The unavoidable gun fight. Are you confident with your handgun choice?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I've been carrying concealed since 1973 and I am so confident in my shooting ability, I'd be happy to show some lowlife how shooting accurately is important. Being a retired cop, it'll always be in me. I can't stand to see people taken advantage of. Every situation is different and you won't know how exactly you'll react until that moment. The brain puts everything in slow motion, but everything happens within seconds after the decision is made, it's over before you know it. Then one takes pause, shivering, because the adrenaline is still flowing and not ready to slow down. Less than a minute later everything is over. You know you did the right thing, as long as the right people have gone down. Hitting bystanders is a mortal sin, so do nothing if there's a chance of that. Listen to me, most of you know these things, I hope none have to experience it, it'll wake you up at nights. Be safe out there!
 
Interesting thread, especially for me being an Aussie and carrying is not an option here, I haven't read every reply, but i have a few questions and they're pretty general but if you want to satisfy my curiosity or critique my train of thought i appreciate the education, Aus and the USA are very different places despite the maccas and KFC....

So concealed carry, legal where you are (not everywhere i know) but do you have to wear a holster or can you carry in a pocket, handbag etc?
I have seen, on this forum, inside the waist holsters for snubby revolvers etc. but they all seem cumbersome and a quick safe draw might be difficult? especially under pressure?
Would you even try if the villain already has his gun drawn and ready? even if he's pointing it elsewhere?

There is no chance i would pull a gun to defend property, mine or an employers or any one else's, especially if the villain is obviously armed, they can have what they want, it's all replaceable.

Is open carry a thing anywhere? I would think open carry might lead to a larger weapon holstered correctly so therefore easier to access safely and faster?

If i were the customer hiding and was carrying i might definitely be tempted to shoot the villain in the back while he is preoccupied, no problem there, if it ends the threat i wouldn't lose a moments sleep either.

Here in Oz we don't even have castle laws and home invasions do happen, defending yourself in your home can lead to criminal charges, even civil action from the intruder, which is crazy but that's how it is. Having a license and hand guns doesn't allow me to shoot a home invader legally but if the safety my family is at risk the consequences ill be dealt with after, their safety supersedes any law that favours criminals ( And yes, i know by defending my family that makes ME a criminal but by necessity)...
 
Yes, I would be confident with my EDC kit.
I go to the pawn shops in Phoenix all the time. I'll probably be "Looking for a deal" tomorrow afternoon.
My attitude is. If it's my day, it's my day.
I've faced foreign troops, chased armed terrorists into dark alleys and played with IEDs. In the course of those actions. I've lived through a few shoot-outs. I'll tell you, I sure wish most where over quickly and limited to 10 rounds. I'd have a lot more brothers to call on the holidays. All this experience has given me situational awareness x10. I can spot a bad guy almost instantly. Once I do, I never take my eyes off them or anyone they talk to.
Stay alert! Stay alive!

~Certainly there is no hunting like the hunting of man and those who have hunted armed men long enough and liked it, never really care for anything else thereafter.~
Ernest Hemingway
 
People eaten up with concealed carry live and breathe these "what if" imaginary situations. That's unrealistic extremism, far beyond reasonable preparedness.
What Rock said. My additional $0.02? Read too many threads like this and you won't leave the house without an infantry rifle platoon and close air support.
 
Forget the concealed carry situation. Your reference is the most terrifying thing in this thread ;) . Serpico, the man who served, got shot, risked life and limb in his service and then after a single one night stand, lost over 90% of his pension that he worked so hard for.

I will definitely take getting shot, please :ROFLMAO:.

Regarding concealed carry and this topic... Again. Sometimes it is what you don't plan for that gets you. In fact, your Serpico reference makes a lot of sense that way. He was well equipped and survived all the bad guys, but who would have known that in the end, his life's work would be taken by his lack of preparation in love, not in war?
Sad tale but true!
 
There was a guy who is no longer with us who used to post here frequently under the name 18DA1.

He claimed to have investigated over 200 homicides in his career and I don't have any reason whatsoever to doubt him. One of the most common things I heard him say (or read him saying) was "You will run out of time before you run out of bullets". He said it over and over and over again. He said every time this discussion came up.

