engraving hurt the value ?

M

muzzlestuffer2012

Member
Joined
Feb 24, 2022
Messages
306
Reaction score
183
does factory engraving hurt the value if the factory does it after the gun is purchased ? and does it matter what gun it is ? thinking about having my 617 engraved nothing too fancy but was curious thanks for the input.
MS
 
Register to hide this ad
Done right, I don't think so. But after you get all this done, are you planning on selling it anyhow?
 
Don't plan on selling especially if I have it engraved not laser but real engraving they are sending me the catalog since it's a 617 no dash 22 lr I'm thinking a small game type of deal maybe a squirrel or bunny with some oak leaves and acorns any thoughts or should I stick to the scrolls only ?
MS

Sent from my SM-T813 using Tapatalk
 
mtgianni said:
If you ever do decide to sell it might not recover the cost for a while.
Like custom homes, generally those who can afford them want their own custom home.
Click to expand...
Well if it's anything like home costs now a days I should make a boat load pretty quick !

Sent from my SM-T813 using Tapatalk
 
"hurts the value" is kind of a subjective term, my opinion (this is only my opinion and you know what we all say about that....) is that it greatly reduces the number of people that may seriously consider buying it but among that smaller group of buyers it increases the price they would be willing to offer....
does that make any sense...?
 
I would guess if you have the work done by a known skilled artisan, and you keep proof of the work being done by said engraver, that you would break even or increase the value of the gun.

As far as what engraving should go on the gun, all of what you suggested sounds fine but you should get what you like. A Cape buffalo may look a little odd, however. :)
 
Have it engraved.

The road you will need to take to get it done 'your way' will be an invaluable lesson.

You will put a lot of time in the research of an engraver that will meet your expectations.

You will then collaborate on what you want done, the engraver's opinions, their skill level, and, agreements to get this all accomplished.

Weighing in on top of all that is the cost to have it completed.

A lot of people throw their two cents in about 'recovering costs'.

That's not something to even consider on a project this personal.

Don't let that interrupt your thought process on having a 'one of a kind' piece of art fabricated just for you.

If your ultimate goal is to sell it, down the road, then have it engraved in the 'cookie cutter' fashion. Pick a 'look' from catalogs and books and follow what's already been done.

If you truly want something unique to you then have it engraved your way so that you may cherish it forever.

I sincerely hope you get it engraved. You will have something to be proud of.

bdGreen
 
I say get it engraved. That way, it's unique, it's special, and if it does tank the value, then that just gives you an excuse to hold onto it, thus preventing you from selling it in a moment of weakness or financial difficulty, and ensuring that it will remain a family heirloom rather than get pawned off somewhere down the line by some unsentimental descendant who would trade in a piece of his family heritage for money.
 
Thanks for the input guys the only bad thing about engraving is it ties your gun up for months. When I have anything built I have it engraved just something about a engraved anything it becomes a piece of art as well as a gun or whatever it is.now if my gun will show up I can at least shoot it looks like probably early next week I'll send some pics.
MS

Sent from my SM-T813 using Tapatalk
 
muzzlestuffer2012 said:
Don't plan on selling especially if I have it engraved not laser but real engraving they are sending me the catalog since it's a 617 no dash 22 lr I'm thinking a small game type of deal maybe a squirrel or bunny with some oak leaves and acorns any thoughts or should I stick to the scrolls only ?
MS
Click to expand...

Get what you like. Engraving is something that should speak to you... something that makes your gun a one-of-a-kind family treasure. It is not inexpensive, but in my opinion, if done right, it is well worth it.:cool:

Go for it and good luck,
 
muzzlestuffer2012 said:
Don't plan on selling especially if I have it engraved not laser but real engraving they are sending me the catalog since it's a 617 no dash 22 lr I'm thinking a small game type of deal maybe a squirrel or bunny with some oak leaves and acorns any thoughts or should I stick to the scrolls only ?
MS

Sent from my SM-T813 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...

That type of engraving wouldn't hurt the value to me. But a number of years ago I went to look at a Python and a shotgun (I can't remember the model) that had been engraved. The owner had his name and a various biblical quotes engraved on both guns. He thought the value of the guns should be increased by at least the cost of the engraving. He got mad when I told him that having his name engraved on the guns decreased the value to me.
 
I don't have any traditionally engraved firearms, but of the ones I have seen I like the ones that are partially engraved better than the fully engraved ones, they seem to be just show guns.

I have a 617 that I personalized myself, I don't care about resale value because I plan on shooting it until I can't shoot any more and then pass it on to the grand-kids. Also I bought it cheap because the side plate was scratched, I polished out the scratch and added my logo with my CNC machine with a diamond drag bit.

I think if the engraving gives you enjoyment then that's all that matters, I've enjoyed showing off my 617.

roQLPJD.jpg

P6E3gcT.jpg
 
So my question is why engraving after it left the factory not considered as a refinish, since it would be getting re blued after the engraving.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

gr8smiles
‘Cowboys and Indians’…aka Engraving meets the Wild West
Replies
11
Views
936
gmanofsteel
G
DoubleDelta
Model 29 Nickel Engraving
Replies
3
Views
487
22hipower
22hipower
G
S&W 49 Factory Engraved Value
Replies
2
Views
387
Eddietruett
E
D
24-3 6.5” value
Replies
6
Views
353
DEF3
D
Messer
629-1 with scope cuts value?
Replies
7
Views
595
steelslaver
steelslaver

Latest posts

Back
Top