Serious question on recoil.

Straightshooter2

Straightshooter2

US Veteran
Joined
Oct 14, 2011
Messages
2,580
Reaction score
2,546
Location
South of Gritville
Three years ago, I had quite extensive right shoulder surgery. What started out as a simple 45 minute rotator cuff repair ended up 2 1/2 hours with scraping the underside of the bone because of calcium deposits, trimming ligaments that had frayed and taking care of a highly inflamed shoulder joint. Just to give you an idea of how bad it was, it was 2 1/2 years before I could even sleep on my right side. Bad enough that I had to sell my Garand, my highly customized 03-A3 Springfield that would drop a deer like you hit them in the head with a hammer. Along with the 30-06's, I sold my Model 94 30-30 and my 942 Remington Woodsmaster. Believe me, I DON'T want to pull the trigger on anything .30 caliber.

So here's my question for the huge knowledge base of this forum. I'm looking for the least recoil in a rifle that can still take a deer (legally). Sure a headshot from a .22LR will take a deer but it is highly illegal in Georgia. What I'm looking for is a rifle that won't leave a deer dead in the field and me in the deer stand eating narcotics because my shoulder is on fire. What is the recoil like on a 25-06 or such. Especially since I have a LARGE amount of 30-06 brass. BTW, my Woodsmaster was a semi auto .243 and that was still too much. I prefer a bolt gun for the field (yes I know more recoil). How about a 22-250)

Am I basically in a Catch-22 situation. To take a deer legally do I need something with some recoil and to do it without recoil I would be illegal? I would appreciate ANY input.

Oh, and before anyone suggests it, I CANNOT shoot left handed. I can barely scratch my posterior left handed.

Thanks,
CW
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
Rifle weight could be a help. Some of the heavy barrelled varmint guns in 22 hornet have the recoil of a .22 mag.
 
If I were in your position I'd start shooting left handed. With practice in can be done and it's not that hard to learn. The only other option that comes to me is a muzzle loader in something like a 45 caliber, with enough mass in the gun they can have a fairly mild recoil that is more of a push than a punch.
However, if a 30-30 is too much I really think your only option is shooting left handed.
 
How about trying a lever in a pistol caliber?

Marlin makes a nice one in .357 and I used a 94 Winchester in 45 long colt for SASS matches years ago.

Shoot all day long without pain.
 
A .243 Winchester to me is very mild and is quite adequate for deer. I know some who use a .223. With the .223 I'm inclined to think that well placed broadside shots would be preferred.
 
I am right-handed. However only my left-eye works. So, I shoot left-handed. In 1985 I bought a Rem. 700LH in .30-06 Springfield. This same rifle is available in .270 Winchester and 7mm Rem. Magnum. My rifle has been outstanding producing MOA or less groups with factory and handloaded ammunition. With modest loads recoil is of not concern. Loaded heavy it will handle anything in North America. For the nasty stuff that can bite, claw, chew... I'd just load it with some nice black-tipped AP... i.e., the stuff that makes cover into concealment. I would also suggest you look at a M-1 Garand. I have several that I have bought through the CMP. They are superb in every possible respect. My first Service Grade rifle routinely averages 96-97 at 100 yds. from a standard prone position. Of the bench it never leaves the 10 ring. I have used M-1 rifles for deer hunting on numerous occasions. They are outstanding. If you wish to mount a rifle scope, it is a simple matter to replace the rear handguard with a base (AMEGA, etc.) and then mount a extended eye-relief scope. It is a very fast easy to use set-up for hunting. With a low-power scope it is ideal for heavy cover where fast repeat shots might be required. With a higher power or variable power scope, it works very well for longer more deliberate shots. HTH. Sincerely. brucev.
 
I am left handed but right eye dominant. I can't do ANYTHING right handed. Years back I forced myself to start shooting from my right shoulder and now it is as natural a thing as if I was a righty. It CAN be done, it just takes practice.
 
