I was one of the many beneficiaries of CrazyPhil's recent Monumental Holster Extravaganza. Among holsters I acquired is this Alessi:
I bought it for a K-frame, and it does well with my M10 and M65. But it shines, is a perfect fit, for my Colt Three Fifty-Seven, a gun that I have been looking for a suitable CCW holster for quite a while.
With the 357, the sights and hammer, as well as the frame, fit into the holster perfectly. Zero wiggle. In fact, even if the pull through snaps aren't snapped, the holster, with the 357, passes the hold-upside-down-and-shake test.
Alessi was not first with the pull through approach — there is an earlier discussion of this here on the forum — but he sure executed it well. I read somewhere that the snaps are of a special design so as to only unsnap when pushed apart from one side, in this case when the hammer pushes up against them, seperating them during the draw. I think it would be difficult for someone to snatch your gun from this holster.
There is a bit of initial resistance if not pulling strongly, but during an intentional draw, I don't think most people would notice it.
While I don't know, I suspect it is made of horsehide. (The leather is similar to a Kramer pocket holster I have that I know is horsehide.) It is of excellent quality.
Thanks, Phil, My Three Fifty-Seven and I are very pleased with this holster:


I bought it for a K-frame, and it does well with my M10 and M65. But it shines, is a perfect fit, for my Colt Three Fifty-Seven, a gun that I have been looking for a suitable CCW holster for quite a while.
With the 357, the sights and hammer, as well as the frame, fit into the holster perfectly. Zero wiggle. In fact, even if the pull through snaps aren't snapped, the holster, with the 357, passes the hold-upside-down-and-shake test.

Alessi was not first with the pull through approach — there is an earlier discussion of this here on the forum — but he sure executed it well. I read somewhere that the snaps are of a special design so as to only unsnap when pushed apart from one side, in this case when the hammer pushes up against them, seperating them during the draw. I think it would be difficult for someone to snatch your gun from this holster.

There is a bit of initial resistance if not pulling strongly, but during an intentional draw, I don't think most people would notice it.
While I don't know, I suspect it is made of horsehide. (The leather is similar to a Kramer pocket holster I have that I know is horsehide.) It is of excellent quality.
Thanks, Phil, My Three Fifty-Seven and I are very pleased with this holster:

Last edited: