Absalom
SWCA Member, Absent Comrade
When you compare adapters, you need to keep in mind that you are dealing with different eras of materials.
Not all things were better quality in the "old days". The last Mershon adapters were produced in the 1950s, and Pachmayr did not make them much beyond the 1970s. Both are simply hard plastic, perfectly servicable but they will crack or splinter when abused. BK adapters are currently made from considerably more contemporary material. And of course the metal of the Tylers is an entirely different story all along.
By the way, there are alternatives to just putting the old-time adapters on a gun and then complaining that they are loose and don't fit.
Quite a few of the old 1940s/50s police revolvers I've bought over the years that came with Mershons or Pachmayrs showed evidence of fitting work by the owner.
See the attached photo for a comparison. The 1947 M&P on the left wears a Mershon which shows whittling or filing marks all around the contact edge with the gun, and fits like it's molded to the gun. No looseness or shifting. The Colt wears a Pachmayr that was obviously just slapped on; it stood off at the toe and actually broke the tip at some point.
Not all things were better quality in the "old days". The last Mershon adapters were produced in the 1950s, and Pachmayr did not make them much beyond the 1970s. Both are simply hard plastic, perfectly servicable but they will crack or splinter when abused. BK adapters are currently made from considerably more contemporary material. And of course the metal of the Tylers is an entirely different story all along.
By the way, there are alternatives to just putting the old-time adapters on a gun and then complaining that they are loose and don't fit.
Quite a few of the old 1940s/50s police revolvers I've bought over the years that came with Mershons or Pachmayrs showed evidence of fitting work by the owner.
See the attached photo for a comparison. The 1947 M&P on the left wears a Mershon which shows whittling or filing marks all around the contact edge with the gun, and fits like it's molded to the gun. No looseness or shifting. The Colt wears a Pachmayr that was obviously just slapped on; it stood off at the toe and actually broke the tip at some point.