Completely disappointed by S&W

Wolf1775

Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2014
Messages
96
Reaction score
44
Location
New Castle, PA
Yes, I understand where I am and what forum this is, and for that reason I figure maybe, just maybe, someone at S&W might be able to do something useful and helpful.

-----------------------------

Based on my father’s experience with S&W, I later obtained an M&P40 for the purposes of home and personal defense due to S&W’s reputation of reliability and service as well.

I enjoyed the M&P40 thoroughly due to its ergonomics, accuracy, low felt recoil, and reliability. It fit my hand significantly better than the Beretta M9 that my unit issues to me, and was much smoother shooting as well. This made it great for the purposes of personal and home defense, and doubled as a competition pistol with local USPSA and IDPA matches. It has served each purpose well with easily over 2,000 rounds through it until recently when it began to show issues with reliability by giving light strikes on primers.

I checked the springs and thought maybe it was just a weak spring that had gone bad from wear. I replaced the sear spring, made sure that the trigger bar and springs to that were in working order, and checked to make sure there wasn't anything that was out of place or put backwards.

At this point, the only two things that weren't factory parts were the APEX sear and front sight post. The only things replaced were springs and a trigger bar with factory parts. Still gave the same exact issues.

I contacted S&W’s customer support on September 10, 2013 regarding this issue and received a reply on September 16, 2013 requesting more information regarding the nature of the problems found with the firearm and the firearm itself. I sent in the information and made sure to note everything about the pistol to include the issues with it and which parts I had replaced with other factory parts.

After responding with the information requested I received no further reply. It wasn’t until calling the customer support number on September 27, 2013 and waiting for over 20 minutes that I was able to find out that the shipping label was never sent to me. I finally received a shipping label to have the firearm sent to S&W on September 30, 2013.

The firearm was shipped on October 2, 2013 and received two days later. I was told that there would be a wait time of approximately 4 weeks, and that I would be contacted if there were any issues. I waited until November 15, 2013 and called the customer service number again, and was told that the firearm was being held and would not be worked on until the billing department received a reply from me due to not being covered by the warranty as the second owner of the pistol. However, no letter or bill had been sent to me between when my firearm was sent in and when I called.

I was later sent a letter with a list of charges, and given the option to service the firearm at the fee charged, or have it returned. The work being charged would be to replace the striker, replace the aftermarket sear, and range testing for a total of $130.54. The parts would only have cost $9, the testing would cost $45, and the labor would cost $63. The striker and the sear, however, are drop in parts that can be swapped/replaced within minutes. I replied in early December, well before the Christmas and New Year’s holidays, stating that I wanted the firearm returned and included my billing information for any necessary charges.

By January 2, 2014 I saw no charges to my account and had not received my firearm. I called the customer service number and waited approximately 45 minutes before receiving a response. The customer service representative, Jason, was unable to provide an answer as to why there were no charges and why I had not received my firearm yet, but he stated that he did not think that I would be charged for return shipping or initial testing, and would call me back by the following Monday, January 6, 2014. I received no phone call.

I sent a letter out by mail on Thursday, January 9th and waited until Wednesday, January 14 before calling the customer service number. When I got an answer from a representative I was reassured that S&W did have my pistol, it was in the "returns" department, but for some reason it was stuck in the system and hasn't been processed to be sent back. He said he would send a runner to find the answer and either he or the runner would get back to me today.

Honestly, I'm not holding my breath waiting for that phone call.

Now the reason I was told I wasn't covered under warranty is because I'm the second owner. Fine, I can handle that. What I'm severely disappointed and disgusted with is that I started asking S&W for help in September and I didn't get much in the way of support until my third email and phone call. And the response I got was a "yes, we can help."

The pistol has been in S&W's possession since October 4, 2013 and no one has contacted me about a single damn thing regarding it. I've received no calls, emails, or letters showing I'd owe them any amount of money for service or asking what I want to do. I've received no calls back from them when they said they would. I still have no answer on why my pistol has sat around and nothing has been done.

So at this point, I want my pistol back so I can just get the parts online and have a gunsmith take care of it locally. It'd be faster and cheaper than what S&W would be able to offer, and I wouldn't feel like a company just lost or stole my gun.

And I don't care what charges may apply at this point; I think the company can swallow them after this horrible service.
 
Register to hide this ad
Conversely, I think Smith & Wesson is pretty great. This is quite the dichotomy. Maybe it was something you said to them? Or possibly the way you phrased it.
 
Honestly, I thought S&W was great as well. Hell, I even named one of my German Shepherds after them. This, however, is the complete opposite of how I thought they'd treat someone who owns one of their firearms.

I haven't sworn at anyone, I've been civil, and I've been honest with them. And so far, I've just been ignored.
 
Wolf1775. When you get a brake job at a local garage do you buy all the parts and take them to the garage for installation? So whats in it for the garage business? Just sayin'.
 
Wolf1775. When you get a brake job at a local garage do you buy all the parts and take them to the garage for installation? So whats in it for the garage business? Just sayin'.

You're missing the point.

S&W said they'd contact me if there was an issue of if they needed to send me a bill. They didn't do that, and it took over a month of waiting and a phone call before someone remembered to do that. When I got the bill I opted not to deal with it because that would have been another 6-8 weeks of waiting, so I told them to send it back. That was before Thanksgiving of last year.

They've had the gun since October 4, 2013. It is now the middle of January 2014 and S&W can't give me answer as to what the status is, whether it's going to be shipped out to me, or what the issue was.

I would have been fine being charged the testing fee if it had been sent back after they received my letter saying to send it back. But they've held on to it, and no one can tell me what the issue is. I think charging me for forgetting about me would be insult to injury now.
 
