Self Defense Can Sometimes Go South In A Hurry

semperfi71

US Veteran
Joined
Nov 8, 2006
Messages
2,675
Reaction score
1,116
Location
Central New Mexico
I am not attempting to resurrect a closed thread.

The incident in Florida is horrible. It personally has troubled me as a long time ago I was involved in a situation whereby I was prepared to use deadly force and was justified. And then the situation rapidly evolved into a scenario of which I had never thought of.

I would like to share it with those who come here for “concealed carry” purposes. I think a lot of our LEOs here will agree with me in my final analysis.

In 1977 I was 24 years old, married with two young kids and living in a four-plex with a lease agreement. We had peeping tom who would not go away. Instead he got worse and was coming around more often and even had our telephone disconnected. I had the police involved but they could not catch him. I decided I had to defend my family alone. I had the semi-official approval of a police captain. I had the law, of the times, firmly on my side. I was going to be armed and if need be prepared to shoot. I did not want to do this but I felt I had no choice. My family was in danger and we were tied to the apartment via a lease.

So I set a trap by waiting outside the apartment after dark, armed and ready, to confront the “Peeper”.

The whole plan went awry from the get go. Nothing happened as I thought it would. I was not able to be “stationed” where I had planned to be to ambush the “Peeper”. I got rained on as I waited in the next door apartment complex to ambush the “Peeper”. I ended up having an irate, drunk with a half empty beer bottle verbally coming after me with his wife (ex) and young son in tow from the same next door apartment complex. And I was armed. My wife almost shot the couple’s son as he left them to peek into our bedroom window as his father was arguing with me. She was armed. The manager of the next door apartment complex got involved, and thankfully he defused a bad situation.

I was, at that time raised in "Old South Texas", which means a man forks his own broncs and doesn’t ask for help if he doesn’t need it. Additionally I had lived several years in the "Out West" where a person handled his problems alone. I was now a “country-boy” living in a big city and unaware of how different things were. It was not my ego that placed me in this situation. It was my lack of experience, my genuine fear for my family, and my resolve to handle my own affairs as a responsible “man” should.

Nothing went as planned and everything went wrong. And, if I had shot a peeping tom I would have been shooting someone who really, probably only needed a serious whipping. And I almost had to shoot a drunken fool in self-defense. And my wife could have shot a young kid whose parents were inattentive fools and of whom my wife should not have been “staged” by me in the bedroom watching out the window waiting for the “Peeper”. We were all a bunch of fools.

Later we moved anyhow and I reflected on the incident and still do. I probably could have talked to the landlord and been moved out of the lease due to the dangers. If not I should have moved anyhow. At the least I should have moved my family out a.s.a.p. I had other options and did not consider them because I was not prepared or “trained” to consider them.

The reason for this long-winded discourse is please be careful. The incident in Florida is horrible. It will probably happen again.

Our society has gotten too ramped up over "crime", "concealed carry", and "self-defense". I think that sometimes the fears are outweighing the actual risks. However at other times we see or hear of some horrible incidents that shake our souls. Those of us who have ownership of, and carry firearms must be very diligent. It can be too easy to go for a gun.

Please be careful of your mindset. Don't go somewhere if you think you have to go armed. Go elsewhere or come back later when it is safer. Even if you are armed let the law handle it, even if they show up late. If someone is stealing your car stereo, let 'em. You can buy another, but you may not be able to buy out of the trouble and mental anguish you will suffer from a shooting, even a legal one. Especially in today’s society.

I have firearms. I sometimes legally carry them.

But I never, ever want to shoot someone.

You will not and do not know how it will ultimately come down.
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
Upon first starting to read semperfi71's post I thought "oh, wow." But then semperfi71 nailed it.

Great post...spot on in every respect.

If only everyone was as wise.

Be safe.
 
