How big a problem could this have been?

Interesting thread, and responses.

Since I first came to this forum, It was quickly evident this was a place to learn. From pretty basic questions about my 686, to beginning reloading. (In my case, pecking away at the kitchen table with a Lee loader.) I've been reloading for several years now. This forum makes me truly grateful for members such as venomballistics with his concise advice and know-how. He, and others, have helped me.

Now I seem to know a little more about the 9x18 Makarov.

But maybe it's just me, or maybe it's just too close to Christmas, to endure a lecture, as the one just above.

Yup. I see this syndrome occasionally in other threads and other forums. I think the result is to discourage people, especially new shooters, from asking what may be considered by some ignorant questions. I have also learned a lot from this forum and we should make an effort to be gentle in our responses.
 
I'll take some more clearer pictures and try to remove the bullet. I didn't deliberately distort the picture, just pulled out my phone and snapped the pic while removing the ammo.
 
I've shot a few thousand rounds of FM 9mm remans( and 223 ) with zero problems. Curious to see what comes of this.
 
image_zpsqfjih3jt.jpeg


image_zpsqf2roaz8.jpg


image_zpsobewd7ye.jpg


image_zpsyupe5vdr.jpg


image_zps1dsfyxv1.jpg
 
Last edited:
On a side note I don't think Freedomunitions makes 9x18 Makarov.
 
Wow, the better photos tell the story. Sure looks like it's clearly pushed in to me. I've seen this a couple times when I didn't crimp a round well enough.

Anyhow. I wonder how many rounds do this when they slam into the feed ramp. If it's a light load, would we just experience a little sharper recoil and a "flyer" and never think anything of it?
 
Interesting. Ammoload brass has the step inside that's "supposed" to prevent just this scenario (setback). I guess not!
 
Most of you people are really something! Incapable of looking at the OPs photo and seeing that the center cartridge is, a with a near 100% certainty, a 9mm Makarov, not a 9mm Parabellum with a deep seated bullet! Look at the ogive, completely different that the others. Bullet is full diameter at the case mouth instead of showing a gap as it would be if it were the same bullet seated this deep. Case is shorter, hard to tell just how much but it sure isn't a 9x19. If OP had done two things, aligned the cartridges so they were all the same distance from the camera instead of angled away to the right side so there is some perspective acting on the image, and taken the shot level instead of looking down at an angle which distorts the case lengths and reduces the length difference! Deliberate? I don't know, but it could very well be, just to see what sort of silly responses the distorted photo would engender! Sure worked if that is what happened. Question for OP, did you happen to look at the headstamp on the odd cartridge? What does it say?

What would have happened if he had tried to fire it in his 9mm? Absolutely nothing! The larger bullet would have increased pressure over what would be expected from a 9x19, but nowhere to standard pressure of 9x19. Case mouth is nominally .004" larger than 9x19, but not enough to wedge the case in a normal 9x19 chamber. Most likely thing that would happen is an under-recoil and no ejection. In other words, a simple stoppage. Hardly the disaster that at least one poster flat stated would result in a blown-up gun! Give me a break.
Wow! Feeling a little out of sorts today are we? :D

From the additional info and better photos, it looks like this one has all the telltales you describe for a bullet pushed in too far - including the gap between the case mouth and ogive of the bullet.

Please forgive me saying so, and I hope you don't get upset for my saying it, but I think there may be a little helping of crow with your name on it ;)
 
Last edited:
As Speed2 stated, the problem is probably not enough tension between the bullet and the case. If it's reloaded brass the problem could just be the original brass. My suggestion would be to put some thumb pressure on the rest of them to make sure the bullets are tight in the case.

I rarely buy factory ammo but the suggestion above to check each round of factory ammo is a good one. It seems every time I read a gun rag there is an advertisement for an amoo recall by a major ammo manufacturer. Another reason I make my own. I think when we reload we (or least I do) double check each step of the operation. When you buy factory too often you assume it's 100% perfect. Mass production might be 99.99% perfect but that would mean 1 in 10,000 rounds is defective.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top