What should I do?

Joined
Jan 20, 2021
Messages
7,165
Reaction score
22,113
Location
Portland, OR
This might be long, so bear with me. Growing up, my dad had a .38 M&P. Smiths are in my blood. When the 586 came out, I knew lust. I was a kid and the price was dear. What I was able to afford was a police trade in M15 4". Love that gun and still own it. IMO one of the best revolvers ever.
But I still felt lust. The way you have lust for a girl you used to know, but haven't seen in a long time. Doesn't consume you but you think about it now and then. It was diluted by time and other new guns to yearn for. I can't remember the model but I remember when the unfluted cylinder 629's came out. Lust. Price beyond my means.
I mean, I had the 15. It did everything I wanted it to and was far more accurate than me. The Spokane Police Dept. stamp was a cool touch and a conversation starter. I especially like it when people would see it and then ask me, in a quiet voice while unconsciously backing slightly away, "Uhhmm, where'd you get this?":D
But it wasn't sexy. It had holster wear, it was scratched and beat on. It was a shooter and my woods gun/under my pillow gun/in the saddlebags of my bike gun. I wanted a sexy gun and those damn L-frames are temptresses of the highest order.
Now my available fundage and the presence of an affordable price L-frame haven't connected yet. Still got that itch I never scratched. Like Yolanda from the 7TH grade. Hi, Yolanda!:D
So now I have the available funds earmarked for my sexy spinner. I've even nailed it down to the exact one I want. 686 Plus 3" 3-5-7 edition. Sexy unfluted cylinder, 3" and a RB for good crossdraw woods carry, 7 shots, Adj. sights, stainless for corrosion resistance ( I have the dreaded "rusty fingers"). Everything I need. But I'm having a devil of a time finding one.
So, here's my question. Given my history and the length of time we're talking about, and taking it as a given that things will get back to "normal" and prices and supply will stabilize, Should I wait until it becomes available (at a reasonable price for a current production item) or compromise on a feature or 2.
The cylinder seems to be the real sticking point. I could go with a standard 6 shot or a fixed sight model or a different size barrel, but if sexy's the point?
So what say you, People of Smithdom? Hold out or grab the closest thing to it that's a good deal? thanks for sticking with me.:)
 
Register to hide this ad
If it were me, I'd buy the first decent 686 that was close enough to my idea of perfection, then pounce on the perfect version once it comes along.

You can always sell the compromise gun. ;)

The MSRP on a M686+ and a M686+ 3-5-7 is the same. If you're lust is so deep for the unfluted cylinder and you can afford it why not just get a local FFL to order you a new one from S&W? If they don't have one available I bet they'll put you on a waiting list.

The current crop of 686s on the S&W website all seem to have interesting stocks, 6 different available barrel lengths, and the same price. I'd just get one that's available if you have to have one now.

The unfluted cylinder doesn't move me much.

Hi, Bonnie! (You not the only one with unrequited love although I happen to know where Bonnie lives and that she is way past what I recollect of her from back in the day but, amazingly, so am I!).

Sidebar added - it has to be a 7 shot; 6 rounds is so yesterday in a 686!
 
Last edited:
You can always sell the compromise gun. ;)

The MSRP on a M686+ and a M686+ 3-5-7 is the same. If you're lust is so deep for the unfluted cylinder and you can afford it why not just get a local FFL to order you a new one from S&W? If they don't have one available I bet they'll put you on a waiting list.

The current crop of 686s on the S&W website all seem to have interesting stocks, 6 different available barrel lengths, and the same price. I'd just get one that's available if you have to have one now.

The unfluted cylinder doesn't move me much.

Hi, Bonnie! (You not the only one with unrequited love although I happen to know where Bonnie lives and that she is way past what I recollect of her from back in the day but, amazingly, so am I!).

I asked a couple of places to order me one. They laughed. Told me, "We already have standing orders for everything. Not taking extra orders when we can't get our orders. We'll call you if we get one in, but don't hold your breath."
 
