W is rethinking that lock, they are definitely loosing money on new sales. I am NOT complaining about the lock just making an observation. Do I like the lock, well no but who really does it seems like.
LOCK AFFECTING SALES?
- Thread starter NEURON
- Start date
- Status
Register to hide this ad
bigggbbruce
Member
Among collectors pre lock is first on the buy list.
Every where in the US today any possible source is searched constantly.
I know a pawnshop local that has enough collectable S&W's I'd go broke.
Every where in the US today any possible source is searched constantly.
I know a pawnshop local that has enough collectable S&W's I'd go broke.
Last edited:
BigBill
Absent Comrade
I like both. In nickel it's a plus either way. Older no loc is ok, newer with the loc is good too either way it's s&w history.
Without getting into my preference (which everyone already knows), I'm sure it has affected revolver sales greatly. I have a habit of watching the inventories of certain local dealers very closely. It's amazing to see how fast used pre-IL revolvers sell and how slow a brand new IL revolver will linger. And I'm talking model for model here... not a super popular model vs. a less popular one... and reasonably competitive pricing.
My theory is that S&W has unfortunately backed themselves into a "PC"/cover-your-butt-liability-wise corner from which they don't feel they can easily escape. They can't just suddenly start calling all their revolvers "professional models" and eliminate the IL.
I think folks would see through that sham pretty easily. 
I think it's nationwide. I know many people who, like me, simply will not buy a S&W revolver if it has the lock. I actually did briefly own a 629 with a lock and although it was satisfactory otherwise I could not rid my mind of the worry it would lock spontaneously. So I sold it. The problem is compounded by the fact that S&W originally swore the lock could not cause problems, which of course proved to be a falsehood. I don't think anyone trusts the locks now.
Cheers,
Whisper
Cheers,
Whisper
BigBill
Absent Comrade
When my LGS dropped the prices on the new s&w N frames to $599/$699 the case that was full sold out in no time. Is the loc or the cost?
I can think of no instance where the lock is preferred over none.
When someone says their revolver is a "pre lock" that is a positive selling point.
When someone says their revolver is a "pre lock" that is a positive selling point.
Kernel Crittenden
US Veteran, Absent Comrade
The lock has been with us for almost 15 years now. What ever effect is has on sales is fully "cooked in" to S&W corporate sales and marketing numbers. Obviously, they think the current situation is satisfactory. When you can sale every gun you make, and you're working at full production, what's there to complain about?
SweetMK
Member
In my opinion,,, the lock is having zero effect on the sale of new guns,,
Yea, there is the guy who walks into the LGS and says:
"No S&W revolver with a lock for me, thank you!!"
The problem around me is that EVERY new S&W revolver is already sold before it hits the LGS,,,
The effect the lock IS having is to drive up the cost of "no lock" guns.
That,, is just part of the hobby,,,,
Yea, there is the guy who walks into the LGS and says:
"No S&W revolver with a lock for me, thank you!!"
The problem around me is that EVERY new S&W revolver is already sold before it hits the LGS,,,
The effect the lock IS having is to drive up the cost of "no lock" guns.
That,, is just part of the hobby,,,,
Unless you are shopping for a medium-large frame 5 shot .44 Magnum then the math is:
3 screw with lock & MIM > pre-War > 5 screw > 4 screw > 3 screw pinned & recessed > 3 Screw pre-lock & pre-MIM
bountyhunter
Member
- Joined
- Jan 8, 2002
- Messages
- 1,862
- Reaction score
- 464
From what I have seen, SW is selling their limit and their stock price is way up. Much of that is luck because of the constant panic buying caused by gun control fears from the current administration but I don't see any problem with SW sales.
Their stock price over last five years is up about 10X:
Attachments
Vulcan Bob
Member
For all J and K frames a lock is unacceptable, all steel L and N frame revolvers locks are acceptable. I think the high prices on the new ones are the problem, you can get a no lock vintage model in most cases for less.
I've owned a couple w/the lock and it was never a problem. Eventually they were sold b/c the lock is just ugly and spoils the lines of a classic firearm. I would never carry a lock revolver for self defense, the idea that it could go wrong at the moment of truth is just too much for me.
gnappi
Member
Personally I don't care about the lock. I shoot what I buy. Give it time... when even lock guns become scarce all of a sudden they will become ok.
Jingles
Member
I hesitated for years before buying a gun with a lock. I probably missed out on some good guns. I still hate them, hate being forced to wear a helmet, wear a seatbelt, etc., but if I want to play the game I follow the rules.
That said I still prefer pre-locks, but it is because I think that era were made with more craftsmanship. I also hate our Cali LCI, but I got over that too.
That said I still prefer pre-locks, but it is because I think that era were made with more craftsmanship. I also hate our Cali LCI, but I got over that too.
Good point... the prices on the S&W at my LGS start at $800+ and goes quickly North to the $1800 mark for the 500 Magnums. They haven't moved, but it's a different matter for the Rugers.
I also think the issue might be more of S&W's quality control issues soiling their reputation that the lock. 5 years ago the forum was dominated by lock related posts, now you're more likely to read about a new gun having a non-lock issue right out of the chute affecting functionality/performance.
Clocked barrels, canted front sights, large groupings...
Last edited:
clayflingythingy
Member
- Joined
- May 22, 2010
- Messages
- 40
- Reaction score
- 25
OP,
Go look at the Annual Manufacturers & Export reports. Your idea is not supported by the data.
https://www.atf.gov/resource-center/data-statistics
Go look at the Annual Manufacturers & Export reports. Your idea is not supported by the data.
https://www.atf.gov/resource-center/data-statistics
DocB
Member
Yeah, the lock has hurt sales on the revolvers, as well as all the other major changes they made during the 1990's. I stop my buying around 1992-1993 when the changes were about to begin. With the semi-autos, they are what they are. They were taking off in the early 1990's. There wasn't a lot to change from or to. Although, I do prefer an old WWII German P38 to all of them even though they are bit heavy.
- Status
Similar threads
