Originally posted by hoser:
Started an investigation and also spoke to someone at the post office near my house. She said she'd look around.
If I paid for this holster, is seller responsible for insuring it and making sure it gets to me? I understand him not wanting to insure something that's only $50, but since it's lost, who technically should "eat" the cost (for the record, I always insure things I sell for this reason)?
I regularly ship out products using USPS first class mail with delivery confirmation. First class mail travels with Priority Mail, so there is no added benefit to Priority Mail in delivery time or service. I have had only one incident of a "lost in the mail" item in which the customer came across as absolutely sincere (other items had been taken from his mail around the same time), so I replaced the lost item at no charge.
On the other hand, I have had a few incidents in which a customer claimed not to have received an item, then I check the delivery confirmation on the USPS web site and get the delivery date and time, report that to the customer, and get a "Oh, yeah, my wife put it in the closet".
Is seller required to replace. I don't think so. The transaction was known by the buyer to involve delivery, so some degree of risk is reasonable to assume.
Is seller required to insure? No, not unless the buyer wishes to pay for that service. USPS parcel insurance on a $50 item is $1.70 (3.4% of total sale price, which means that a seller would be making every 30th holster just to cover the insurance costs).
Most homeowners' insurance policies provide coverage for personal property away from the home. But few of us have deductibles that would make a $50 claim a real option.
After saying all of that, personally I prefer not to have unhappy buyers, so I would do my best to reach an amicable agreement with the customer. Just as long as the customer was being reasonable I would try to accomodate the customer. But when I am being pushed, I have been known to push back!