Who Uses a Hogue S&W Cylinder Release?

[Jon651]

No offense meant in my reply in any way.
I am not so sure it is all that practical for EDC.
1)Snagging of course is a huge issue.
2)Showing up in court to explain that a modification was required to reload beyond factory means.
3)If you dont have the dexterity to push on the factory thumb latch, I would dare to question the ability to reload 6 in a firefight.

Youmight wish to reconsider to a semi auto.

While I agree with #1 about snagging, I'm not buying it on #2 and #3.

As for "modification beyond factory means", my rationale is the factory release is more difficult and therefore for me may lead to accidents or just being unintentionally careless - neither of which I want. An easier release means I don't have to use more force and/or concentration in performing a simple action, which would be safer.

Plus the factory is not the ultimate arbiter in producing the best gizmo to do the job. They also have additional concerns ranging from "does it look good" to "which of the available options is cheaper to produce", none of which concerns me.

As for reloading quickly, there is a distinct possibility that I can reload FASTER with Hogue extended release - but if I need more than six rounds in a firefight then I'm either carrying the wrong gun or in the wrong place at the wrong time.

And as for a semi-auto that is as easy to use as a revolver, I also own a S&W 380EZ - but now you are getting into the age-old dispute between "9 rounds of .380 ACP vs 6 rounds of .44 Special" (and similar comparisons), and that is not what this thread is about.

 

[CH4]

You might try Tony Rumore's Extended Cylinder Release Latch. It's only $25. It's larger and easier to use. I have one on my model 69 and really like it because I have arthritis in my hands and it makes the cylinder a lot easier to open. The website is tromix.com.

Interesting design. It nicely covers the IL

Smith & Wesson Extended Cylinder Release Latch - Tromix Lead Delivery Systems

 

[GaryHK]

Interesting design. It nicely covers the IL

Smith & Wesson Extended Cylinder Release Latch - Tromix Lead Delivery Systems

Looks like it doubles as a Hilary Hole (I hope we are allowed to say this) cover...BONUS!!!!

 

[Revolver Man]

I do!

I use them on my 929, 627-5, and my 6" 617 that I all shoot Steel Challenge with. I also shoot USPSA with the 929. I really believe that I can open the cylinder faster because of them, than with a factory release. It's definitely personal preference, but I was hooked after I bought my first one. For everyday carry, I wouldn't use one. For competition, always.