".a renaissance of interest in revolvers. . ." Michael Bane. You think that's true?
- Thread starter dwever
- Start date
HorizontalMike
US Veteran
I don't do "pistolaros" so I am NOT sure of what you are talking about. Bought my first revolver in 1986 and still have that and a few other revolvers. IMO, you must be confused... or having buyer's remorse because you bought into the wrong fad, or sumpin'... 
You need therapy, but there is still a chance you will see the light... Only time will tell...
You need therapy, but there is still a chance you will see the light... Only time will tell...
HOUSTON RICK
Member
I hope so, but I have not seen it. I am almost always the only one with revolvers or wood stocks on the firing line, either of which are items of wonder for the younger shooters.
HorizontalMike
US Veteran
BTW, in my CCClass of ~40, only I and the instructor had a revolver for carry. ALL of the others had pistols, yet there was quite an interest in seeing my little SW642. You woulda' thunk it was gold plated...
Birdgun
Member
I can't argue with one thing Tim said. All is true. Well said, Tim!
For me, there is just something "more" about the revolver which the plastic semi-auto just doesn't have. It's hard to explain and I'm not dumping on semi-autos. The best I can come up with is this: A fine revolver has a "soul."
Silly, I know. But to me, it's one of those irrational intangibles.
Maybe someone more poetic than me can explain it better.
Last edited:
snowman.45
Member
The older I get and the longer I'm retired, the more appreciate my revolvers. Maybe I'm just getting nostalgic for the the old days, but I carry a J-frame (640-1 or 340 M&P) more than anything else. I recently got a Shield .45 and really am impressed with it and the way it carries and shoots. However, I still prefer the .38/.357 or .38 J-frames.
Mistered
Member
Lot of potential reasons for a resurgence of interest in revolvers but I am hoping it's a move toward 'quality' shooting and accuracy as opposed to just 'slinging' as much lead as one can with a semi-auto. Personally where I live am seeing a lot less of 'black gun' shooters out in the woods than I used to and quite frankly I hope a lot of the 'fad' aspect of 'black guns' is waning. Price of ammo is no doubt one reason for the interest but I am certainly hoping it is a move back to the interests of 'traditional' shooting with revolvers, levers and bolts once again becoming the 'norm'.
Bullzaye
US Veteran
Thanks!
You said it well...if not "poetically".
I believe that at least part of the attraction, for me, is the mechanical complexity, and the more "manual", less "automated" operation of the revolver. It's the same as enjoying a fine mechanical watch, such as an IWC, Bell & Ross, or the like...or appreciating a fine automobile or motorcycle. One enjoys the intricacies of the mechanism, and appreciates the artistry and craftsmanship that went into its construction. We find Bugattis, TVRs, Paganis & Lotus to be fascinating cars, even though they are impractical on many roads, for most of our daily needs...and we'd rather have a Patek Phillipe mechanical on our wrists than a Timex digital, even though the Timex is 1/100th (or less) of the cost, and likely more accurate.
Tim
jessebogan
Member
I like accurate guns. (Not that I am the best shooter mind you). But I also think anyone that collects guns should have a 1911, and a Garand...I have mostly revolvers in my very modest collection. But I have 3 22 cal autos, a 92F and I just had a chance to handle a S&W model 52....Oh my! I have never shot a plastic pistol of any sort. Not that I wouldn't, just haven't. Heck I like guns. Some I like better than others I guess, but I have only ever had one I actually disliked. I disassembled it and thew the parts in a pond...
Mistered
Member
My take on guns:
Steel is REAL
Blue is TRUE (but recently three SS guns have came my way and I can 'adapt' - but they are still STEEL)
Wood is GOOD
Steel is REAL
Blue is TRUE (but recently three SS guns have came my way and I can 'adapt' - but they are still STEEL)
Wood is GOOD
Qc Pistolero
Member
Most new shooters show up with a semi-auto;it generally is in 9mm and of the polymer frame type.They post a target at 5 or 7 yards and start peppering it.Most will show up 4 or 5 times a year.Those who really get the shooting bug will pretty soon walk up to any oldtimer shooting a revolver at 20 or more yards away and eventually ask to try it.
Pretty often,these guys will show up a few weeks after that with a wheelgun,95% of the time a .357Mag.My last such guy tried my 586 no dash and showed up a couple weeks later with a brand new 586.
