august1410
Member
All this .41 Magnum love........I might have to make my next S&W a .41 Magnum.
SW...nice looking 58 with original stocks...
Shooting reduced loads will help. I have fired very few full 1200+ fps loads from my 58s staying instead with reloads that equal the original Police load of 950 fps...
Bob
SAFireman... Thanks for reply. Have been looking for photo posting sticky but not having any luck. I'm sure the directions are somewhere on the site but when you are computer illiterate finding specific information is tough. I tried searching FAQ but got zip . Used the terms: " posting photos " , " photos " , " photograph " and " photography " and got absolutely nothing in reguards to getting pictures on the site. What am I doing wrong?
Help....gary
I humbly request tentative admission to the 58 club. I would have one, but none are to be had at my current location, which essentially means I simply can't own one, please pity me. However, I have full intention of gaining full membership when I finally move back to the land of the free. After seeing some of the many photos (and with no "like" button), I can't wait for it to happen. Disregard MIM and IL for a moment, and someone tell me what they think of the current "classic" 58 in blue, 4". Whoevever posted that picture of the 58 next to the M10 sold me!!!
Picked up this early one (S259xxx) a couple years ago. Magnas, big hands and full house loads aren't a good combo. Waiting for a warmer day to try out reduced loads. Apologies for photo focus, need a tripod.
![]()
Well, IMHO, a modern M58 is mech better than NO M58... But I recommend trying to find a "S" era if one shows up, followed by a "N" era gun.
Picked up my new girl today.
Its is so clean its amazing it has that turn line. It came from a collection that was clean but all had some turn lines. My guess is that they were owned by a guy that would dry fire shoot at the TV or something like that. The stocks are some of the nicest magnas I have seen.
![]()
In a SHOOTING TIMES magazine article published in the late 1960's or early 1970's, Skeeter Skelton wrote up a discussion of single action versus double action revolvers. There was a photograph included that had the data sheet for a Model 58 with a lineup of cartridges on it. The caption said, "Double-action .41 Mag. S&W M58 is ideal officer's and hunter's handgun. Good calibers for this gun are - left to right - .41 Mag., .45 ACP & AR, .44 Spl., .45 Colt, .38-40 and .44-40."
I always assumed Skeeter took the photo and wrote the caption, as it looks like the other pictures in the article were provided by him, most including him in them holding some of his favorites.
The Model 58 is a very business-looking sixgun, to be sure.
I found mine at Greentop guns near Richmond, Va about '91 or '92 when stationed @ Quantico.
Was a SFPD revolver, so interesting how it ended up on the east coast only to make it back to Socal with me since '93 and now central TX and maybe home state of MT in near future.
A travelin' 58 I call Buford.
Think it cost me $168 or $188.
Above having been said, some of my favorite guns are modified 58's.
My 58-44 is an 1967-ish Model 58 with it's barrel rebored and rifled to .429" The origional cylinder is rechambered to .44 Magnum. I picked it up for a song. It's a rugged companion in the field and shoots moderate loads very well...
![]()
Cast, 242 grain roundnosed, flatpoint by Tennesee Valley Bullets at 900 fps.
![]()
Currently, I am considering the following conversion with Hamilton Bowen which will mate a refinished Model 58 that I paid $300 for last year with a shortened 1955 Target Barrel and a .45 ACP cylinder. (This is Bowen's work. Photo from the internet, but I can't remember where....)
![]()
Oughta make for a perfect fighting revolver....
Drew
Some people always want to argue with me when I suggest the 58 didn't work well for its intended purpose.
I guess I'm wrong. The 58 was the perfect law enforcement weapon. Most officers found its weight a dream to pack. They also found the reach to the trigger to be quite manageable, even by cops with small hands. The recoil was but a mere slap on the palm. That's why it was a raging success, adopted by many, many departments and proved to be the biggest seller in S&W history as it is so versatile as a sporting pistol.
Oh, wait...
I saw that masterpiece in another thread. It belongs to one of our members. It's in .45 Colt I believe.
I picked up a model of 1950 target NOS barrel & cylinder to have my 58 converted to a 3" or 4" .45 Auto Rim. May keep the 58 as is now. The parkerized finish is really growing on me.
What caliber are you going to have yours converted to?
Okay guys, here is your chance....post your photos, stories, and favorite loads for the unloved beast that is the Smith & Wesson Model 58.
I have been a fan since I held one the first time...many months later I finally came to own 2, now I am totally sold on them...how about y'all?
Here are my two, both are first year of production. The blue one gets carried while riding the fence lines, the nickel one is on BBQ detail
![]()
Frizzman
Are you a "Collector or a Shooter". Nothing wrong with being either or, a combination of both.
I have always been a shooter, at my age even more so... There would be some exceptions of course...
I do still have some unfired S&W's I have held in reserve, in case I wear out, or my users get stolen...