The NRA's Personal Protection Inside the Home course I took more than a decade ago, and all the "gurus" of note I've read/watched are nearly unanimous in their emphasis on avoiding shooting situations if humanly possible. A concealed carry license is not a police badge or a hunting license. I regard my civilian status as a great blessing that almost always entitles me to walk (or run) away from trouble. Those confused on this most elementary point are mighty poor candidates for a carry license.

The Florida tragedy is, fortunately, exceedingly rare. However, I'm concerned about the "ride" we're all going to get in its aftermath. The demagogues are rising like cluster flies.

PC
 
Honesty and wisdom are two virtues that are sadly in short supply these days. Thank you semperfi for a thought provoking post.
 
Great post -- I am a lawyer, retired colonel, proficient with weapons -
and was the chief legal architect of the first ever iraqi federal criminal court (the CCCI -- the Central Criminal Court of Iraq) -- we were in the RedZone every day and I constantly had to remind my young troops that we had to follow the ROE and show restraint -- same thing applies in civilian life -- we live in a very nice neighborhood , have been plagued with vehicle and home burglaries in our area -- our home has not been burglarized but our vehicles have been four differrent times. The crime epidemic in this country does have good middle class citizens on edge -- yet one still has to weigh all of the potential consequences. My wife is an excellent shot, Ole Miss honor grad, and she is fed up with crime -- I have no doubt she is more than the equal of any burglar or potential carjacker -- she is level headed and has a great job and I have had the "talk" with her that she has to very carefully weigh the circumstances if an encounter occurs -- yet make a decision in perhaps a very short time. It all comes down to common sense. We have a very strong Castle doctrine in Louisiana and a "no retreat necessary" which I do think is a good legal doctrine. Very good protection if protecting yourself and loved ones at your home, on your property (even if outside, as long as you are on your property) and in your car, wherever located. Best rule is don't go chase someone down off your property if they have not committed a felony.
All in all, liked your post.
 
  1. A gun is not a substitute for clear, rational thought.
  2. Clear, rational thought is not a substitute for a gun.

The police simply are NOT going to protect you or your family as individuals.

That being said, there is no good purpose in CREATING a deadly force situation when one did not exist.

When I was a kid in Chicago, I witnessed a burglary/vandalism incident from my bedroom window. I told my father who called the Chicago PD. When they showed up and found out that the perpetrators were White teens in a newly Black neighborhood, they simply drove off without taking further action. In response, my father did NOT go looking for the suspects.

We did our part. If the cops chose to do nothing, it was on them, not us. It wasn't a deadly force situation and there was no point in taking action which could have caused it to turn into a deadly force situation, especially given that it wasn't our home or property broken into.

I don't carry a gun because I want to be a cop. I carry a gun because I know the police won't and CAN'T protect me as an individual.
 
Best rule is don't go chase someone down off your property if they have not committed a felony.
I wouldn't chase somebody down even if it WAS a felony, certainly not unless it was a VIOLENT felony and other people were in IMMINENT danger of harm.

Would I chase Mohammed Merah down and shoot him in the head? You bet, every day and twice on Sunday.

Would I chase somebody who stole a $10,000 watch out of a house? Not happening.
 
Good information

On many forums, if you read between the lines, you sometimes sense that there's a prevailing, subconscious urge to shoot/kill someone as the ultimate right of passage. I advise people to always work within the law. Attempting to investigate a crime or series of crimes skirts very close to vigilantism and can only lead to monumental legal and financial problems.

Also, any "off-the-cuff" advice or solutions offered by LEOs should not be taken seriously. If you indeed follow their advice, will they show up at your trial to testify for you? Know the use-of-force laws wherever you carry a gun.
 
Also, any "off-the-cuff" advice or solutions offered by LEOs should not be taken seriously. If you indeed follow their advice, will they show up at your trial to testify for you? Know the use-of-force laws wherever you carry a gun.
FBI agents exempted, if they had law degrees, they probably wouldn't be cops. The frequency of misstatement of, and sometimes disdain for the law I've personally witnessed or heard of by cops is truly astonishing.

