Model 625, to buy or not to buy?

T

thunder23js

Member
Joined
Jun 25, 2009
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
I have my eye on a 625-4 5" barrel with box and papers, they are asking $560 otd. It appears to be in great shape, is this a good price or should I hold out?

Wasn't really looking for this gun but the .45acp revolver definitely seems like it would be a fun gun to have.

Thanks for any input!

Jody
 
Register to hide this ad
I wouldn't let my 625-2 go that cheap. They are desireable guns and it probably won't last long at that price...
 
Just bought a 625-8 5" <$500.00 otd. Love that pistol, buy it you can always "turn it" if it is not to your liking. Keep in mind the extra's, Moon clips, loader, de-mooner, man it seems like it never ends. But worth every penny..:D

Demooner

Moon Clip Loader

Moon Clips
Have fun and be safe

Clint
 
that is a very good price they are going for $650 to $700 now some going for that don't have the box
 
Nope, You do not want it.:) If I had the cash, this pistol would of already been sold. Buy it while he still has it so I can move on. I was going to offer a trade, but noticed he is looking for cash. So if you get it and do not like it, I have a Sig 220 compact tu-tone DAK.
 
Last edited:
I just recently paid $550 for a 625-6 Model of 1989 and would do it again in a heartbeat. It's a really nice revolver.
 
My experience has been that they're pretty hard to come by - especially at a good price like that. The 5.0 inch barrel is very desirable - I wanted one when I bought my 625 years ago, but settled for a 4.0 inch barrel. I'd get it quick if I were you, I don't think you'll be disappointed.

Regards,

Dave
 
I'll go along with the buy it sentiment. The 625 is an immensely popular revolver and it shows in the trend I've seen in my track of the 4-inch version. The 5-inch was ruled out of some competition and started showing up in some numbers a few years ago.

The four inch version has become more popular and my track is the non Jerry Miculek version no longer manufactured. So the pricing and trend shown in the track & chart below are probably high for the 5-inch version, but probably not by more than $50-$70 would be my guess.

Smith & Wesson 625 Revolver in .45 ACP, 4-in Bbl. Bluebook of Gun Values (30th Edition) indicates between $550 in 98% condition and $650 in 100% condition for this gun. I have 38 recorded prices for this model gun from $400 to $750 over a period of 6 Yrs 0 Mos ending May 31, 2009. The average price as of that date was $529. No refurbs, no refinishes, regular sights, all represented as 95% or better, no distinction for engineering revision, if any, no special editions, no distinctions for box, papers, tools. Current or last MSRP is $988.

Here's the chart:

SW625200905.jpg
 
thunder23js said:
I have my eye on a 625-4 5" barrel with box and papers, they are asking $560 otd. It appears to be in great shape, is this a good price or should I hold out?

Wasn't really looking for this gun but the .45acp revolver definitely seems like it would be a fun gun to have.

Thanks for any input!

Jody
Click to expand...

Buy it!
Or send me the dealer's contact info.
I have a 3" 625-4 and would love to have the 5" to go with it.
WFR
 
I have both a 4" 625-8 JM Special and a 5" 625-6 Model of 1989 and neither of them will leave my hands until they bury me. They are WONDERFUL shooting tools!

Dale53
 
Check out item no.26291 at Bud's gun shop. 4 in. 45 acp for 652. delivered. Non JM model 4 inch.
 
The 5" barrel version of the 625 is no longer being made. These versions are very highly coveted by the USPSA shooters. The -4 is probably the best variation out there. No lock, no MIM and no frame mounted firing pin. All three of mine will fire without moonclips. There is no excuse for NOT buying this revolver.

Dave Sinko
 
Thank you Gentlemen, the response is overwhelming! I pulled the Trigger last night and will pick it up tomorrow.

Thank you for all of the advice and look forward to sharing some pics.

Regards,

Jody
 
Sorry, I should have done this sooner, here's a picture of my Model 625 wearing CT laser grips and a fiber optic front sight. Yeah, I'm a geezer, but even without my glasses and in poor light, if you're within 30 feet, things could get - eh, a bit interesting. She's a real tack driver and a soft recoiling pistol.

Best of luck,

Dave
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1109.jpg
    IMG_1109.jpg
    77 KB · Views: 123
deanodog said:
Check out item no.26291 at Bud's gun shop. 4 in. 45 acp for 652. delivered. Non JM model 4 inch.
Click to expand...
That's what I have. Bud's must have had it in inventory somewhere because S&W hasn't offered it for a couple years as far as I know.
 
