Thanks for all the great input, hope you enjoyed the thread. I decided to buy neither... today I bought a 442 no lock, unfired, box papers with Crossbreed Supertuck, Don Hume IWB and Don Hume pancake holsters. 150 rounds of high quality defense ammo... $400 for the works. I think she will be pleased with the revolver, and she has shot my J frames enough to know that she will do fine with it.
