You have $800 to spend and no S&W revolver yet but want one...what do you get?

[Jdavis]

If the OP is asking for revolver recommendations, I would suggest looking for a nice model 28-2 with a 6" tube. The longer barrel 28 will complement his 4" model 66 very well allowing him to shoot unlimited full power loads. If he is not asking for a revolver, the M&P 9mm Performance Center models would be an excellent choice. The ammo is cheap and plentiful which will allow him to enjoy it all the more.

 

[reddog81]

We need more clarification... I'd assume he's looking for a 1961 to 1980 S&W revolver based on the subforum and that the post title is a typo.

If it's truly within that timeframe then 686 isn't an option. I'd vote for either a model 17 or a 29 depending on want kind of shooting you do.

 

[arjay]

lots of good options.If the op really means not an S&W,I'd get a colt

 

[Stopsign32v]

Didn't the OP state no S&W revolver???

I mean as in if you didn't own one but were looking to get one

 

[Arik]

But there quality has slipped as of late. Why are there so many threads on the topic?.

Because the Internet didn't exist the way you know it today until around 2000 +/- a few years


Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk

 

[ralph7]

I'll throw my hat in the ring for a .22 as well.
An 18 or 617 would be nice for target practice, but a 34 or 63 snub would be a cool carry gun in the woods.

 

[sodacan]

The way I read it is that the OP wants a S&W revolver, but doesn't know that a model 66 is one.

 

[deyomatic]

Another for a Highway Patrolman/ Model 28.

I see the word "yet" in the title, so I take it that the OP wants input on which S&W to get.

 

[Jim L]

since the OP cleared things up & changed the wording of the title
S&W 686+ with 2 1/2 0r 3 inch barrel. But check the revolver over well for flaws & quality.
Also I stand by my Ruger Redhawk (short barrel) choice.

 

[lebomm]

Didn't the OP state no S&W revolver???

Actually, he said "no revolver yet, but want one". Then later says "...only revolver I have is a 66 no dash....".
Hmmmmmm, don't quite know how to read that.

Larry

 

[fdw]

Anyone that recommended anything other than a S&W needs to sign out and go elsewhere.

For the OP, you need to evaluate your shooting interests. Target, competition, self defense, hunting, etc. There are S&W revolvers to suit just about every shooting situation. One of the most versatile, fun, guns is the Model 17/617 .22RF. It has provided the most enjoyment for shooting to thousands of shooters for 85 years is one form or another, as a K Frame 22 RF.

I'm a big Smith fan but if I was buying a revolver in that price range it would be:

Ruger Redhawk .44 Mag 5 1/2" Satin Stainless (KRH-445) $782.00 SHIPS FREE)

And sorry, I'm not going to take my ball and go home...

 

[pharmer]

I still see nice N frame revolvers under $800. They ain't collector grade but still make an owner proud. Joe

 

[Jim L]

Actually, he said "no revolver yet, but want one". Then later says "...only revolver I have is a 66 no dash....".
Hmmmmmm

Larry

he changed the title ( which cleared it up)

 

[Stopsign32v]

S&W 686+ with 2 1/2 0r 3 inch barrel. But check the revolver over well for flaws & quality.

Could you give some examples? Why not just buy a new 686+

 

[Stopsign32v]

Actually, he said "no revolver yet, but want one". Then later says "...only revolver I have is a 66 no dash....".
Hmmmmmm, don't quite know how to read that.

Larry

It's not that serious. I did that to avoid a super long thread title. My mistake, I apologize.

 

[RKmesa]

For $800 +- $100

Q: What would I get?

A: One of these...





The long-tube 27's are in my opinion one of the nicest shooters and probably the most elegant revolvers ever produced by S&W (or anyone else for that matter - although a nice SAA is hard to beat...).

Good luck,

 

[Jim L]

Could you give some examples? Why not just buy a new 686+

I meant a new 686+ (short barrel)
As far as quality, check the finish, check the timing, check end shake, check cylinder gap check that your grips fit well etc etc

 

[ameridaddy]

I'd go for a Model 19...2 1/2" barrel.
Blued or Nickle.
Masterbuck54

Or a 4" bbl. Get an older one. I think the value will go up, and you will love either one.

 

[BCDWYO]

I'll throw another vote in for a 4" L-frame in 357 mag...(686, 586, 681, or 581). Hard to beat the versatility and durability.

 

[TIMETRIPPER]

A K22 of some sorts. Or maybe a nice J AND K frame 38 Special as in model 36 and 10.
Having variants of both, plus a few others, I personally be looking for a 44 or 45 caliber N frame.

John