WHY BUY A GLOCK 19 WHEN YOU CAN GET A MUCH BETTER GUN WALTHER PPQ?

bigmatt17073 · Oct 14, 2014

$80 price difference on the prices the OP showed between the PPQ and the Glock 19. With a little bit of money and a little work you can have a much better trigger in the Glock easily. All of my Glocks have gotten a $.25 polish job and a minus/3.5lb connector and that is the end of the trigger job. My M&P Shield on the other hand needed an $90 Apex kit to make it an acceptable trigger for me.

And with the money saved over the PPQ then buy some extra mags or more ammo.

diyj98 · Oct 14, 2014

marathonrunner said:
The PPQ right out of the box comes with a match barrel...

More and more companies are starting to toss out that "match barrel" term. I'm not sure everyone's definition of "match barrel" is the same.

Hohopelli · Oct 14, 2014

Bologna I believe is the term.. Or is it just Baloney..

Muss Muggins · Oct 14, 2014

Two things:

1: I don't know anyone who owns a PPQ. I'd never heard of it until this thread.

2: Nobody saw fit to post a picture of a PPQ on this thread.

rwsmith · Oct 14, 2014

One thing that would make me think...

I shoot lead a lot more nowadays, so the traditional rifling of the PPQ wins over the Glock's polygonal rifling.

Also, the Walther should be good to go right out of the box, but if you can do the work on the Glock yourself, what the hey?

Dezfan · Oct 14, 2014

The "_________" is way better than a Glock.

I see it on every firearm board I'm a member of.

And whatever "it" is, it's always compared to the Glock.

I think that says it all.

Jessie · Oct 15, 2014

I'll keep my 19. I know it works and don't care if it gets scuffed up.

John R · Oct 15, 2014

Jessie said:
I'll keep my 19. I know it works and don't care if it gets scuffed up.

I agree, and it's hard to make an ugly gun any uglier.

xfarfuldog · Oct 29, 2014

PPQ

I purchased a used PPQ for $ 425 a couple of months ago. Already owned a VP9 and a G19. PPQ trigger is excellent as is the HK. Glock is more combat proven. I love all 3 (as well as my 4 Smith and 2 Colt revolvers).

vipermd · Oct 29, 2014

OP: You are playing in plastic, go to a Browning Hi-Power, SS, 40 SW and see where that compares to the plastics. Be Safe,

Arik · Oct 29, 2014

vipermd said:
OP: You are playing in plastic, go to a Browning Hi-Power, SS, 40 SW and see where that compares to the plastics. Be Safe,

Lol. Yea I'd like to see a Hipower outlive a Glock in reliability

G-Mac · Oct 29, 2014

I sold my Glock 19 and bought an S&W 3913. I don't even want to know what a Walther PPQ is.

watercop · Oct 29, 2014

God I have to add my 2 cent. I own a G19 and a G30. Get that out of the way first.
I have a good assortment of S&W and a couple Ruger's.
It seems to my many guy's and girls' after getting their Glock stat changing it, slide release, mag release , trigger, well you get the point.
Owning a Glock is like owning a Honda Civic or Toyota Corolla, they work and they are ugly. Walther's are dishwasher safe.

kmyers · Oct 29, 2014

Get what you like and want. We have a PPQ here and the grip and trigger pull is superior to the 2 Glocks I have had for 10 plus years. We also recently got a H&K VP9. The Walther has probably 4000 rounds with no issues and the VP9 probably 1000 also with no problems. Both are nice pistols that shoot very well.

k80clay · Oct 29, 2014

Glocks are not target pistols. Were never meant to be. Saying the trigger sucks is like wondering why your minivan can't clock 175mph.

The Glock does what it was meant to done it does it superbly. If you REALLY need it, you're not going to care what the trigger is like. All you'll want is for it to work.

And for those who talk about Glocks being modified by their owners and the 1911 is the "ultimate" pistol; I have to laugh. The 1911 has been modified over the past 100 years, and unless you're shooting a true 1911 with the useless tiny sights, high unflared ejection port, no finger reliefs, tiny manual safety, spur grip safety that won't feed anything but 230gr hardball, you don't have any room to talk.

I have 1911s, S&W 3rd gens, Hi Powers, even a 357 Blackhawk. What lives in the nightstand? Glock. Period.

bnipper · Oct 29, 2014

Glock VS ?

Can one gun fit all the needs for personal defense or concealed carry? I like my S&W 351C, and my Colt LW Commander and my Gen 2 Glock 19. Do I use all three, yes and I train with all three.

marathonrunner · Nov 28, 2014

agreed

Rpg said:
Marathonrunner:

You're missing the ultimate handgun : the Colt 1911.

Get a real Colt 1911: preferably a series '70.

Put 1000 rounds down range after you've done a training course.

Then get a Colt Commander (the Commander is the light weight, the Combat Commander has a steel frame )

Finally, once you've mastered the 1911, get a j frame (my favorite is the old M38.

Learn to shoot it.

You'll be selling many of your Tupperware guns.

Just my opinion, of course.

I did shoot a 1911 style gun pretty darn well at 75feet. Even my match grade Glock 34 with barstow barrel could not come close

marathonrunner · Nov 28, 2014

ruger

Biggfoot44 said:
You're on a forum of SMITH & WESSON afficianados , looking for support of a Glock over a Walther ? My head spins.

Stand by over on the Ruger Forum to tout the relative track record of the latest Tarus over the Springfield XD.

alot of people I know who bought Rugers had so many problems with them> Kind of like he volkswagon of guns

Dezfan · Nov 29, 2014

marathonrunner said:
alot of people I know who bought Rugers had so many problems with them> Kind of like he volkswagon of guns

Yeah, Smith has never had an issue with any of their releases.

Fanboys.

schgsd · Nov 29, 2014

Steyr Mannlicher.

S-A1, C-A1, M-A1, L-A1. What Glock could have been.
Created by a former employee of Glock, Wilhelm Bubits took the A1 design to Steyr. The M was released in 1999 and the others followed. So a design with some time in the field, made by a longstanding reputable name.

Anyone who grabs onto my L9-A1 says wow.

A recent article detailed some very nasty financial shenanigans that Gaston has done to family members. I won't own one.

WHY BUY A GLOCK 19 WHEN YOU CAN GET A MUCH BETTER GUN WALTHER PPQ?

bigmatt17073

Member

diyj98

Member

Hohopelli

Member

Muss Muggins

rwsmith

Dezfan

Member

Jessie

US Veteran

John R

Member

xfarfuldog

Member

vipermd

Absent Comrade

Arik

Member

G-Mac

watercop

kmyers

k80clay

Member

bnipper

Member

marathonrunner

Member

marathonrunner

Member

Dezfan

Member

schgsd

Member

Attachments

Similar threads

Latest posts