I asked a couple of places to order me one. They laughed. Told me, "We already have standing orders for everything. Not taking extra orders when we can't get our orders. We'll call you if we get one in, but don't hold your breath."

Hmmmmm....why not check in with Classic Firearms online? If you have to wait they might be your best bet. You'll pay full retail, of course.

Maybe there's a local FFL not in a retail shop who can put in the order for you? You'll still wait but at least the order will be in.

Or go onto the WTB Forum here and see if anyone wants to sell one. Presuming you're not fussy about barrel length you might get lucky.
 
Last edited:
I don't know about the gun, but look on Facebook and join your graduating HS class's group page. I'm not sure about you, but at 64, I'm really not interested in the ones I "dated" anymore. Like in the Waylon song, "Where does a slow-movin', once quick-drawin' outlaw have to go?"
ISCS Yoda gave some good advice.
Dang, I really like that song...gonna put the headphones on now!
 
I had a thing for a 4” blued 586 back in the day and twice in the last ten years I’ve grabbed a “good deal” on the 6” version. Sold them both within a year or so. Hold out for the one you really want
 
Like Commander Peter Quincy Taggart said: "Never give up, never surrender!" :cool:
Settling is giving up at a minimum.... surrender (to the market) at worst. :eek:
Stay the course, young Grasshopper. Accept only that which you seek.
 
Several years ago, an older friend of mine confessed his burning desire for a BMW Z4. He lamented that it was an extravagant and frivolous luxury.

I reminded him that he and his wife had raised and put three children through college, that he didn't have a mortgage and could afford this extravagance but, as a depression era child, he just couldn't seem to take that leap. I then told him the story of my Dad, who pined after a 1955-57 Ford Thunderbird. My friend was told that my Dad passed away, rather unexpectedly, a little over one year after he retired but, never got his T-bird.

A week after that discussion, my friend showed up with his brand new Z4.

The morale of the story, of course, is that life is short and the future, no matter how we plan, is unknown. If you can find the 686 you want, buy it ASAP! If you can find one you can "live with", until the unicorn comes along, buy it, shoot it and enjoy the experience! In the blink of an eye, it can change or be gone.
 

Attachments

  • fullsizeoutput_113.jpg
    fullsizeoutput_113.jpg
    69.5 KB · Views: 47
The thrill of the chase is more than half the fun. Personally, when I find a thing I've been chasing after for a while, I feel a little let down that I won't be scouring every dusty corner of the market looking for it.
 
If you go to one of the large online gun auction websites, you'll find at least nine of that exact gun listed. The Smith & Wesson SKU number is 150853, and I'd just search by that number.

Of course, it may not be at the exact price you were hoping for ... just have to ask yourself how badly you want that gun right now.

Mike
 
The problem we are facing at the moment is what is that light we are walking towards in this tunnel.

Is the light at the end of the tunnel?

Or

Is it a light on a train engine coming towards us?

If the light is the end of the tunnel then you should wait for the gun you want. However if it is a train grab watch you can and get off of the tracks. IMO given the current political situation it is a train coming at us.
 
Last edited:
Impatience has landed me multiple guns that were close but not quite the same as the one I really wanted, a 4.25 inch m&p vs a 5 inch, a Rossi instead of a Marlin, a Remington instead of a Colt. You get the picture. Don’t settle. Just wait and get what you want.
David
 
I’ll swim against the tide a little.

I have found that sooner or later (usually sooner) set-aside money gets wasted on things like food, bills, or transmissions.

I’d buy a nice vintage L-frame and enjoy the hell out of it. If the exact Model you’re looking for comes along then you beg, borrow, or steal enough to hold it til you sell your “good enough for now” gun.
 
Don't settle!

I have a 686+ 3" 3-5-7 Talo with the unfluted cylinder!
Worth the wait!
Hold out for the one you really want!
You won't be disappointed!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top