This is a devilish thread. I didn't see it when it first came up, but I have read all of it now.
OK guys let's hear it.
What is your personally most desirable Pre Model marked Smith? And why?
That's a tough question. I am a collector and shooter of S&W revolvers, the vast majority being pre-model marked, yet I can't make a simple answer. The question calls for the choice of one gun and then asks the reason.
Would it be the gun I prefer to shoot above all others?
Would it be the most rare one?
Would it be the most expensive one?
Would it be the one hardest to obtain?
Would it be my favorite handgun caliber?
Would it be the best for home defense or for carry?
Jeez, how do you decide this question?
I suppose it must be the one left in the gun safe if the gods declared all must go away but one. That's how I interpret this question.
I have this exquisite Model 1955 Target (pre-25). It came with its original diamond target stocks, all in pristine condition. I did one better: I had Keith Brown make me a set of Roper stocks of English walnut. And here it is:
It's not the rarest, not the most valuable, and not the oldest I own. But right now if I had to keep just one this is it.
Tomorrow I might have a different choice. Let's be thankful the gods allow us to have more than one!
Curl