Looking for Sword Information

finesse_r

Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2009
Messages
3,707
Reaction score
6,351
Location
Northeast Texas
Do we have any sword experts, or just someone knowledgeable about swords on the site? I am curious about the possibility of a quality sword along the lines of the Japanese swords used in Kill Bill, but for somewhat less than the million dollars placed on one of those? LOL It would seem there should be someone making a quality sword for a reasonable price. I mean if we are going to prepare for the walking dead, a good sword would be the ticket as a back up weapon.
 
Register to hide this ad
Check out Cold Steel. You can get a catalog from them and it comes with 2 dvds and shows the swords in action. However, they are not made like the Japanese swords, in that they are not hand forged and folded and beaten over and over.

I also think there are "real" Japanese swords imported for a few thousand$$. Cold Steel seem to be pretty strong.
 
Try Museumreplicas.com

I have no experience with their Japanese swords, but I used to own some of their Medieval swords and a Roman gladius, and they seemed deadlier and were probably better quality steel than the originals back then. You could actually special-order them sharpened; don't know if they still do that. But you'll be spending a couple hundred at least, which is appropriate if you look at current quality knife prices.
 
What about a Khukuri? They are cheap, easy to find, easier to carry than a sword or machete, and very effective. Ask a Gurkha.
 
Last edited:
Wilkinson's is out of business, but was functionally replaced by Pooley Sword, formed by workers who were at Wilkinson's for decades. A British history professor whom I know on the Net said the swords are almost identical, to the same official designs. I think the address is www.pooleysword.com

I have handled the Wilkinson cavalry sword, pattern 1908 and the Officers (Infantry) sword, pattern 1897 and was most impressed. The cavalry sword, looking much like the later US Patton sword, is too long for easy use while dismounted. The other is about ideal for me.

You can get both service (brown) and ceremonial (chromed) scabbards. The price is commensurate with the quality, and I think they still quench and temper the blades in whale oil, to prevent breakage in actual war use. The blades flex within specs, if stressed enough. I URGE you to view their site. They make not only official British swords, but others. I think they can supply the USMC officers' sword with Mameluke hilt, similar to those worn by UK Field Marshals.

If you cannot afford these, your best bet is to look at antique dealers for the US Patton sword of WWI. I've seen them in fine condition for a few hundred dollars, and they were made to be used: they weren't toys. Long, like the British M-1908 that they largely copied. On horseback, it won't matter and was preferred for the way they fought.

The arms and armour sites have info on replica swords and my son has a very nice rapier that he had personalized when ordering with gold-filled engraving. He has a Roman cavalry sword (spatha)from the same maker. I've handled it and it's well made, with white bone handle and wood fittings.
These firms make both the Pompeian pattern and the earlier styles typical of Caesar's legions.

I think prices run from some $300-1,000.

The finest single sword that I've seen in some time was a pic on the Net of a Viking sword made by a Finnish master smith. Even the scabbard (leather, probably over wood) had ridges to match the fuller lines on the superb blade. I didn't see a price, but think $10,000-$15,000 would probably buy it. That sword and the maker's other work is absolutely of museum quality.

US Civil War swords occasionally turn up in nice shape. My son has owned a couple of M-1860 Light Cavalry sabers, but sold both when others offered him considerably more than he had in them.

If you want a Japanese style, hunt shows for military issue ones from WWII. I've seen them sell for a few hundred dollars. They are NOT the work of the masters who made the originals hundreds of years ago and who make those in limited quantities now for prices that only Donald Trump and his peers can pay.

Get the annual title, Knives, from the Gun Digest people. They illustrate swords, but I've seen almost none that suggested that the makers knew zip about what they should be building. I doubt if these guys even got to Barnes & Noble and looked for the coffee table sort of books that show real swords through the centuries. That's where you begin. I have such a book that shows the famous mosaic of Alexander at Issus, and the artist showed his sword hilt in surprising detail. Keep in mind that that artist KNEW what the swords looked like then...when he lived!

I checked the URL that I gave above for Pooley Sword. It's correct. If you don't go there and find yourself impressed, I've wasted my time with you. But I think you'll like what you see. Work all the buttons, too. Learning about swords and the historical background is where you begin. Look for books by authors like John Wilkinson-Latham. I've seen a magnificent book, "Swords" for under $30 at B&N. It's my main reference, but I have a couple of other sword books, too.

Unless you are prepared to spend at least $500, I don't think you should be thinking of buying a sword. And you need to read a lot about them first.

But first, get thee to that Pooley site. Nice, eh?
 
Last edited:
Japanese master sword makers have to be apprenticed and have to pass a rigorous tests. Then they are allowed to make and sell a set amount of swords per month. All this is controlled by the Japanese government. Swords that go unsold are sometimes are sold for a lot less as the sword maker also need to make a living.

People have found old handmade Japanese swords in old antique shops around the country. WW2 vets brought home souvenirs of old family swords. Many were 'retrofitted' for military service but are still true to form. If your lucky, you may find an old Japanese officer sword.

There was a video bit about a traditional Taiwanese sword maker. I looked it up on Youtube and found a name Kuo Chang-hsi. He uses human bones to make his swords, sorta like a spiritual element into the sword.
 
For a Katana that is fashioned in the traditional Japanese "folded steel" method, see Bugei Trading Co. (I'll place link below)

Because Japan severely limits how many swordsmiths may operate in Japan, some companies send their swordsmiths to China, where they teach some workers how to forge a folded steel sword, etc...

I bought my sword for 1,200 dollars, a "Dragonfly" model, which is light and designed more for Iaido than for heavy cutting.

They have many different price points, and even have a really affordable line of swords (in the low hundreds, perhaps?) for beginners.

They inspect all their swords before putting them up for sale, and only the highest quality make the cut.....

Check them out: Japanese Swords, Samurai Swords, Samurai Katana, Japanese Wakizashi, Japanese Weapons
 
Do we have any sword experts, or just someone knowledgeable about swords on the site? I am curious about the possibility of a quality sword along the lines of the Japanese swords used in Kill Bill, but for somewhat less than the million dollars placed on one of those? LOL It would seem there should be someone making a quality sword for a reasonable price. I mean if we are going to prepare for the walking dead, a good sword would be the ticket as a back up weapon.

Paul Chen practical katana. They're $220 right now on their website and well made (Paul Chen Hanwei). The blades are the same as the higher dollar ones, they just don't go for authenticity on the rest. Beyond that, you're looking at $800+
 
You should look at Sword Buyers Guide Home

They specialize in ~$300 swords, and have some higher priced ones as well. Plus, they discuss all kinds of things regarding the topic of swords. I would suggest a through-tempered monosteel sword if you are looking for your first one, rather than dropping the big cash on hand-forged/folded differentially tempered steel. Of course, it depends on if you are actually going to be doing any backyard cutting with it or not.

Good swords can be had for reasonable prices, depending on components. Different materials are used for same, such as plastic or real ray skin. Ito (the wrap on the handle or Tsuka) can be anything from rayon, to cotton, to silk. Same with the Sageo (cord wrapped around the scabbard, or Saya). There are so may more parts that go into the making of a Japanese sword.

My one suggestion, and a strong one at that, if to avoid aluminum alloy or 440 stainless steal blades. Those swords are wall-hangers at best.

As mentioned above, you can't go wrong with a Bugei Trading Company sword, but they tend to be higher priced, than say a Cheness piece. http://www.chenessinc.com/
 
Last edited:
You might want to look at handmadeswords.com, as they have some interesting swords in prices ranging from a hundred or so to several thousands. If you want a real Japanese sword, try samuraisword.com.
 
Back
Top