If a person does not need the power/penetration of a 44 Magnum, I think a S&W revolver in 45 ACP is the best choice.
 
The price point is what it is worth to you. I have seen a bit less and many a lot more. I feel very, very, lucky to have found a 625 in 3 inch. 45acp about two weeks ago. Price was $855. Had an urge and went to Lightning Arms and there was a set of Spegel Extended Grips and there went another $175.

I retail and have for about 30 years as part-time funds to pay for my addiction to the shooting sports. You may spend a bit more and maybe a bit less over time. But after 30 years of retail as a second job, I have learned the value to me, NOT price, is what is important.

If you want it and feel you can have fun and enjoy it, that is a great part of the value.

Now on the 625's, I now have three. A Mountain gun, I use on my bike, pedal jockey not motor, for dog's both four and two legged. I am in meth, drunk and moron country sometimes when I ride.

I have a four inch that is in the house and have a blast shooting. Download, upload, change bullet weight and do not have to play with springs like my 1911's.

They are addictive and what else to watch out for is the accessories. :eek:

Best if you decide.
 
thunder23js said:
Thank you Gentlemen, the response is overwhelming! I pulled the Trigger last night and will pick it up tomorrow.

Thank you for all of the advice and look forward to sharing some pics.

Regards,

Jody
Click to expand...

I recently paid $630 for a 5" 625-4 on gunbroker and I would do it all over again with no hesitation.
That is a very desirable gun and they are getting difficult to find.
Congrats.
 
Pictures?

You guys have me jonesing for a 5" 625 in .45 ACP.
Is the general consensus that the "-4" is the best one to town?
What other dash #'s are desirable?
I have a 3" 625-4 and want a 5" to go with it.
Thanks!
WFR
 
WFR said:
Pictures?

You guys have me jonesing for a 5" 625 in .45 ACP.
Is the general consensus that the "-4" is the best one to town?
What other dash #'s are desirable?
I have a 3" 625-4 and want a 5" to go with it.
Thanks!
WFR
Click to expand...

I think most will agree the -3s and -4s are the most sought after.
Many will also say the 4" models have more value due to IDPA regs on barell length.

Personally, I'd jump on any pre lock 625 I could get my hands on for a fair price.
 
From what little I know, about the guns and the fact I own a 625 three inch barrel (just got it), 4 inch barrel and also a mountain gun, I would say, get a pre lock of you preference of barrel, length. Two are -3's and one is -6 (mountain gun)

Functionally between the -2, -3, -4, -5, -6 and what ever, for use I do know that much difference other than firing pin and when MIM was started to be used. Again, I am not qualified for technical differences. I just prefer the prelock's maybe they look or feel to me to be a bit better built.

I am not a purist, but functionally yet to have an issue. Between the two 4 inch guns after close to 1000 out of each. I have not fired the 3 inch enough yet but I really, :D like it.

The biggest issue is this unique items reproduce at the most in opportune times. :eek: They love to feed on plastic cards that hide in wallets, sheet of paper in checkbooks, and just madly consume the government debit cards (formally called cash before the stimulus plan) ;)

Best in your choice.

Be safe and keep the brass flying

Terry Peters

Do your research but you get what you pay for front end or back end.
 
This 625-2 Model of 1988 5" is one of my favorite revolvers. It's easily the most accurate. I have modified this one with a red ramp front sight and Ahrends retro classic stocks. After an action job by Nelson Ford of Phoenix, it is hands down the smoothest double action revolver I own, and I have a classic Python that doesn't even come close. Note the overtravel screw on the trigger. Single action let off is like breaking the proverbial glass rod with virtually no perceptible movement. It fires even military cartridges without the clips if necessary. Ford calls this the "Cadillac of Smith revolvers" and I'd have to agree. I bought the original gun in 2005 for $525 and have never regretted it.

625.jpg
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

pools350
  • Locked
WTB: 625-? MG, full, tapered lug. 45acp. What's out there?
Replies
2
Views
614
maxx
M
BCDWYO
Found a 45 acp Mountain Gun
Replies
15
Views
3K
BCDWYO
BCDWYO
mic214
Mountain Gun conversion....
Replies
11
Views
3K
CWH44300
C
PALADIN85020
The ultimate .45 ACP revolver?
2
Replies
41
Views
11K
OK Hog Shooter
OK Hog Shooter
M
7 shot .357 mountain gun-BUY?
Replies
9
Views
7K
Az. revolver fan
A

Latest posts

Back
Top