My tenant says that I'm "unrealistic".

Joined
Nov 24, 2003
Messages
4,313
Reaction score
4,943
Location
CNY
I went down to my rental property yesterday to get something out of the garage. I see one of my tenants on the front lawn with a little pit-bull puppy on a leash. Cute little thing. I said to her she should have asked me before getting a pit-bull. Her answer was that I never told her she couldn't...and besides...she's already got cats and the other tenant has two dogs (Jack Russell and Shih Tzu). I said that's different. They're not pit-bulls. She asked if she's supposed to call me and ask what breed of dog she can own. I said "yes". She said that's "unrealistic". And she said she's keeping it. I think I'm about done with being a landlord. 30+ years is long enough putting up with this ****.
 
Register to hide this ad
We have a pure bred American Staffordshire Terrier... She is the sweetest and most gentle dog we have ever owned. And she absolutely loves our grandchildren!. Don't judge your tenants dog differently than any other dog breed. They are wonderful pets. Stereotypes shouldn't be applied to people either.
 
I rent out my house in Hawaii. Have a no pet policy that one tenant broke. I let her keep the dog but used her security deposit to clean up after she left.

I think it is reasonable to have a pet policy, and reasonable to ask a tenant to pay/keep deposit money for pet caused damage if the policy is broken. I don't think it's reasonable to ask tenants to seek a landlord's approval for breed of dog if pets/dogs are allowed.
 
The potential problem is the owners insurance policy having a 'dangerous dog list' on which bulldogs are always #1. Something happens, and the owner is sucked into a lawsuit involving the dog because he is the 'deep pockets' target, his insurance company may be able to void their coverage.
As the owner I wuld immediately check the policy to see if it has a dangerous dog prohibition clause. And if you don't have one already, it is relatively inexpensive to carry a 1M or 2M umbrella policy to protect you from anything and everything.
And there is no finer insurance company than USAA, available to all vet's and their immediate family. Great prices, great support.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, that's a tough one. I used to be a land lord and had a "no pet" policy. Not because I don't like animals but because they can make a huge costly mess, especially cat urine on wood, if the owners don't train them properly.
As far as pit bulls go, their evil reputation comes from owners that train them to be aggressive.
I have a half Pit Bull/Black Lab male and he is absolutely the most friendly and funny dog I have ever owned. It's how you train the dog.
Having said that, I personally would never be a landlord again. I'd rather deal with animals instead of people in todays world.
 
i have two full blood pits and one half pit and half dogo argetino and they are very loving and great dogs would trust them with any of my young family its the owners that dont train them right or dont watch them right that are the problem
 
I went down to my rental property yesterday to get something out of the garage. I see one of my tenants on the front lawn with a little pit-bull puppy on a leash. Cute little thing. I said to her she should have asked me before getting a pit-bull. Her answer was that I never told her she couldn't...and besides...she's already got cats and the other tenant has two dogs (Jack Russell and Shih Tzu). I said that's different. They're not pit-bulls. She asked if she's supposed to call me and ask what breed of dog she can own. I said "yes". She said that's "unrealistic". And she said she's keeping it. I think I'm about done with being a landlord. 30+ years is long enough putting up with this ****.
Go pay to have her evicted.

Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk
 
Go pay to have her evicted.

It's a difficult situation. Her older sister lives in the other apartment. It's a duplex. Older sister has actually expressed interest in buying the house from me. I just put almost $10,000 into having the two full bathrooms, one on each side, fully remodeled. I told her that I need to get an appraisal. I guess I've been dragging my feet on that.
 
I don't know why the horror of pitties. They're sweet as long as the owner doesn't mistreat them. I've had 2 pit mixes and my friend has 4 purebreds . Nice although a little "wound", but heck they're terriers. Not too may dogs like to be swung around by their teeth.:D

My MIL owns several rental properties and unless you specify, preferably in the lease, you don't have much recourse. Especially you let the other tenants keep dogs.
 
Last edited:
Without a lease or rental agreement in writing there is little the property owner can do.

Personally, my response at the next renewal would be something like "I will continue to be unreasonable while you get used to being homeless", or perhaps a 100% increase in rent with a stiff damage deposit.

Re: above comments about insurance policies; I did thousands of property inspections for insurance companies over several years. Every major insurance company of which I am aware WILL DECLINE a policy, or REFUSE TO RENEW a policy, if they find that there is a dog of several different breeds kept on the property (either by the owner or by a tenant). I once inspected the same house for 4 different insurance companies, and every time I showed up the same 4 American Staffordshire Terriers (pit bulls) were in the yard and behaving aggressively, easy to photograph and document for the underwriters.

Insurance policies are contracts providing specific coverages in exchange for payment of premiums and owner's agreement to abide by contract provisions during a specific policy period. Coverage exclusions are common, specific dog breeds are frequently mentioned, and any dog displaying aggressive behavior may be grounds for declining to issue a policy, for terminating an existing policy, or renewing an existing policy. When such specific exclusions exist all risk of loss passes directly to the property owner.

Edit: One more quick thought; For those who have mortgage loans on their properties, should you ever find yourself without a current property insurance policy the bank or mortgage company might just invoke their contractual rights to call the loan due and payable immediately.

I doubt that 3 people in 100 have ever read their insurance policies or mortgage contracts from start to finish, but there are a whole bunch of terms, conditions, and remedies spelled out in detail.
 
Last edited:
Not wanting to accept that dog as the landlord is a problem if a pet policy wasn't spelled out to the tenant at the beginning and isn't in the contract. I've lived in places before where it stated that "pets are subject to approval by the landlord".

If you don't have that, a dog is a dog and unless you can document that this dog will be a material problem unlike the ones you are already tolerating, you haven't got a leg to stand on.

It would be a bit like a landlord telling tennants they can only keep revolvers and shotguns because he doesn't like "black rifles".
 

Latest posts

Back
Top