What to do with two 64 3" revolvers?

And you are asking this question to a bunch of S&W enablers???

Finding not one but two in such a short time? Perhaps a lottery ticket is in your future....

Randy
Trust me, I've got two bucks in my pocket and it may be time to play! I recognize the logic in asking enablers and honestly I've been pleasantly surprised that a couple of people have suggested to sell one!

Sent from my Pixel 3a XL using Tapatalk
 
I have to apply my K38 philosophy here ... you can never have too many! Keep both, especially if it is a model that you carry! I don't subscribe to the NY reload philosophy (partly because I live in a may issue state). Having a replacement model of what you carry is beneficial in the event of a shoot and your primary carry is seized. I am not fond of DAO in a revolver, since you never know when you may need to fire a precision shot.

In summary, I would say keep it!

your seized gun could be incarcerated for 3 months (personal experience) and having that spare is a blessing
 
"Should I sell one or keep them both"
We should all have such hard choices to make.
 
Shoot the pee pee out of the newer one. Give that one a DAO hammer if you want. Baby the older one. It will be an investment. They aren't getting any cheaper.

[ame="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2HnzHPLTRZg"]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2HnzHPLTRZg[/ame]
 
My first inclination would be to keep both. Can't go wrong with 2 k frames in your carry rotation or in your range bag. But maybe consider trading one toward another gun you don't have. For instance maybe trade one for a true k-snub with a shorter barrel. Or trade one for a 15/67 with a 4 inch barrel, which would be a better range gun IMO. Good luck, those are 2 nice .38s you have there.
 
So far I like the baby one, abuse one mentality! Imagine that, a gun accumulator asks for help to a bunch of gun instigators for help and the outcome is to keep both. Shocking! I think the newer one will get a makeover; new shoes, lose the Hilary hole, and likely a DAO hammer and spring upgrade. It will serve well as my shooter/carry gun/truck gun. Maybe I'll sell my Sig P320 X Compact instead as I'm still not sold on carrying gun with that light of a trigger and no external safety. Thanks everyone! I know it can be annoying for someone to post a thread like this, and I have read/participated in a few like this before with annoyance. The good news is there are still deals out there waiting to be found! Cheers!!

Sent from my Pixel 3a XL using Tapatalk
 
I actually took two Model 64s to the range today. The plan was to run about 100 shot shells through a new Kel-Tec KS7, but problems with that shotgun, requiring return to KT, left me with lots of time and only a little bit of ammo.

I had packed two boxes of PPU 158gr SWCHP ammo in the range bag, along with the 3" Centerfire Systems 64-8 and a 4" 64-8 that I had picked up cheap from a local toy store. Now I wish that I had packed more ammo.

Both 64s are solid performers. All rounds fired double action, what nice triggers. I think that my 64 no dash cried a little bit at being left in the safe today, and that the other gals are probably teasing her after they got their baths and were put away.
 
I actually took two Model 64s to the range today. The plan was to run about 100 shot shells through a new Kel-Tec KS7, but problems with that shotgun, requiring return to KT, left me with lots of time and only a little bit of ammo.

I had packed two boxes of PPU 158gr SWCHP ammo in the range bag, along with the 3" Centerfire Systems 64-8 and a 4" 64-8 that I had picked up cheap from a local toy store. Now I wish that I had packed more ammo.

Both 64s are solid performers. All rounds fired double action, what nice triggers. I think that my 64 no dash cried a little bit at being left in the safe today, and that the other gals are probably teasing her after they got their baths and were put away.
The model 64 is my favorite out of all the Smith revolvers that I have owned and currently own. I love shooting six rounds at a time as the range ammo lasts longer and I shoot smarter. I've had a no dash 64 before and between the 3" and the pencil barrels they are my favorite as they balance very nicely. Sorry to hear about the keltec, I recently watched a YouTube review where they too had to stop shooting and send it back in to the factory (much to their disappointment).

Sent from my Pixel 3a XL using Tapatalk
 
Keep them both! The more the merrier.
View attachment 397006

Exactly... Two is one, and one is none is reason number 1 to have two of the same. A NewYork reload is something I do all the time with a pair of matching and identical (except one is blued and one nickel) M36's...they are set up the same way, handle the exact same way and have the same method of operation and manual of arms. Lastly, another good reason to have two of the same exact model (I've known several cops that do this), one to train with and gets the heavy range use, and one that has been vetted but has a low relative round count so it will always run/be in the best shape when needed. These are all good reasons to have two of the same exact gun/model. Sometimes you just need to think outside the box!

Obligatory Pic of my New York "Crew"...
pC4jxBU.jpg
 
I was in your shoes several weeks ago with m38's.
I ended up selling one a bought a sweet m15.
 

Attachments

  • 3798982F-3E44-4CCA-A797-E25C25A5276F.jpg
    3798982F-3E44-4CCA-A797-E25C25A5276F.jpg
    44.9 KB · Views: 18
I can't think of a better use for that IL model than to extract the IL and have that revolver made into a dedicated DAO shooter with the hammer bobbed off nice and smoothly. Would be hard to find a better EDC or bedside or truck gun or what ever else you need it for if you like a six shooter. You already said this model is your maybe favorite one. And they are both 3 inchers! Best of all worlds in my books!

I'm guessing you don't have a ton invested in both of them together, so I'd spend a bit more for a good gunsmith (if you can't do it yourself) to make the action into a DAO only one with a great trigger and keep both of them. I'll bet you might have another handgun that you could sell that you don't use much or has no real attachment to you to finance the conversion plus buy some more ammo to shoot through the Model 64's. One to shoot the snot out of and one waiting in the wings just in case that stuff happens that sometimes does (but ain't very likely!). Two of these equals two great guns, and that's two more than a lot of guys would love to have one of if they could find them!!!
 
Choices, Choices...

I would put the pre-lock in the safe and use the one with the lock with hammer intact. I tend to buy two of everything. One to use and one for a spare. Good luck in your choice. tom.
 
Back
Top