If you think you may have heart disease or cancer, you don't talk to somebody from the IT department at the hospital. You see a doctor.

If you want to know the law, you ask a lawyer, not a cop.
 
This may be more of a lament than anything; I certainly am not, nor do I want to sound like a trigger happy fool, but there's something not right about the demise of the " justice of the Old West". When you read some of the statements in this thread, you realize how much our society has genuflected before the liberals, PC crowd, and criminals. It has become wrong, in this Country, to defend your property and possessions, because " you can always buy a new one" or " that's why I carry insurance". People live in fear in neighborhoods because the local abandoned house has become a dope den and the same set of laws that can't put it out of business will slam terrorized neighbors in jail if they take it upon themselves to run the scumbags out of town on a rail.
COL jagdog, listen to what you say about ROE and restraint with regards to your "...young troops...". I was one of them in 1968. We heard the same ****. I've got a suggestion to the Military Brass. If the civilian government wants you to go to war with imposed " no fire " zones, tell'em you're not going to put your soldiers in that position! Don't fight a war with " conditions". War is hell; live with it or don't get into it. You can't fight a nice war!
Why do we allow our elected officials to write laws that make US to be the criminal if we stand up and defend what is ours? WHY? When we do this we embolden the thugs and the criminals ( just like " gun free zones".. what a joke ). When the first time criminal gets away with it, he becomes a second time criminal and so on. When we impose" no fire " zones on our troops , we tell the enemy we're not serious about whipping your sorry rear ends!
In short, we seem to have given up our " life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" in order not to offend the bums and ne'er-do-wells who prey on us like helpless victims. It takes away my ability to live my life in tranquility because I must be constantly alert not to get ripped off and constantly alert not to over step the limits placed on me by my own government to protect me and my belongings.

Thanks for listening, yawl!
 
I agree that the initiator of this thread is spot on. I carry daily and while I am prepared to pull the trigger (I think/hope) I pray to God that I never have to.

Part of the responsibility of carrying is avoiding situations where you may need your gun. Massad Ayoob covers this very well in his excellent book "In the Gravest Extreme". Recommended reading for anyone who carries a gun or keeps a house gun for defense.
 
Good post, and good advice.
I like "The whole plan went awry from the get-go".:D You were, in a way, conducting surveillance. Everybody who ever watched The Rockford Files thinks surveillance is always easy, and exciting. Uh, no, it rarely is easy, is usually boring, and things often "go awry". I speak from experience, as I have conducted thousands of hours of surveillance as a Private Investigator. Some idiot will always get in your line of sight, and you always have to have a good story (lie) ready to tell somebody about what you're doing.:rolleyes: Plus the weather rarely cooperates. I've done it in temperatures ranging from -11 degrees to 100 degrees.
Sounds exciting, doesn't it? You got a taste of it on that rainy night. Glad you lived to tell us about it.
Jim
 
It would absolutely never occur to me to 'lie in wait' for a suspected peeping Tom so that I could shoot him.

And your local police gave you the nod for this plan?

In many jurisdictions, 'lying in wait' is an aggravating circumstance that intensifies the potential punishment.
 
It would absolutely never occur to me to 'lie in wait' for a suspected peeping Tom so that I could shoot him.

And your local police gave you the nod for this plan?

In many jurisdictions, 'lying in wait' is an aggravating circumstance that intensifies the potential punishment.

I have been told twice by local officers to"just shoot em and drag em inside!" Dont expect them to stand with you after you do it and they will deny having told you so!!!!!!!!!
 
I have been told twice by local officers to"just shoot em and drag em inside!" Dont expect them to stand with you after you do it and they will deny having told you so!!!!!!!!!

While that may sound like a good idea, I'm betting that bloody drag marks from a corpse will give away the fact that the perp did NOT die in your house. There may be some questioning.... :p
 
Back
Top