If you cant handle 243, I doubt 25-06 would be doable. Possibly 7mm-08, but it will be close to 243. If your interested I have bolt guns in 25-06 and 250 Savage I could meet up with you and let you shoot. Then you'll know if those calibers are tolerable. PM me if your interested.
 
I've always found the 6.5 Arisaka to have very mild recoil. Which makes me think of all the 6.5 Swedes that were imported a few years ago. I guess a bolt action 30-30 would be too obvious a choice?
 
Get yourself a heavy barreled AR or an M1 carbine and some 5 shot mags.

I've got a 20" HBAR A2 rifle with a 1-9 twist barrel...and it's a tack driver with 62gr softpoints. The rifle weighs about 9 pounds...no recoil

The M1 carbine is a short range deal..but most deer hunting is too. has a bit more felt recoil than the AR..but not much.

So just what's legal in your state?
 
A now deceased friend of mine had extensive shoulder injuries from an accident. I don't know whether it was as bad as yours, but he suffered like hell from it and shooting HP rifles or shotguns were out of the question. He bought a lever action .44 Magnum for a brush gun. I seem to remember it was a Marlin...maybe a model 39? That seemed to work well for him.

He later had an Ithaca damascus double barrel SxS shotgun customized, lined for .357 Maximum. It will fire .38, .357 Mag and .357 Maximum for bigger game. I bought it from him before he passed away and it sat in my safe for years. It sat there so long, I even forgot it was chambered for the .357 Max until another forum member was kind enough to send me a casing to chamber. It has become my favorite all around rifle. The recoil is almost non existent. The .357 Maximum is mild recoil, but a little more than the magnum and louder. Downside...it's heavy, over 11 lbs. Hope you feel better and find a solution. Good luck this season!

Cheers;
Lefty
 
I use a .250 Savage. Recoil is mild but I am not sure it is less than you got with the .243.
There are some .30 caliber wildcats made on the .223 case that might be lighter recoil.

Can you use .223 in your state? Some big bucks have been taken with it in my area. It wouldn't be my first choice but it might work with careful shot placement.
 
I've shot a dozen or so whitetails with the .222 Rem. and it did just fine. All shots were at 40-75 yards and to the heart/lung area. But hand loads are a must with any of the .22 center fire cartridges and bullet selection is critical. You'll want to keep muzzle velocity as high as accuracy allows and keep your shots to under 100 yards. The light .22 caliber bullet depends on shock to kill and needs high velocity at contact to do so. After 100 yards they start lose velocity rapidly. Also, most .22 cal factory loads are made for varmint shooting and are thin skinned for rapid expansion but there are heavier jacketed bullets available for the hand loader. For deer, I use Sierra's 55 gr spitzer and load to a muzzle velocity of just over 3000 fps. The Sierra bullets held up well and even went through both shoulders of one young buck at about 50 yards. Dropped him like a ton of bricks. The .223 and 22-250 cases should work even better as you can up the velocity. But don't even try to take a shot through brush, they just don't cut it as a brush buster!
The 6.5 Swede is my favorite deer cartridge. It's a great caliber but if you have problems with a 243 it ain't gonna work for you. Have you tried using a shoulder pad? I know from experience that there is a whale of a difference in felt recoil when shooting my 30-06 or 6.5x55 while wearing a T-shirt or all decked out in winter hunting togs, which is a thick Woolrich jacket plus three layers of clothing underneath!
John
 
I found a recoil calculator that may help you. I'm a data-driven type of guy....

Recoil Calculator at HuntAmerica.com

I ran an example with an 8 pound rifle in .44 mag and the felt recoil calculated at 5 pounds. Not bad.

You can play with this and compare loads you used that hurts to other loads, and maybe get a good WAG for a rifle/round combo that could work without a bunch of actual testing-ouch.