As stated previously, He investigated over 200 homicides and again no reason to doubt him. I may not get this exactly right but I'm pretty sure he said only one that he investigated went over 10 Rounds fired by all parties involved. That one he said the victim was actually dead by the second shot and the guy that shot him stood over the corpse and emptied his magazine into it.

I've never been in a gun fight but I've witnessed four of them. Of the four none of them lasted longer than 30 seconds and I'm almost positive none of them went over 10 Rounds.

I predominantly carry a glock 19 and 2 reloads or Glock 26 and one reload depending on how I'm dressed. So 45 rounds or 27 rounds (12 round magazine in the 26 and a 15 round reload).

The only thing I'm "confident" of is that I'm going to run out of time before I run out of ammunition
Perhaps the most relevant comment on here. Most of the homicides I investigated were one shot gun fights. At least only one dead guy and he did not get a shot off.

A robbery where you are a witness is not a gun fight. It is, you are a witness. And if they start the killing process, you are the key witness. There is no issue of protecting somebody's money, it is surviving that next 1 or 2 seconds. That's it.
 
This is an incident that happened in a Pawn Shop I was in a few weeks ago. It just as likely could have happened at any store you entered. There's only one way out. Take out the shooter or die. Are you confident and proficient with your carry choice to get out alive?

To give a summary based on the article, it sounds like the shooter entered the pawn shop & fired a round into the air. The armed clerk working the counter grabbed his gun to engage the shooter and was killed. Some shopper who was in the store hiding after the shooting started was shot in the head as the shooter left with some stolen guns. The shooter and getaway driver were later arrested and charged with murder.

New details about moments before, after deadly shooting at Tucson pawn shop

As I mentioned, I was in this Pawn shop a few weeks ago looking at guns. It isn't in the nicest area, but most Pawn shops aren't. And Pawn shops in my area, do have some good deals on used handguns. But this could have happened in any business. When you come through the door of this place, to the left is the gun counter. So, this is going to put you in the corner of the store and your back to the door. You probably wouldn't know what was happening until you heard a shot and turned around. I don't know if anyone else was in this shop during the shooting, but it doesn't sound like it. Every time I've been there, they've had at least two people working. Maybe someone went to lunch?

This is one of those situations where you can't avoid a gun fight. Do nothing, and you're still shot in the head. Sure, stay out of bad neighborhoods and pawn shops. But as I stated, this could have happened in any store. The chances of this situation are slim, but I missed it by a few weeks, so you never know. And this is why we carry.

And now it comes down to your carry choice. I know a lot of people like their small low cap pocket carry guns. But if you were in this situation, do you feel confident and proficient with your choice of carry gun? Situations like this really make you think and evaluate your carry choice, training, mindset, & tactics.
Hopefully you can view this video. It happened some years ago in my town, not far from here. I have discussed this with the owner and wondered about his training. I figured he was a retired leo or military but he is neither. He is a firearm instructor and didn't hesitate to defend himself and his staff. Two men are seen coming into the store. When the first guy decides to pull out another gun (because 1 gun and his friend with a shotgun wasn't enough smh) the owner makes his move. Killing the first before he hits the ground, as the other disappeared never to be seen again. The owner said he's been robbed before and his shop damaged by vandals and such. He expressed he didn't want to shoot anybody but wasn't gonna let someone kill him without a fight. Crazy times.
 

Attachments

The Statistics show (as was proven at this incident) that the majority of people who are killed in a robbery are those that tried to resist. I think too that once you spook the criminal they start shooting at everyone that gets in their way when they leave in a hurry.

The clerk not only succeeded in getting himself killed but also an innocent bystander as well simply because he chose money over life and decided to shoot it out. We still do not know if the bullet that killed the bystander actually came from the clerks gun or the criminals gun in a deliberate act or an accidental stray bullet from either gun that killed the bystander.

Although your chances are higher that you will be struck by lightning than be involved in a robbery by a criminal in a store the best route is not to engage in a gun battle but to take cover and only shoot it out if the criminal comes looking for you. Again highly unlikely considering the fact that the criminal wants the money and then wants to get away as soon as possible and not waste his time to go looking for other people to shoot.

Remember also that when the bullets start flying you can be sued if any innocent bystander is injured or killed in the crossfire which is highly likely in the confines of a crowded store as few stores are completely empty at any one time.