I like semi autos,even own half a dozen of them(all steel frame though)but a revolver doesn't balance the same in my hand.But then,I'm only an oldtimer!!!
Qc
Pretty often,these guys will show up a few weeks after that with a wheelgun,95% of the time a .357Mag.My last such guy tried my 586 no dash and showed up a couple weeks later with a brand new 586.
I like semi autos,even own half a dozen of them(all steel frame though)but a revolver doesn't balance the same in my hand.But then,I'm only an oldtimer!!!
Qc
A few years ago I got my 1st pistol.
I didn't want to get to fancy on my 1st handgun, so I ended up picking up a new Springfield XDM 4.5 in 45 ACP.
I like it. It feels good in my hand, accurate, fun to shoot.
A few months ago I decided to added a Revolver to my little collection.
I made a trip to a LGS, struck gold w/o knowing it, and adopted a used S&W Model 66-6 F-Comp.
I went a few years between purchases after picking up the XDM. A few months after getting the Model 66, Im already thinking about getting another Revolver. They're just more satisfying to shoot IMO.
I didn't want to get to fancy on my 1st handgun, so I ended up picking up a new Springfield XDM 4.5 in 45 ACP.
I like it. It feels good in my hand, accurate, fun to shoot.
A few months ago I decided to added a Revolver to my little collection.
I made a trip to a LGS, struck gold w/o knowing it, and adopted a used S&W Model 66-6 F-Comp.
I went a few years between purchases after picking up the XDM. A few months after getting the Model 66, Im already thinking about getting another Revolver. They're just more satisfying to shoot IMO.
Mistered
Member
I recently bought these from an estate sale - to go with the ones I already have - any question about interest in revolvers?
Another series of Dirty Harry films might help. 
Seriously though, Bullzaye summed it up very well. There will always be a nostalgic desire for revolvers, and a few who like them because they are different, but we are living in a semi auto world and always will. 50 years ago, who would have ever thought Colt would one day stop making revolvers? Likewise, 50 years ago, who would have thought that semi autos would become 75% (give or take) of S&W's production numbers? Who knows, in another 50 years, none of the major arms companies will make revolvers, and the gun magazines will be talking about whether Start Trek type phazers will replace semi autos if makers can increase battery life to provide more than one or two shots.
Seriously though, Bullzaye summed it up very well. There will always be a nostalgic desire for revolvers, and a few who like them because they are different, but we are living in a semi auto world and always will. 50 years ago, who would have ever thought Colt would one day stop making revolvers? Likewise, 50 years ago, who would have thought that semi autos would become 75% (give or take) of S&W's production numbers? Who knows, in another 50 years, none of the major arms companies will make revolvers, and the gun magazines will be talking about whether Start Trek type phazers will replace semi autos if makers can increase battery life to provide more than one or two shots.
Its All about the J frames for many ccw holders
I have autos and revolvers. I like the simple drill and ammo variabilty of a 357. My wife likes the simple drill of the revolver and has trouble pulling back the slide on a 9mm. I have a feeling many of the new CCW permit holders (many of them women) like the light,cheap, simple to use J frames. In my LGS Smiths start at about $400.
Me, to carry in my pocket, it would be a 360j. If I'm expecting trouble its going to be a 9 shot 9mm or a 8 shot 45.
I have autos and revolvers. I like the simple drill and ammo variabilty of a 357. My wife likes the simple drill of the revolver and has trouble pulling back the slide on a 9mm. I have a feeling many of the new CCW permit holders (many of them women) like the light,cheap, simple to use J frames. In my LGS Smiths start at about $400.
Me, to carry in my pocket, it would be a 360j. If I'm expecting trouble its going to be a 9 shot 9mm or a 8 shot 45.
I recently bought these from an estate sale - to go with the ones I already have - any question about interest in revolvers?
You got your primary and your back-up there. A police officer from 1976 would feel right at home with that battery. Very nice and congratulations.
GCF
Member
That pretty much nails it...
I was the only revolver in my CCW class in 2005, and I was the only in my class again this year. (I had to take the class again due to letting my permit expire)
Outside of this forum, most people are very surprised I carry a revolver.
Outside of this forum, most people are very surprised I carry a revolver.
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
