Yeah, it probably won't blow up your gun. Probably.Scare tactics leave a lasting impression. I got your point. However...
Yeah, it probably won't blow up your gun. Probably.
But then, how much does a foot of brass rod cost vs. the cost of a barrel?![]()
...because...the barrel is not supported against high pressures as well as in the cylinder area? Possibly. I would think the pressure would be lower at the stuck squib because of the distance from the throat and the cylinder/barrel gap. Especially if the charge was the same or less. This would need to be proved in a scientific laboratory type condition before I venture to clear a weapon in this fashion.Assuming a squib to be a round fired leaving the bullet lodged in the bore, the use of any charged case brings the nasty possibilities of either a bulged barrel or a ruptured barrel, possibly with fragmentation effect in the surrounding area.
I wouldn't use Hatcher's method in a handgun. Using a rod and hammer is much better. However, I have used Hatcher's method (pulling the bullet from another round and dumping out about half the powder charge) on several occasions in rifles, and it works fine. And in fact it is preferable to using a rod and hammer, as there is no possibility of damage to the bore.
Confused with your statements and borders on "fork-tongue".
"Using a rod and hammer is much better."
" And in fact it is preferable to using a rod and hammer, as there is no possibility of damage to the bore."
No. Blanks are quite powerful, contrary to popular belief. A number of people have killed themselves by putting a handgun to their heads and firing a blank. There is enough pressure there to put a hole in a skull and turn the brain to mush.
Best is a brass rod about bore diameter. Or a steel rod with a brass tip about bore diameter.
I concur.....As a professional instructor of over 4 decades....30 of those as a LE instructor ( and armorer).....I have seen my share of lodged projectiles, particularly from handloads.....have carried a brass range rod and mallet in my range kit since the 70's.....had a young lady pound four lead bullets up the pipe of a Ruger Sp 101 during a citizen NRA pistol class once....the 4th bullet lodged in between the cylinder and barrel...tied up the cylinder....which was fortuitous, since the 5th round had a full powder charge in it.....took a trip to the machine shop to solve that conundrum.
AS AN NRA CERTIFIED INSTRUCTOR MYSELF, FOR OVER 30 YEARS, I MUST QUESTION THE LEVEL OF SUPERVISION (OR LACK THEREOF) THAT WOULD ALLOW A YOUNG STUDENT TO PUMP 4 CONSECUTIVE SQUIB ROUNDS UP THE BARREL OF A REVOLVER, WITHOUT INTERVENTION………
I'm a bit nervous about putting a steel rod down the bore. Depending on the length inserted and flex, you can still bugger the muzzle. I've seen steel cleaning rods, but I've always been hesitant to use them.
I don't like putting anything down the bore that is as hard as the barrel steel.