And even more strange but true is that if you succeed in wounding or killing the criminal, especially if he has only a knife his relatives can sue you for wrongful death or injury even though the criminal was clearly committing a crime at the time you shot him. You will probably win in the lawsuit but it will still cost you thousands for a lawyer and thousands more on the time off of work lost.

I might add that even Wyatt Earp and his Brothers were taken to court over the shoot out at the OK corral and that was during the days of the wild west when courts and juries were much more lenient towards Officers engaged in a shootout. If Wyatt and his brothers had not been law enforcement officers they just may have gone to prison over the shootout at the OK Corral. If the shootout had happened today in 2025 at the OK Corral the peace officers may have been sent to prison over an unjustified and/or illegal confrontation.

Some tips before going into a high crime area are always look at the cars in the parking lot. If you see a car parked backwards its a red signal that a criminal is planning a robbery and quick getaway by not having to back his car out of the parking lot.

If you see a lot of stickers plastered all over the store window blocking your view to the inside of the store be very cautious on entering the store because you will not be able to see a robbery that is now taking place and you just may walk smack dab into a robbery taking place.

And of course you must ask yourself the question "Is it really worth going into a store in the bad section of town" because the more you frequent such a store in a high crime area the higher the chances that someday you will walk in on a robbery in progress or be caught inside the store when a robbery goes down. Is looking for a "good deal" really worth getting your head blown off. We are not living in the country of even our Fathers let alone our Grandfathers, it's a different world out there today.

Again although its very unlikely you will ever be involved in such a shootout situation why take chances when you do not have to. I long ago quite going to a pawn shop in a town where once even my Grandfather and Father used to frequent and the pawn shop in question even stopped selling guns there. It's the current reality on how we are forced to live.
Perfect example of what not to so when the s*it is hitting the fan. Thinking about lawsuits and court costs while becoming involved in a lethal confrontation will get you killed every time.
 
This is an incident that happened in a Pawn Shop I was in a few weeks ago. It just as likely could have happened at any store you entered. There's only one way out. Take out the shooter or die. Are you confident and proficient with your carry choice to get out alive?

To give a summary based on the article, it sounds like the shooter entered the pawn shop & fired a round into the air. The armed clerk working the counter grabbed his gun to engage the shooter and was killed. Some shopper who was in the store hiding after the shooting started was shot in the head as the shooter left with some stolen guns. The shooter and getaway driver were later arrested and charged with murder.

New details about moments before, after deadly shooting at Tucson pawn shop

As I mentioned, I was in this Pawn shop a few weeks ago looking at guns. It isn't in the nicest area, but most Pawn shops aren't. And Pawn shops in my area, do have some good deals on used handguns. But this could have happened in any business. When you come through the door of this place, to the left is the gun counter. So, this is going to put you in the corner of the store and your back to the door. You probably wouldn't know what was happening until you heard a shot and turned around. I don't know if anyone else was in this shop during the shooting, but it doesn't sound like it. Every time I've been there, they've had at least two people working. Maybe someone went to lunch?

This is one of those situations where you can't avoid a gun fight. Do nothing, and you're still shot in the head. Sure, stay out of bad neighborhoods and pawn shops. But as I stated, this could have happened in any store. The chances of this situation are slim, but I missed it by a few weeks, so you never know. And this is why we carry.

And now it comes down to your carry choice. I know a lot of people like their small low cap pocket carry guns. But if you were in this situation, do you feel confident and proficient with your choice of carry gun? Situations like this really make you think and evaluate your carry choice, training, mindset, & tactics.
Several years ago an attempted robbery at a pawn shop in Omaha didn't end well for the would be robber.. The pawn shop employees had practice such an event and responded with appropriate force and ended the threat without injury. It appears they spread out to different locations in the small shop where firearms had been deployed just for the kind of event. I suggested that kind of planning at the range I worked at and with a couple simple signals we were put on alert.
 
Jeez, Rambo, I ain't saying go meekly into the dark night, I'm pointing out that E&E + shoot if they come at you is the best answer. My comment was mostly directed at the young man working at a drug-troubled KFC…nothing worth shooting someone over in that context except yourself.
Anyone can sneak up on anyone and commit violence ,there's no sure thing , if a cop armed with the best 10mm on his hip is in line at the deli at lunchtime any goblin with any deadly weapon can take him out. My pocket 357 j frame is my edc i have alot more stuff but I believe the 3/3/3 rule and the odds say im correct that being aware and ready able and willing is the most important thing for the average person.
 
