Do I really need a shield?

M

miles71

Member
Joined
Aug 3, 2009
Messages
290
Reaction score
40
Location
Harford County Maryland
Ok, I know this isn't a good question to this crowd, but I need to think this through. They have a 9 mm shield at my LGS for 450.00. I can probably talk them down a bit but do I really need it? I was shooting my M&P FS today along side my old 4013. I am impressed with the M&P but the old 3rd gen did just as well. I also already have a 3913, which to me is the old grand dad of the shield.

I know some places have shields for a little less, but in my area you have to add about 50-75 dollars on top for shipping and transfer fees. Plus there is the whole 9 vs 40, but that's another story.

Thoughts? Talk me down boys!
TD
 
Register to hide this ad
The prices on them have come down quite a bit that I've been thinking about getting a 3rd one. Not really much help.:)
 
"More stuff!!!"
Isn't that your signature. Besides this is the wrong place to come to get discouraged from buying a S&W M&P. I love both mine.
 
Not needed. Have you shot one? You may not like the size. I for one don't like subcompact guns, and don't have an issue concealing mid or full sized guns.

Yes, I have shot a few Shields. I don't want one, but still kinda want one. LOL

Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk
 
My advice?

Read all input here, then make the decision based on your likes, comfort and lifestyle.

Me..I have one, my first true ccw pistol. Love it. I have a g19 that could also fill the bill in cooler weather, but it rarely gets cold enough here to wear more than two layers.
 
For CCW, you can't beat the 3913. I was at my LGS and fondled the Shields and although I got excited about maybe purchasing, in the end I really didn't want it. (Or need it) I do have a FS in 357/40 and find it easy to carry/conceal should the spirit hit me. Keep your ca$h and carry your 3913. Additionally, I really don't feel comfortable with a cocked and locked striker fired weapon at my side. Hence, the spirit to carry my FS MP has never moved me.
 
Last edited:
I have a shield 9 an I love it, carry it iwb and owb pretty comfortable sometimes forget I have it on. Very accurate right out the box without any mods

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I747 using Tapatalk
 
ShieldGlockS_W_006.JPG


I bought two 9mm Shields back in May, one for my daughter and one for my daughter-in-law. The Shield is a neat gun, especially when it is given to you, LOL!! I have been carrying and shooting my daughter's Shield, and it is a fine gun. I also own a 3913, my second one. I sold a 908 to buy my first 3913, and found out I liked the 908 better as it was slimmer due to the single side safety. I later traded for a 3953, which is my favorite 9mm CCW that I own.
 
Simple answer, go shoot one. When you get a big ole grin on your face you'll have your answer. Should you not get the big ole grin on your face, again you'll have your answer.
 
Nope! You definitely don't NEED a Shield, but you definitely SHOULD have one! ;) You'll NEVER regret it. :D
 
I am only 1 gun away from having enough guns at any time. Yes you will like a Shield, I have a 4.25" FS 40 and a 5" 40L CORE to go with my 40 Shield. It will be the best $450 you will spend.
 
never confuse WANTS with NEEDS...two completely different things...you only want something if you can't afford it...buy it and be happy...:)
 
miles71 said:
I know some places have shields for a little less, but in my area you have to add about 50-75 dollars on top for shipping and transfer fees. Plus there is the whole 9 vs 40, but that's another story.

Thoughts? Talk me down boys!
TD
Click to expand...

I'm not gonna try to talk you down at all. My wife asked the same question "Do you really need another gun?"

Anyway, maybe I can save you a few bucks. This is where I got mine.
SMITH AND WESSON MP9 SHIELD 9MM PISTOL @ Sportsmans Outdoor Superstore: No tax and free shipping. Ordered Monday night and had it in my hands Friday morning. And that was with Christmas in between. My transfer fee was only $25 tho.

If you are LEO, Active Military, Military Reserves, National Guard, or retired military(with credentials), you can use their IPO program and get it for even less. EMTs and Firefighters too.
 
Last edited:
Need..... No you don't need it. But since when did need have anything to do with it. If you want one get one. Me, I'm waiting on the .45 version.... and no I don't need one. :)
 
Sounds like your already pretty well covered for CCW. Still, " The heart wants what the heart wants. " You might try seeing if you can find a used one first or even borrow one to shoot.
For myself, I was dyeing for one until I owned one. People either seem to love or dislike the shield.
 
As suggested, try to handle and shoot one if possible. I also have a 3913, and would definitely not replace it with a Shield. However, I've shot a Shield on two occasions and did quite well with it. It's not a bad pistol.

With the sub $400 prices online leading up to Christmas, I likely would have bought one if the $50 S&W rebate hadn't excluded it.

Everyone is different though. My wife shot the Shield yesterday and after one mag put it down a said, "I don't like it".
 
Rastoff said:
There's no need for a Shield if you have a full size.
Click to expand...

Rastoff

I take it you are ok wearing layers of clothing throughout the year to conceal a full size handgun.

For most people that is not a reasonable option. I work inside and wearing layers of clothing is not practical especially in the summer.

My Shield rides in my pocket in all seasons and at 7 yards shoots just as tight as my full size XD 45.


Russ
 
I'd been Pocket Carrying the PF-9 for 4 Yrs and was looking for a replacement. With the Shield being almost the same dimensions, only 6oz heavier than the PF-9, as smooth as my G26 to shoot and the same price range as an LC9, it fit my requirements very nicely. If I didn't Pocket Carry, I might have never tried the Shield... But I did try it and I totally love the little rascal.

My Wife on the other hand, was a devout Glock hater until she tried the G26 and has been carrying that for a few Years now. When she tried my Shield, her comment was simply: "It's a very nice little pistol, but not enough to replace my little Glock.".

To each their own. As mentioned, it seems like people either Love the Shield, or are Unimpressed with it. Some are more than happy enough with just their FS, or Compact, to NOT add the Shield to their stable, while others have replaced something in their stable with the Shield and still others had added the Shield simply because it's there.

Don't just fondle one at the counter... Actually shoot one and decide it you like it enough to put 4 Benjamins on the counter. :)
 
Need is very subjective. Do I need a car, shoes, my pinkie toe? Not really! Do I want those things, YES. Does one need a Shield if one already has a good comfortable cc weapon?

I say if you are asking to be talked out of it then you should just buy one, carry it for a month. If you are not happy with it then sale it. You don't see many on the used market for long. If you can't afford one then don't buy it. I personally wouldn't pay over 400 out the door for one.

Second on the, didn't need one but bought one, and glad I did so.

Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk
 
I was in a gun store a few months ago and they had a sign over the counter that fully explains your issue....."Need Has Nothing To Do With It"

So I say if you want it, go for it and don't look back. It just felt right in my hand and after 400 plus rounds I don't regret buying one.
 
I'd buy another in a heartbeat if I had the money. I don't need two but I want two. One for each hand. More rounds is better right?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

D
SHIELD X Series??
Replies
8
Views
496
Beju
B
D
PC M&P Shield RDS compatibility?
Replies
2
Views
312
Beju
B
Redcoat3340
Shield Plus and 4566 TSW: Question & Comment
Replies
0
Views
117
Redcoat3340
Redcoat3340
D
What affordable sight pusher most people use for their Shield sights.
Replies
22
Views
952
DartonJager
D
D
First impressions of my new optics ready 3.1" Shield Plus 13+1 2.0
Replies
1
Views
310
M1A4ME
M1A4ME

Latest posts

Back
Top