Wanting to build a Model 58 .45 Colt....Any pointers?

Major George Nonte was a proponent of converting Model 58's to .45 Colt and .44 Special back in the mid 1970's and wrote about his efforts in the gun magazines of the time.

I think this would be similar to what you are looking for:

standard.jpg


standard.jpg


standard.jpg


standard.jpg


I ran across this gun in a pawn shop in north Texas about 10 years ago. The conversion was done by Spokhandguns, which is no longer in business. Vern Ewer, owner of Spokhandguns, did a wonderful job on the conversion. One of the smoothest actions I have felt. Barrel length was 3 1/4".

The biggest negative was that the cylinder was too short for the 454424 or 255gr RCBS KT bullet to be seated normally in a full-length .45 Colt case. That was the bullet I was loading at the time and it worked fine if seated deeper or if .45 Colt cases were shortened.

I also had a 625-6 Mountain Gun in .45 ACP, 4" barrel, of course. The 454424/RCBS KT could safely be loaded to equivalent velocities in the two guns, about 850 fps over my Oehler chronograph.

Comparing weights, the two guns were within one ounce of each other. I forget which was the heavier. With both guns being round butt and of equivalent weights, the only drawback to the MG was the 3/4" longer barrel. The longer barrel did provide a longer sighting radius, and I preferred the adjustable sights on the Mountain Gun.

I hope this info helps you in deciding what you want to do.
 
The original cylinder for the Model 58 was the same one used in the Model 57 and the same length as the Model 29. It would have handled the 454452 seated normally

Spokandguns made some really excellent customs.
 
Another suggestion is To buy a HE 455, many have been reamed to take 45 Colt. I have 2 and both were cheap and shoot good at defensive ranges. Also Brazian 1917s are a good starting point for conversion.
 
I think I am going to cry. And not a happy cry, either. Gorgeous, and I am glad you own it, but I have to ask "Why not just buy a Lew Horton and be done with it?"

Please understand: this is not ridicule. I am just sincerely wondering why you would do that to a Model 58 S... To me there are other options out there.

But again: it is gorgeous, and I suspect truly one of a kind.

My thoughts exactly! 58s are hard enough to come by. Doesn't look like money is problem.
Steve
 
My next big project will be taking a Model 58 and making it look like a PC13-4 on steroids, including the MagNa porting. I will leave as the .41 Mag though.

bob
 
Back
Top