Best of luck to you.
 
brucev said:
I am right-handed. However only my left-eye works. So, I shoot left-handed. In 1985 I bought a Rem. 700LH in .30-06 Springfield. This same rifle is available in .270 Winchester and 7mm Rem. Magnum. My rifle has been outstanding producing MOA or less groups with factory and handloaded ammunition. With modest loads recoil is of not concern. Loaded heavy it will handle anything in North America. For the nasty stuff that can bite, claw, chew... I'd just load it with some nice black-tipped AP... i.e., the stuff that makes cover into concealment. I would also suggest you look at a M-1 Garand. I have several that I have bought through the CMP. They are superb in every possible respect. My first Service Grade rifle routinely averages 96-97 at 100 yds. from a standard prone position. Of the bench it never leaves the 10 ring. I have used M-1 rifles for deer hunting on numerous occasions. They are outstanding. If you wish to mount a rifle scope, it is a simple matter to replace the rear handguard with a base (AMEGA, etc.) and then mount a extended eye-relief scope. It is a very fast easy to use set-up for hunting. With a low-power scope it is ideal for heavy cover where fast repeat shots might be required. With a higher power or variable power scope, it works very well for longer more deliberate shots. HTH. Sincerely. brucev.
Click to expand...

This is the EXACT situation that I was faced with several years ago. I lost an eye due to a stupid accident, and was forced to change over to shooting left handed. It was not a hard adjustment to make, just a lot of practice. Even carrying the gun had to change. Go to the range and try it out. Believe me, recoil will be no more of a problem than it was before your surgery.
 
I'd think about a CZ in 7.62X39mm.
Not much recoil in those guns and good deer gun out to medium ranges.
JM$.02.

Rule 303
 
Howdy

Hi straightshooter,
I had a serious shoulder/cuff surgery done in June. It was a tendon torn plum free and repair required a removal of a lot of bone and extra work.
I have seen two very good doctors in the St. Louis area and both expect me to recover but tell me it could be a year. My shoulder is still weak and sore.
Recently I was asked to work up a load for a buddy for a new barrel that was put on his 22-250
Dennis has property that allows him to shoot long distances and likes his loads on the warm side. I ran several different types of powder and bullets up to 60 grains at near max or max out of his medium weight 22-250.
It was noticeable but not too bad. I was shooting from a bench in a t-shirt and fired 50-60 rounds over three days.
I think the combo of hunting clothes and a 22-250 might suit you.
I think Stevie might be on to something too.
Good luck
Mike
 
I'm in a similar situation. Right shoulder shot and my right elbow along with it. I had to change to the left shoulder for long arms. I kept my lever guns and sold the bolt guns. Most of my rifle shooting now is a Smith MP 15 Sport. It works well for me. The only problem was the bad taste of all the crow I had to eat after badmouthing ARs for forty years.:)

If recoil is the only issue, you might want to consider a 260 Rem in an AR platform. I shot one last summer that a friend had put together for his daughter who suffered a neck injury a few years ago and now needs to keep recoil at a very low level. It was built on a DPMS lower with a custom upper with an excellent muzzle brake. I think the break was from Vandenberg Custom. The recoil was about the same as a 223, but the pulse seemed to be spread out over a longer time.

The 260 Rem is a great but seldom encountered cartridge. Recoil in just about any platform is less than a 7-08, yet its performance is very similar.

Just a thought.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Doug627
Obsolete?
2 3
Replies
43
Views
8K
wbraswell
wbraswell
bigmoose
Any Smith collectors into Remingtons also?
2
Replies
24
Views
6K
410bore
410bore
D
Advice on Rifle Reloading Case Prep
Replies
14
Views
7K
Frank46
F
jimmyj
Worst Issued Equipment
2 3
Replies
51
Views
5K
Kavinsky
Kavinsky
PALADIN85020
An interesting gun designer - John D. Pedersen
2
Replies
20
Views
13K
jaymoore
jaymoore

Latest posts

Back
Top