He said "may be" the go signal, I believe. So, perhaps there's something worth reading in his argument.
You saying that "defenders are behind the 8 ball and the go signal for people being after the criminal has already shot at you" is the perfect example of a gun carrier having their head up their ass, and is the definition of ZERO situational awareness. Why do you carry if you're that unaware of people around you?
How about plain old practical, non-tactical, and more meaningful "observant" instead of the stiff-collared, classroom gunfighting theory term "situational awareness"?
 
My mentality is different than most of you when I'm out and about. I think like a criminal because that's what I dealt with during my career. I'm ALWAYS aware of my surroundings and will see the criminal before they see me. Therefore I don't worry about being surprised. My ffl pickup spot is a local pawn shop, so I'm always watching the door anyway. I've also been in gunfights, so been there, done that. Shooting somebody that was trying to shoot at me was way easier than anybody led us to believe at the academy. Bottom line guys, if it's them or you dead, you better be cold blooded and make sure it's them.
I'm pretty aware of my surroundings when I'm out and about, but given the large variety of shapes/sizes/flavors that criminals come in, I'm not at all confident in my "universal criminal detection ability." Sure, sketchy looking hood-rat/meth-head/gang-banger types would earn some closer scrutiny and concern, but there are plenty of criminals that look just like an ordinary dude walking down the street.

What's your secret that results in you always seeing criminals before they see you?
 
The Statistics show (as was proven at this incident) that the majority of people who are killed in a robbery are those that tried to resist. I think too that once you spook the criminal they start shooting at everyone that gets in their way when they leave in a hurry.

The clerk not only succeeded in getting himself killed but also an innocent bystander as well simply because he chose money over life and decided to shoot it out. We still do not know if the bullet that killed the bystander actually came from the clerks gun or the criminals gun in a deliberate act or an accidental stray bullet from either gun that killed the bystander.

Although your chances are higher that you will be struck by lightning than be involved in a robbery by a criminal in a store the best route is not to engage in a gun battle but to take cover and only shoot it out if the criminal comes looking for you. Again highly unlikely considering the fact that the criminal wants the money and then wants to get away as soon as possible and not waste his time to go looking for other people to shoot.

Remember also that when the bullets start flying you can be sued if any innocent bystander is injured or killed in the crossfire which is highly likely in the confines of a crowded store as few stores are completely empty at any one time.

And even more strange but true is that if you succeed in wounding or killing the criminal, especially if he has only a knife his relatives can sue you for wrongful death or injury even though the criminal was clearly committing a crime at the time you shot him. You will probably win in the lawsuit but it will still cost you thousands for a lawyer and thousands more on the time off of work lost.

I might add that even Wyatt Earp and his Brothers were taken to court over the shoot out at the OK corral and that was during the days of the wild west when courts and juries were much more lenient towards Officers engaged in a shootout. If Wyatt and his brothers had not been law enforcement officers they just may have gone to prison over the shootout at the OK Corral. If the shootout had happened today in 2025 at the OK Corral the peace officers may have been sent to prison over an unjustified and/or illegal confrontation.

Some tips before going into a high crime area are always look at the cars in the parking lot. If you see a car parked backwards its a red signal that a criminal is planning a robbery and quick getaway by not having to back his car out of the parking lot.

If you see a lot of stickers plastered all over the store window blocking your view to the inside of the store be very cautious on entering the store because you will not be able to see a robbery that is now taking place and you just may walk smack dab into a robbery taking place.

And of course you must ask yourself the question "Is it really worth going into a store in the bad section of town" because the more you frequent such a store in a high crime area the higher the chances that someday you will walk in on a robbery in progress or be caught inside the store when a robbery goes down. Is looking for a "good deal" really worth getting your head blown off. We are not living in the country of even our Fathers let alone our Grandfathers, it's a different world out there today.

Again although its very unlikely you will ever be involved in such a shootout situation why take chances when you do not have to. I long ago quite going to a pawn shop in a town where once even my Grandfather and Father used to frequent and the pawn shop in question even stopped selling guns there. It's the current reality on how we are forced to live.
I don't know about your AO, but in mine, it's pretty normal to see 30% or more cars that are backed into parking spots. It's a pretty common way for people to park, and in the vast majority of situations, it's certainly not a criminal planning a quick getaway from a robbery.
 
