Sig P365. Shield Killer

My theory is that in testing and development they were dealing with a much smaller sample size. Probably a dozen or so.
Then when you release thousands to the public, the flaws quickly surface.

There's that, too. My point was that a test rig does not grip gun like a human. Looking at the number of people who complain of slide bite that I cannot replicate, I can only assume that grip varies greatly. A machine rig does not do that.
 
That's interesting. I wonder if this type of issue is not noticed during development because the guns are mounted on test rigs.

My theory is that in testing and development they were dealing with a much smaller sample size. Probably a dozen or so.
My guess is along the lines of Triggernosis, but that those dozen or so Beta Test subjects were all very experienced shooters that (similar to Hickock45) can pick up almost any handgun and NOT have grip related problems with it.
 
My guess is along the lines of Triggernosis, but that those dozen or so Beta Test subjects were all very experienced shooters that (similar to Hickock45) can pick up almost any handgun and NOT have grip related problems with it.


The p365 has been problematic from the get go, even with experienced shooters. They initially blamed the issues on the weather, the wrong lube and limp-wristing. HickOK45 did have a malfunction on camera, but failed to even mention it, so who knows if he had already experienced others.

Introducing the SIG SAUER P365 - Soldier Systems Daily

Sig Sauer's new P365 11-Round Subcompact EDC Pistol | RECOIL
 
I’ve purchased around 15 handguns in the last 4 years searching for the elusive perfect gun, both ccw and duty size. I think my search is over and my wallet agrees. Duty size sigs are quality but high bore access and chunky. I simply shoot Glocks and M&Ps better. The G43 is too small in the grip although i shot it well. I like the feel of the larger Shield magazine grip and can hide it well. I had all 3 Shield calibers due to the $100 sale plus rebate. I sold the 40 to a cop buddy as a BUG and kept the 45 because it has the same ammo count and I like the impulse bettter, and I shoot it better. I’m keeping the 9 because I’m invested in several holsters, magazine holders and around 8 magazines, and the wife claims it as her own. The P365 sounds good but I’m done searching for the next best thing that comes along. The Shields have a proven record to boot.
 
Last edited:
I saw something similar. This one is having some teething problems. I'm sure they will get it sorted out.

Sig Pausing P365 Production / Osage County Guns Blog
Interesting first tweet last week was

"Again, thanks for everyone’s input and feedback with regards to the P365. There have been isolated incidents of the pistol’s failure to return to battery. Although this can possibly be traced back to a grip issue (whether unlocked wrists or high thumbs), we do not want even rare instances of issues to make our customers lose confidence in the P365. Therefore, we are tweaking the gun to improve RTB conditions. This will help to allow every 365 user to experience what so many have already expressed online in very positive reviews. We are making these adjustments now and will resume shipping very shortly. Thanks again for everyone’s patience."

If it were truly grip issues, why make tweaks?

Then today he issues

"We’re pleased to announce that the P365 has resumed shipping. Thanks to great customer feedback, we were able to make helpful tweaks to the platform. This includes shipping all new P365s with our X-Ray 3™ day/night sights. Owners who are experiencing any issues with their original P365 SIGLITE® sights can contact customer service to have X-Ray 3s shipped to them at no charge. We have also made minor spring adjustments to address isolated incidents of failure to battery (FTB) which are directly related to the off-center/light primer strikes. While we believe some of the FTBs could be the result of varying grip issues, everyone will benefit from this adjustment. Finally, in order to curb the potential of barrel or slide wear in pistols with a tighter tolerance stack, we have made two relief cuts to the barrel. Though this wear is only cosmetic and has been determined by tireless R&D efforts to confirm that it has no relationship with some of the issues experienced, these cuts will minimize most show of wear. SIG SAUER appreciates the excitement around this game-changing pistol, and we look forward to your continued support and helpful feedback."

Hmm, atleast one gun smith in vid above says it was likely contributory.
 
One problem I'm repeatedly seeing come up with reviews by average joes on various forums who have shot the Sig p365 is the slide failing to fully return to battery.



From what I understand that’s traceable to the dreaded “thumbs forward” grip of the modern semi-auto aficionado.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
From what I understand that’s traceable to the dreaded “thumbs forward” grip of the modern semi-auto aficionado.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Asking folk to use different grip styles for different guns? Telling them to change their beer or to stop driving their SUV like a Corvette is probably easier.
 
:cool:j
From what I understand that’s traceable to the dreaded “thumbs forward” grip of the modern semi-auto aficionado.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk


The majority of incidents are actually occurring when chambering a round.
 
Last edited:
Interesting first tweet last week was

"Again, thanks for everyone’s input and feedback with regards to the P365. There have been isolated incidents of the pistol’s failure to return to battery. Although this can possibly be traced back to a grip issue (whether unlocked wrists or high thumbs), we do not want even rare instances of issues to make our customers lose confidence in the P365. Therefore, we are tweaking the gun to improve RTB conditions. This will help to allow every 365 user to experience what so many have already expressed online in very positive reviews. We are making these adjustments now and will resume shipping very shortly. Thanks again for everyone’s patience."

If it were truly grip issues, why make tweaks?

Then today he issues

"We’re pleased to announce that the P365 has resumed shipping. Thanks to great customer feedback, we were able to make helpful tweaks to the platform. This includes shipping all new P365s with our X-Ray 3™ day/night sights. Owners who are experiencing any issues with their original P365 SIGLITE® sights can contact customer service to have X-Ray 3s shipped to them at no charge. We have also made minor spring adjustments to address isolated incidents of failure to battery (FTB) which are directly related to the off-center/light primer strikes. While we believe some of the FTBs could be the result of varying grip issues, everyone will benefit from this adjustment. Finally, in order to curb the potential of barrel or slide wear in pistols with a tighter tolerance stack, we have made two relief cuts to the barrel. Though this wear is only cosmetic and has been determined by tireless R&D efforts to confirm that it has no relationship with some of the issues experienced, these cuts will minimize most show of wear. SIG SAUER appreciates the excitement around this game-changing pistol, and we look forward to your continued support and helpful feedback."

Hmm, atleast one gun smith in vid above says it was likely contributory.

I think what he is not saying is that they have shaved off the sides of the barrel housing where the rounds sits after feeding....(this is where the barrel wear has been showing up)..
so at this point I don't know if that will weaken the barrel or not????????time will tell....plus new recoil spring..?????...

I will not consider this gun until 6 to 8 months after re-release..
If all goes well for 8 months after I will take another look at it...

Not one to jump on new designs or new technology until it proves itself.....Hope it works just perfect....probably be a
good carry gun if it works.....
 
Back
Top