I sympathize with your situation, but a couple of things you should consider:

1) As the second owner, you are not covered by a warranty.
2) By replacing parts, you would have invalidated the warranty, had it existed (although S&W has been known to overlook that, depending on the circumstances.)

So, in hindsight, as a owner of a gun that isn't covered by warranty, perhaps it would have been better to take it to a local gun smith in the first place. (I'm sure this comment is a lot of help.) This is why I like to buy either new guns, to get the factory support, or 1911s which can be supported by almost any gun smith.

It's not fair to you that they have had your gun this long, and their tracking/communication has been poor at best. There is really no excuse for that.

I have had generally good experiences with S&W, with the one exception being an issue I had over not receiving rebate magazines (when they were offering them.) That dragged on for a year, before it got resolved.

Where I fault S&W is that they don't have any executive escalation program in effect. It is impossible to get their corporate officers' information online, unlike many other major corporations. When I was trying to get my magazines, I finally found the name of a VP of Finance at an affiliate company (one of S&W's holdings) and sent her an e-mail, figuring I had nothing to lose...she actually contacted the S&W CEO's office and guess what...I had my mags within a week, plus two extra. That should have never been necessary.
 
I'm a big fan of S&W and have had very good luck with returns. I do however understand the frustration you are having right now. Sorry, it sux but it happens once in a while everywhere. I this had happened to me I would be reading the Ruger forum right now.
 
Wolf1775: I don't know if this will make you feel better or not but I dealt with S&W customer service today and I had a bad experience so your not alone.
 
Wolf1775. You said,"So at this point I want my pistol back so I can just get the parts online and have a gunsmith take care of it locally." That action is not helpful in obtaining a good service relationship.
 
I think.....

I think I would have put the original parts back in and tried the gun that way. If it didn't work then I'd contact S&W with the simple complaint of 'light striker hits'. This doesn't sound like much but S&W would have to see the fault was with the gun and not the modifications. It would also simplify communication.

Last year S&W was telling customers that there were very long wait times on repairs because they concentrate on warranties.

I agree that you have waited plenty long and was treated somewhat shabbily as far as communication goes but it's common knowledge that they are in up to their gills.
 
How did S&W know he was the second owner? Was the gun sent in before by the previous owner? That is the only way I can think of how S&W would know.

James
 
Yes, I understand where I am and what forum this is, and for that reason I figure maybe, just maybe, someone at S&W might be able to do something useful and helpful.


Welcome to the Forum.


I'd like to direct your attention to the bottom of your screen.
If you scroll ALL the way down you will see this message posted:
© S-W Forum, LLC 2000-2013
Smith-WessonForum.com is not affiliated with Smith & Wesson Holding Corporation (NASDAQ Global Select: SWHC)

This board is privately owned and is not affiliated with Smith & Wesson, nor is there any formal factory presence/representation here.

I'd direct all further complaints to them. ;)
I'm sure you already have their phone number.
 
Last edited:
I actually told S&W I was not the original owner in the first few emails. I didn't expect the warranty to hold to begin with, and I'd rather be honest about it all so I can know from the start whether or not they can help me. When I was told yes, I expected to get charged.

What I didn't expect was not to be contacted about anything and paperwork regarding the firearm to be forgotten about. That's where the majority of my frustration comes from.

I finally got a message back today stating that they found the gun and that it was with the "charge" department. It was all done, sitting in a tub waiting to be shipped over to the mail room to be sent out. So far it seems like there won't be any charges applied, which is good. However, this entire ordeal has left a very bad impression of the company.

A good working relationship would involve communication on both ends, not just one. Forgetting to send out letters or returning calls does not make for a good working relationship.

Also, yes, I've sent in emails, phone calls, and mailed a letter as well.
 
Last edited:
How did S&W know he was the second owner? Was the gun sent in before by the previous owner? That is the only way I can think of how S&W would know.

As the OP mentions below, he told S&W. Another possibility is that many new gun owners "register" their guns by serial number with S&W. I always do, when I buy a new S&W...so, the serial number could be on file with a different owner name. That doesn't mean S&W actually checks...but I'm just mentioning it as a possibility.
 
Disappointment with S&W - Epilogue

So I hear a knock at my front door and my dogs go ballistic. I check who it is and find the FedEx driver standing on my front porch with a package from S&W for me. I sign for it and immediately open it.

My pistol case is dirty, but intact so no big deal. I open the case and find my pistol wrapped in brown paper, the mags I sent it in with, and some paperwork. I strip down the pistol and inspect it. It's the same striker assembly I sent it in with, and it doesn't look like they swapped out the sear either. I take a q-tip and run it over the surfaces. There's a little powder residue and very little (almost no) oil, so it seems to have been fired and given a once over.

I check the paperwork and am left bewildered. My name is on it, and the shipping slip has my serial number, but the two page long work order is for building a custom 1911.

So from Oct 4, 2013 to Jan 20, 2014 nothing was done but maybe a test fire. S&W forgot about paperwork and phone calls, mixed up paperwork, and barely touched the gun. Not even a note in response to emails, phone calls, and a written letter. Classy.

And somewhere, someone will get a 1911 with M&P paperwork and say "whiskey tango foxtrot?"

At least I got my pistol back. Now to fix it and get it running like it used to, then trade it for an XDm.
 
At first I thought it was the striker spring. Then maybe the striker plunger. Or the ammo. Possibly the striker assembly? Well, after replacing springs and testing the same ammo with other pistols it looked like the striker assembly, but I wanted to see if S&W could figure it out since they have more technical knowledge. So I contacted them, and then the rest is in this thread...

Full story
 
After you received back from S&W, and test fired it, what problems did you continue to experience?

Larry
 
Back
Top