I don't know about your AO, but in mine, it's pretty normal to see 30% or more cars that are backed into parking spots. It's a pretty common way for people to park, and in the vast majority of situations, it's certainly not a criminal planning a quick getaway from a robbery.
Most folks at my church back in to park as it makes leaving after services less likely to cause a lot get-together, but hey, I'm Methodist, so it's hard to be sure.

Oddly enough, my first murder investigation 40+ years ago was 11 shots in the decedent; my last was 5 shots in the decedent. There were many variants in between simply because human behaviors are enormously variable.
 
Last edited:
A robbery where you are a witness is not a gun fight. It is, you are a witness. And if they start the killing process, you are the key witness. There is no issue of protecting somebody's money, it is surviving that next 1 or 2 seconds. That's it.
One of two men convicted and sentenced to death for an infamous 1980 takeover robbery and massacre inside a Los Angeles Bob's Big Boy restaurant, in which employees and customers were herded into a freezer and shot in the back, has begun legal efforts to have his prison sentence reduced, which could allow the once-condemned prisoner to be released on parole.

Choose wisely comes to mind.
 
What's your secret that results in you always seeing criminals before they see you?
For me 50+ years experience catching criminals.

But unusual activity should stand out. Two men on bicycles looking into cars with a flashlight at 5 am are not looking for a job.

Stranger knocking on the front door at 10 am is really just checking to see if anyone is home.
 
I'm confused - what does having a manual safety have to do with your friend getting shot?
Being sleepy, etc. I use what I am most familiar with (1911 style safeties). Also, had a friend killed in high school when he came home late and his dad unloaded on him. The safety is just an added layer of safety. Also, less likelihood of an accidental discharge in times of stress. Just my opinion. But, it's my life and how I want to protect it.
 
That is unfortunate.

I think now is the time I would like to say thank you to all of our LEO's. If you are a bank clerk and you have an 'off day' at work, you might have to apologise and recount the stack of bills that a client gave you. As a cop? A bad day could get you and those around you hurt or worse.
We had a liquor store near us that got robbed a couple of times a month: easy access and egress from the site. Two guys hit it one night and two L.A. Sheriffs responded. A total of 60 shots were fired and no one was hit except one perp was hit in the hand. They escaped over a 6 food cinder block fence and through a back yard to the next street where perp #3 had the get away car. Sheriffs got the wounded guy later at the hospital!
 
Josey Wales:
Now remember, things look bad and it looks like you're not gonna make it, then you gotta get mean. I mean plumb, mad-dog mean. 'Cause if you lose your head and you give up then you neither live nor win. That's just the way it is.
 
I'm pretty aware of my surroundings when I'm out and about, but given the large variety of shapes/sizes/flavors that criminals come in, I'm not at all confident in my "universal criminal detection ability." Sure, sketchy looking hood-rat/meth-head/gang-banger types would earn some closer scrutiny and concern, but there are plenty of criminals that look just like an ordinary dude walking down the street.

What's your secret that results in you always seeing criminals before they see you?
They target focus on the prey. Watch a cat before the pounce. It's the same principle. Criminals look for weakness in the prey before the attack.
 
One of two men convicted and sentenced to death for an infamous 1980 takeover robbery and massacre inside a Los Angeles Bob's Big Boy restaurant, in which employees and customers were herded into a freezer and shot in the back, has begun legal efforts to have his prison sentence reduced, which could allow the once-condemned prisoner to be released on parole.

Choose wisely comes to mind.
Choose wisely about what?
 
