Need some help picking a EDC revolver and caliber.

[smoore]

I don’t edc, not allowed in my country, so I am not in,fluenced by personal preference. My thoughts are that before deciding what to carry you need to work out a few other things first.



Number 1, as quoted above, get yourself a good belt. I picked up a couple of DeSantis E25 belts from Midway, just a short drive from St Charles, for under $25 each when I passed through last year, and while I don’t carry a pistol I use them daily on both my uniform and casual dress trousers. Even if you choose not to belt carry the belt will be worth it as you will need to carry ammo etc and the belt/pockets are the logical place to carry.



Number 2, how will you carry. Belt? Pocket? IWB? OWB? Shoulder? I visited St Louis in the first week of November and it was cold, wet and windy, but at other times of the year I understand it gets hot and muggy. Pocket or IWB seem to me to be the places to start. That lead to:



Number 3, choose the size of the revolver that you know you can carry concealed according to your location. J frame? K Frame? Larger? Other manufacturers equivalent?



Then and only then, would I start to look at gun options.



And get a decent holster too. Even if you are pocket carrying (especially if pocket carrying and you have a handkerchief, keys etc in the same pocket.



As far as caliber goes, many years ago I read the following, the best .38 Special round will be equal to an average 9mm in stoping power. The best 9mm equal to a lower level .357 magnum.



Finally practice regularly (at least monthly) with some decent g enrich “budget” ammunition and fire off the 6 rounds you have carried since you’re last practice session. Reload with the rounds you have acarfied as spare and replace them out of the box.



Personally, given the OP I would be looking at that Ruger 9mm SP 101. Six rounds of top line defense 9mm with another six on my belt or in my pocket and I’d feel just as secure as when Ihave my G17 on the belt at work.

Lots of good info and suggestions there. Thanks.

I did end up buying a reenforced leather gun belt. It didn’t work by its self as good as the belt I was using. It did allow me to use some suspenders which I can use to hold the weight of the gun, and not have to tighten my belt until my eyes start to bulge out of my head. This combined with an updated iwb holster helped me carry my PPQ easier. Main problem I ran into was one there is no way to ever not feel that I am carrying. It is also something that I would not wear every day. Also the suspenders make wearing the gun uncomfortable while setting at my desk. But while walking bending and any other activity I tried wearing the gun was good. I am sure I could come up with a combination that works best if I kept trying. Since I decided on the 637 38 special I didn’t put any more effort into carrying the PPQ. So far I have carried the 637 in a desantis pocket holster. This one is slightly too large for this gun, but it does cover the trigger, and even the hammer. I have a holster coming from the store I purchased this from. The guy that knew where it was, wasn’t in today so I have to get it later. Depending on what it is, I may buy another pocket holster and a iwb holster for it. I will probably switch between the 2 methods for my daily carry.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Lu..]

I used to go through belts like water until I got an indestructible belt from Bullhide Belts. Have been using the same Hercules belt for the last 5 years and it looks like a brand new leather belt. Highly recommend it.

Hercules Belt - Virtually Indestructible Non Leather Belt - USA Made – bullhidebelts

When I pocket carry, I use a sharkbite holster for my 442 and use Perry “trucker” suspenders.

SHARKBITE™ Pocket Holster

Perry Suspenders - Perry Products

Very comfortable and don’t have to readjust my pants the entire day.

 

[smoore]

I used to go through belts like water until I got an indestructible belt from Bullhide Belts. Have been using the same Hercules belt for the last 5 years and it looks like a brand new leather belt. Highly recommend it.



Hercules Belt - Virtually Indestructible Non Leather Belt - USA Made – bullhidebelts



When I pocket carry, I use a sharkbite holster for my 442 and use Perry “trucker” suspenders.



SHARKBITE[emoji769] Pocket Holster



Perry Suspenders - Perry Products



Very comfortable and don’t have to readjust my pants the entire day.

Thanks again. The belt looks nice. I will put it on my list to try if I order more belts



I got a pair of those Perry Suspenders, the rough and tough ones. I like them, but I should have ordered the tall. I will probably order a pair of the tall to try out.



I also Like the holster and will put it on my list of possible purchases. I am also looking at the desantis pocket tuk one. It is a pocket holster that can also be used IWB. Looks like a good concept, if it functions well. I also looked at the clip grips, but I prefer to have the trigger covered. And I like my current grips one it. Before I buy a holster for it, I want to see what they have for me. my luck is what ever one I buy will be the exact same as the one they are giving me for free, or possibly the free one will be a nicer more expensive one. Of course this will only hold true if I buy one before getting theirs. If I wait, it will be one I don't like and is not worth wearing.

This is what I currently have it in. It is larger than it needs to be, but it works for now. The size might actually help the gun disappear in my pocket. Last night at least 4 times I forgot I had it in my pocket. Part of that reason is I used to keep my cell phone in that pocket. Since I had the gun there I put my phone in my left pocket. 3 times I went to pull my phone out and realized it wasn’t my phone. One time I started to put my phone back and realized I had something in that pocket already. Part of this is habit of carrying my phone in that pocket, part of it was the gun doesn’t feel much different from my phone, size and weight. While the gun is heavier, it is light enough that with out thinking about it, it feels about like my phone.

 

[smoore]

Just a quick update. I have been carrying this every day for almost a week. I have been using the pocket holster pictured. For 2 days now I have used a desantis pocket-tuk holster wearing it IWB. I can’t decide which way I like it more. IWB or pocket. It seems to disappear in which ever way I carry it.

I have not gotten a chance to shoot it yet. Maybe next weekend. I have been using the laser trainer and target to improve my trigger performance and practice aiming, along with drawing and aim on target time. Right now my time to draw and put a shot on target is pretty bad. It will improve though once I practice drawing it more.
Thanks again for all of the help! You guys really helped me settle on this gun, and so far I love it!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[elm_creek_smith]

Well, IWB and I don't get along. Hired Hand suspenders, a 5.11 Double Duty belt and a Bianchi 7 holster keep my Model 65-1 from dragging my pants down as I move and sit and stand and move. I put new wooden service grips and a T-Grip on the former police issue .357 Magnum.
I've been wearing suspenders since I started suffering from Noassatall Syndrome.

Sent from my XT1710-02 using Tapatalk

 

[rubiranch]

I just put some smooth Combat stocks on my 640-1 .357. I like them soo much I started carrying it instead of my 642-1 .38 Special +P.

My 642-1 is an Airweight and has had nothing but +P ammo.




This Galco holster works really well for me too.




Occasionally I will carry my M&P 4.5" .45.

 

[Fortcouragearmory]

Just to add my $0.02 worth, my EDC is an S&W 442. Light enough to carry every day. Strong enough to handle +P ammo (I carry 158-gr +P JHPs in mine). Hammerless design so you could pocket carry if you like. Accurate, reliable, and convenient.

 

[smoore]

Quick update. Picked up that Dan Wesson, and changed the grips.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[smoore]

This is the closest I have gotten to shooting my new guns.

S&W 637

Dan Wesson 15

This is on a 2” target standing back about 12’ using my iPhone target app, snap caps, and a universal laser trainer.

Just thought I would share. [emoji1303]


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[ABPOS]

That is great!!!

A big part of shooting handguns well is recoil management. And even more so with snubbies. But dry firing seems to help me too.