Self-outting poster. You are indeed.
Allow me to reply
He never said anything, ANYTHING, about "train with what you carry". He did say that a BB gun will help with trigger pull and sight alignment. He is correct. You are the one that took his point to absurdity by injecting the comment about him using a BB gun for self defense.
And I reply simply by using your own comments...
You are stuck in the past, and not reading enough. There are BB and airsoft guns that do use compressed air to simulate recoil. While they dont mimic the recoil of a particular firearm 100%, they do it enough. With regards to airsoft weapons and some BB guns, they actually do replicate the controls and the use of them. They do these things well enough that instructors all over the US, including in LEAs, use them for fam-fire and indoor training. They really arent that much different from .22LR conversions, but they are far less expensive to purchase and operate.
That said, the poster you tried to go after didnt mention shooting them to simulate a powder burning, centerfire pistol. He mentioned it as a means to improve sight alignment and trigger pull. While its true that they may not offer a similar trigger pull to firearm, any trigger manipulation is better than none.
Nobody is arguing that. You are merely trying to make an argument that isnt there, or padding your post to make to make it look like it was something of substance. Its not. You can stop now.
Sorry, but I decide when I stop - you don't get to silence people because they disagree. This board isn't part of the cancel culture.
Let me clarify since a lot of what I said apparently went over your head.
My question about the philosophy of "training with what you carry" is in regards to a topic with a long history on this forum. It wasn't a direct reference to anything the other poster said. It was a reference to a universally accepted
principle of self defensive carry. Again, if you read what I said I specifically referred to it as a PRINCIPLE. If you don't know what that word means in this context, I suggest you look it up. Obviously it is a principle that you appear to be unfamiliar with.
The rhetorical question that followed my statement about "training with the gun you are going to use for self defense" is a reference to the fact that training with a BB gun only fits with that
principle IF you plan to use a BB gun for self defense. Obviously no one does - that is what made the question rhetorical. It amazes me that something so simple has to be so exhaustively explained for you to "get" it, but there it is.
The whole theme of what I have been TRYING to get you to understand is that the 8 million new gun owners in this country need to put a significant number of rounds downrange in order to become proficient with their new gun. Especially since the vast majority of them bought their first gun SPECIFICALLY for self defense, because they are concerned about what has been going on across the country. NOT getting that practice means they aren't really prepared and maybe even unsafe. Practicing with a BB gun will improve some fundamentals of marksmanship, but it hardly prepares a person for self defense with a real gun. For that purpose THERE IS NO SUBSTITUTE FOR LIVE FIRE.
These statements are generally universally accepted by anyone who knows which end of the gun a bullet comes out of. Not sure why you have such an issue with what I have been trying to say.
The thing that started the whole discussion is my statement that with the current price of ammo, many new gun owners cannot afford the ammo for the amount of practice and training they need to become proficient. I believe the "scalpers" or "profiteers" or whatever you want to call them are largely responsible for that fact. If that hits too close to home for you, oh well...
BTW I know all about "realistic" airsofts. I have one with the recoiling action you talk about. I'm attaching a couple of photos of it below. It is a full-size replica of a Sig P226 that uses green gas. It weighs about 1/2 to 2/3 as much as the real thing, and the slide reciprocates "just like the real thing" - except that it is nothing like shooting the real thing. The slide is the part that makes it so much lighter than a real gun - it has to be lighter for the gas pressure to make it reciprocate. This one - even being full size - has less recoil than even a 22LR or 25ACP. Plus the trigger has WAY less resistance than a real DA trigger.
So I'm sorry, but I am not convinced that practicing with one of these is sufficient preparation for self defense. Is the trigger and sight alignment practice better than no practice at all? Sure. Is it "realistic" practice/preparation - not even close.