I don't really understand all this. I'm a Marine! Was taught to shoot M1s & 45s when I was in the single didgits by my father & uncles who were WW2 vets, including 2 at Normandy, 82AB, & landing at several major battles in the Pacific. "All" my contemporaries were taught to fight, shoot, protect the weak etc. So, we were always going towards trouble even as kids. As a Marine we were, of course, taught to go towards fire & had pretty good training to do it. As a Officer, same thing. To this day - every where I go - I'm looking for the bad guy & am ready to go to the trouble. As to carry; I taught small arms etc in the military & civilians. For civilians, you have them carry what they can shoot well & know how to fix/clear problems. For most women its a 38 revolver. KISS! Now I carry whatever is going to work for what I'm wearing or where I'm going. My go to guns are .45 autos, 45 revolver, 357 revolvers. I would also carry a 44Mag if I had one of the Smith light weights. But... that's me. I think shooting a .454 Casull one handed is no problem. Others can't proficiently shoot mags, so carry what you shoot good. All the above is well & good, but if "YOU" can't deliver while under duress or fire, your in deep squat. For me (and those that want my help), I have a tactical range set up in my woods so you can run & gun. Shooting at 6/8" rounds, squares & small to large man size. 2 together to practice hostages, next to trees, in the brush, etc. And the preponderance of this shooting is point shooting within 5yds or line of sight look over, with aimed for more distance work. Nothing much past 10yds. Also do the 5-25yd target stuff for them to learn proper aim if needed. But it all comes down to: Practice like it is real! Do it a lot, get muscle memory & be able to put them in the heart locker & head. Practice doing multiples, 2 in the chest, 1 in the head etc, 2, 3 even 4 bad guys with reloads. The thing is, if you haven't been to war/gunfights, the mindset to do it, is the determining factor. So, rounds down range until it's instinctive & when you see the bad guy with the gun/knife, it's on autopilot. fwiw
 
Almost the exact scenario happened to one of the guys on my department I retired from. He's still there as a Captain now. He was hired in 98 or 99 and left a gun shop with his duty gun and ammo he purchased for the police academy he was leaving for just a day or 2 later.

He was walking to his car and saw a car pull up and 2 or 3 black guys exit and walk into the gun store. Something about them gave him a bad vibe, so he wrote the car plate down and drove off. He was contacted by detectives while at the academy within the next 2 days about the double murder and stolen guns at the gun store he was in. His name was in the paperwork because of the gun he had just purchased.

He gave them the info of the dudes and the car they were in and then when the detectives made arrests however many days later, he had to leave the police academy for the physical lineups to see if he could identify them.

After they were charged, one of them a few years later before the trial wanted to have our cop killed so he wouldn't testify at the trial. They even had his name and address on some paperwork found at the jail he was sitting in. It was some wild **** back in the late 90's.
 
They even had his name and address on some paperwork found at the jail he was sitting in.

Defense Atty's are really good at not redacting that info. on the Police report copy they give their clients who are usually in custody.
 
I'm pretty aware of my surroundings when I'm out and about, but given the large variety of shapes/sizes/flavors that criminals come in, I'm not at all confident in my "universal criminal detection ability." Sure, sketchy looking hood-rat/meth-head/gang-banger types would earn some closer scrutiny and concern, but there are plenty of criminals that look just like an ordinary dude walking down the street.

What's your secret that results in you always seeing criminals before they see you?
Ya if I decided to go into a life of crime and rob people the very first thing I would buy is some nice suits,

then some campaign posters
 
For me 50+ years experience catching criminals.

But unusual activity should stand out. Two men on bicycles looking into cars with a flashlight at 5 am are not looking for a job.

Stranger knocking on the front door at 10 am is really just checking to see if anyone is home.
I was mainly addressing the following statement of the poster that I responded to:

I'm ALWAYS aware of my surroundings and will see the criminal before they see me.

I understand unusual, sketchy activity. But what about criminals who don't look anything out of the ordinary, and aren't doing anything out of the ordinary?
 
Forget the concealed carry situation. Your reference is the most terrifying thing in this thread ;) . Serpico, the man who served, got shot, risked life and limb in his service and then after a single one night stand, lost over 90% of his pension that he worked so hard for.

I will definitely take getting shot, please :ROFLMAO:.

Regarding concealed carry and this topic... Again. Sometimes it is what you don't plan for that gets you. In fact, your Serpico reference makes a lot of sense that way. He was well equipped and survived all the bad guys, but who would have known that in the end, his life's work would be taken by his lack of preparation in love, not in war?
The fact that you take getting shot so lightly means that you have never been shot before. I have been twice and I can guarantee you that if the choice was losing a pension or getting shot, I would be living pension less on the street or in a tent out in the woods. I survived twice, on what suddenly became battlefields because there were brave medics handy and the people that were shooting at me were bad shots.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Back
Top